Obama has made criminals the centerpiece of his immigration enforcement strategy - just like Trump wants to do.

Trump echoes Obama in plans to deport 'criminal' immigrants

Trump echoes Obama in plans to deport 'criminal' immigrants

Immigrants can be deported for a host of violations - including the act of crossing the border. So is Trump proposing anything new?

Obama has made criminals the centerpiece of his immigration enforcement...
Obama has made criminals the centerpiece of his immigration enforcement strategy - just like Trump wants to do.

Donald Trump's campaign has sent conflicting signals about his immigration policy in recent days, but on one point it’s stayed the course: the need to deport immigrants who are “criminals.”

During a town hall Tuesday, Trump said that he is open to "softening" laws dealing with undocumented immigrants. His pivot on the issue came after a meeting with Hispanic leaders Saturday, when he told them that he plans to release a new immigration policy that could include legalizing some undocumented immigrants.

But on Fox News Monday, Trump reiterated his as yet unspecified plan to zero in on criminal immigrants. "The first thing we're gonna do, if and when I win, is we're gonna get rid of all the bad ones," he said. Meanwhile, his campaign has spoken of the need for tougher border security - including Trump's wall - and enforcement of immigration laws.

Lee esta nota en español

But what sort of crimes might Trump be referring to? Experts say defining “criminal immigrants” is problematic, in part because of the range of crimes that can trigger deportation - including the simple act of entering the country.

Targeting criminals for deportation

While Trump has continued to rail against so-called criminal immigrants, in reality the Obama administration has already made this the centerpiece of its enforcement approach. Immigration authorities must prioritize those who committed felonies, three or more misdemeanors, and significant misdemeanors for deportation, among other infractions, as detailed in a Department of Homeland Security memo.


"We’re going to keep focusing enforcement resources on actual threats to our security," Obama said when he announced the policy in November 2014. "Felons, not families. Criminals, not children. Gang members, not a mom who’s working hard to provide for her kids."

But that doesn't always work in practice: most deportation cases don't involve serious crimes. From October 2015 to July 2016, 84% of deportation cases in the courts stemmed from immigration violations, according to the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC).

And even if immigrants get detained by police without getting charged, such as for a traffic violation, they still risk deportation. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) can ask jails to keep undocumented immigrants in custody to transfer them to immigration detention centers - and then potentially deport them. About half of ICE requests for jails to hold immigrants are for people without criminal records, TRAC found.

Immigration advocates have criticized the current administration for targeting immigrants without serious criminal records and dubbed Obama as the " deporter-in-chief" since his administration has deported more immigrants than any other president.

"We don't have to wait for President Trump as the 'Deportation Force' is already in action," wrote prominent immigration attorney Matthew Kolken on his blog.

What is a "criminal" immigrant?

"It's something politicians and government officials tend to bounce around," said César García Hernández, a law professor at the University of Denver and the author of the Crimmigration blog. "Other than the political symbolism of that rhetoric, it's a term that's largely meaningless."

One reason is that the number of deportable offenses has grown since the mid-1980s under federal legislation.

"There's an enormous range of criminal activity that can result in deportation - everything from jumping a turnstile in the New York City subway system to the most serious of crimes," said García Hernández. "Most [immigrants] who we're seeing throughout the Obama administration being targeted for criminal activity are folks who are not murderers and rapists; they're people engaged in much more ordinary criminal activity, including things like immigration offenses."

That's because some immigration violations are considered crimes under federal law. For example, if a non-citizen crosses the border without going through an inspection with authorities, he can be charged with a misdemeanor. Illegal reentry - crossing the border without inspection after being deported - is a felony.

A law for Mexicans

Congress first made immigration a crime in 1929. Five years earlier, in 1924, an immigration act was passed that explicitly sought to keep the United States “white” through a stringent national origins quota system. But the law exempted people from the Western Hemisphere from the quota system and a record number of Mexican immigrants entered the United States to work on farm lands. As a result, in 1929, South Carolina senator and white supremacist Coleman Livingston Blease introduced a legislative compromise: Mexican workers could come and go, but the federal government would ensure they went home, through criminalizing unlawful entry. Immigration law and criminal law were effectively fused.


“That was the first law to criminalize immigration, intentionally designed to control Mexican migration to the United States,” says UCLA history professor Kelly Lytle Hernandez. “And that’s the same law that is still in effect today when we talk about criminal entry into the U.S.”

The 1929 law passed legislation to turn crossing the border into a misdemeanor, and crossing the border after deportation a felony.

Why words matter in the immigration debate

Just using the term "criminal" to describe immigrants is problematic, some immigration advocates say. "The fact is that the vast majority of immigrants are not 'criminals' in any meaningful sense of the word," explains a 2015 American Immigration Council report on the criminalization of immigration.

"Those wholesale labels are not helpful," said Avideh Moussavian, a policy attorney at the National Immigration Law Center in Washington, DC. "It's a way of dehumanizing millions of people that are parents, colleagues, neighbors."

And it's precisely this kind of rhetoric that helps shape how Americans feel about immigration, according to Karthick Ramakrishnan, a professor of public policy and political science at the University of California, Riverside. He co-authored the forthcoming book "Framing Immigrants" from the Russell Sage Foundation, which analyzes how the media covers immigration and how the public's views change as a result.

Through a series of surveys since 2007, he and fellow researchers found that people exposed to media framing immigrants as lawbreakers become less amenable to legalization and more likely to favor deportation.


"When you look at the discourse and people's perception of reality, the crime statistics seem to be less important than these claims or even just these adjectives that are repeated time and again," said Ramakrishnan. "Study after study has shown that immigrants are much less likely to commit crimes than the native-born population."

Indeed, perception may be the key to understanding Trump’s about-turn on immigration. The appearance of his softening may appeal to independents who are on the fence about voting for him, while his hardline base still expects him to strictly enforce immigration laws.

When he launched his presidential campaign in June last year, Trump made a direct link between immigration and crime. "When Mexico sends its people they’re not sending their best,” he said. “They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists, and some, I assume, are good people.”

Lytle Hernandez, the UCLA historian, calls it “code talk.” Trump has “decoded what other people have often said in much more complicated ways,” she says.

Donald Trump obtuvo esta semana los niveles más bajos de aprobación desd...
Trump says he's not flip-flopping on immigration
Trump is set to lay out his immigration plan next week. His campaign manager Kellyanne Conway said it is "to be determined" whether Trump’s immigration plan will include a "deportation force" as previously promised.
Mario Rodríguez, head of the Hispanic 100 group in California, and Jovit...
Trump now says he plans to legalize some undocumented immigrants
Sources tell Univision that Trump plans to announce a major shift on immigration policy next week. The Republican candidate met Saturday with Hispanic leaders who said he told them he regrets prior comments about Mexicans.
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rall...
In latest hedge Trump says immigration laws can be softened
Trump confirms Univision reports that if elected he may not deport all undocumented immigrants as previously promised.
On November 15, days before the allegations of sexual harassment against Charlie Rose came to light, the CNN International host issued a public call to editors and executives to end the abuse and sexual harassment in the media. That evening, Rose, who is being replaced by Amanpour on an interim basis, was sitting only a few feet away as she spoke.
The Colombian soldier Mauricio Calvo shares his experience as part of a burgeoning industry of men who travel the world to fight in other people's wars.
Angela King went from being a Neonazi skinhead to working to lure people out of hate groups. Today, King says she’s worried about what she sees as an increase of hate and a U.S. president who refuses to publicly denounce it. She has a unique insight into the most effective ways to respond to incidences of hate and extremism, and why people are in the life in the first place.
Through tears, Joaquín Ramírez recalls the minutes after a gunman entered a Baptist church in Sutherland Springs, Texas, and fired at everyone in his path.
When Rodrigo Duterte was sworn in as Philippines’ president in June 2016, he declared a war on drug traffickers and users. Since then, Human Rights groups estimate more than 12,000 people have been killed in this offensive they call "a war on the poor." Univision News traveled to Manila and witnessed this conflict first hand.
Pedro is one of thousands of undocumented immigrants who work in chicken processing plants in Gainesville, Georgia. In a county where police work in tandem with immigration authorities and more than 72% of citizens voted for Donald Trump, many immigrants live in fear.
They grew up in Chicago and their husbands, the Flores twins (aka ‘Los Mellizos’), worked for the Sinaloa cartel. The twins later became DEA informants in Mexico who helped bring down El Chapo Guzman. They have written a book, Cartel Wives, telling their story as a lesson to others not to fall for the narco life, and they regret what they put their families through. "Our fathers put on their suit of armor and their badge, and they are going out there on the streets of Chicago,” Mia confesses. “It’s the very same streets that our husbands were flooding with drugs.”
Patients with chronic diseases are getting limited treatment in health centers and are still waiting for restoration of power and water supply. Univision News visited several hospitals.
The 1998 hurricane killed 11,000 people in Honduras and Nicaragua and left more than a million homeless. As a result, the United States granted temporary visas to citizens from those countries who were living illegally in the U.S.
Presidents don't usually pardon criminals until they have been sentenced or have at least expressed some regret, but this was not the case with Arpaio, who spoke to Univision News two weeks after being forgiven by his ally, Donald Trump.
The weather station in Key West, Florida, is sending weather balloons into the atmosphere to measure the powerful category 5 hurricane, which currently has winds of 175 miles per hour.
The Trump administration on Tuesday rescinded the DACA program that President Barack Obama introduced to protect the young undocumented immigrants known as Dreamers. Sessions said the program would be phased out over six months to allow Congress time to have another go at passing legislation.
Two brothers graduated from Harvard and Middlebury. They grew up in Houston and are practicing Christians. "Like "good Americans," they like Taco Bell. They have lived most of their lives in the United States and have a simple request for the president: "Do not get rid of DACA."
During a meeting in the Oval office Friday, the president was asked by reporters about the future of DACA, to which he responded that a decision was coming soon. "We love the dreamers, we love everyone," he added.
Nilsa Huete is an undocumented Honduran immigrant living in Key West, Florida. In the last five months, five of her family members have been arrested by agents from the Monroe County Sheriff's Office. Now she’s fighting against the deportation of her daughter and brother.
The former Arizona sheriff pardoned by President Trump is one of the most unpopular figures in the Hispanic community. For 24 years he was sheriff of the fourth largest county in the country and was convicted in July 2017 of ignoring a court order to stop his officers from racial profiling of Hispanics.
Ilia Calderón: "Para mí es un privilegio poder acompañar en este crecimiento a la comunidad hispana"
Ilia Calderón, la nueva copresentadora del noticiero nacional de Univison, habla de cómo llegó a la televisión y cómo hace historia convirtiéndose en la primera afrolatina en presentar un noticiero de habla hispana en Estados Unidos y en su país, Colombia.
Vicepresidenta del Senado de Florida explica los proyectos legislativos para el 2018
Anitere Flores habla sobre las leyes que fueron aprobadas en el año 2017 y lo que se puede esperar para 2018 en cuanto a educación, salarios a los maestros, los estragos de los huracanes y cómo prevenirlos, y el transporte.
Polémica por aprobación de un cobro extra de la FPL a sus usuarios para proyecto de limpieza
La Comisión de Servicios Públicos aprobó que la FPL cobre más de 200 millones de dólares a sus usuarios, que serían invertidos en un proyecto para limpiar la contaminación en los canales de enfriamiento de la planta nuclear Turkey Point.
Analista republicana defiende al presidente Trump de las acusaciones de acoso sexual
El Congreso ha pedido una investigación sobre las denuncias de acoso sexual que han hecho varias mujeres contra el mandatario, antes de convertirse en presidente. Cada partido analiza la situación.
La crisis de Honduras amenaza con regresarla a su imagen de "república bananera"
Tres semanas después de una elección fallida, las protestas callejeras y las acusaciones de fraude han generado dudas sobre cualquier posibilidad de obtener un resultado creíble de las elecciones del 26 de noviembre. La inestabilidad a largo plazo podría generar un aumento en la migración, advierten los analistas.
Este es el programa contra la Mara Salvatrucha que propone el gobernador de Nueva York
Con iniciativas educativas y deportivas después del horario escolar en áreas de riesgo y apoyo a jóvenes inmigrantes susceptibles de unirse a ella, Andrew Cuomo desveló este domingo un programa para su agenda del 2018 que busca atajar el reclutamiento de la MS-13 en Nueva York.
Esta familia de extraficantes de personas cuenta cómo opera esta red en México
La familia Garfias solía dedicarse al tráfico de personas. Ahora, tras pasar más de una década en prisión, rehabilitarse y convertirse en cristianos renacidos cuentan la dura realidad de este negocio.
¿Se pueden utilizar las denuncias de acoso sexual en contra del presidente Donald Trump?
Una analista demócrata y una republicana debaten sobre las acusaciones de acoso y agresión sexual en contra del presidente Donald Trump.
Coutinho guió la goleada del Liverpool al Bournemouth
Con el 4-0 como visitante, el equipo que dirige Jurgen Klopp recuperó la cuarta posición en la Premier League.
Kaká anuncia su retiro del fútbol a los 35 años
El brasileño que brillara con el Milán y Real Madrid anunció mediante las redes sociales su retiro de las canchas como profesional.
Kaká anuncia su retiro del fútbol a los 35 años
El brasileño que brillara con el Milán y Real Madrid anunció mediante las redes sociales su retiro de las canchas como profesional.
Higuera sobre Cota: "A Pachuca se le juntaron los perritos"
El directivo rojiblanco explicó el motivo por el que lograron quedarse 6 meses más con el portero antes de que el equipo partiera a la pretemporada.