Trolling the trolls: One journalist's creative response to online harassment

Trolling the trolls: One journalist's creative response to online harassment

Jewish journalist Yair Rosenberg has been the target of anti-Semitism on social media. In response, he takes a humorous approach to shut down the hate.

Trolling the trolls: One journalist's creative response to online harass...

There’s a certain type of social media user that seems to exist merely to insult, harass and argue. They’re often too cowardly to show their true identity, instead hiding behind a moniker or cartoon, and the slightest mention of something they don’t like can unleash a barrage of cruel messages.

They are trolls. And the Internet seems more full of them now than ever.

When it comes to responding to online haters, people can take a number of approaches. You can ignore and continue on with your day, trying not to let it get to you. You can slink away. You can report the incident to the site you’re on, though that often has mixed results. Twitter, for instance, has received widespread criticism for its failure to adequately respond to hate on its platform, sometimes refusing to ban openly anti-Semitic users.

Lea esta nota en español.

Yair Rosenberg, a senior writer at the Jewish news magazine Tablet, doesn’t think it’s solely Twitter’s -- or any other technology company’s -- responsibility to monitor for and respond to trolls. Instead, he says individuals should get involved as much as possible. He’s made it a sort-of part time gig to mock his own trolls, or as he likes to say, “troll the trolls.” And in many instances, that’s shut down the hate.

Rosenberg was one of several Jewish journalists aggressively harassed by anti-Semitic trolls throughout the presidential campaign.

In October, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) Task Force on Harassment and Journalism released a troubling report detailing a year-long rise in anti-Semitic hate targeting journalists on Twitter. According to the ADL, Twitter users sent 2.6 million tweets containing language frequently found in anti-Semitic speech between August 2015 and July 2016. These tweets had an estimated 10 billion impressions.

In April, well-known journalist Julia Ioffe was bombarded by hateful tweets, phone calls and emails after she wrote a profile of Melania Trump in GQ Magazine. The images she received often featured disturbing Holocaust imagery, such as a picture of her photoshopped into a concentration camp.

In June Jonathan Weisman, the deputy Washington editor at The New York Times, briefly quit Twitter after a month’s worth of similar anti-Semitic messages and photos.

For Rosenberg, this sort of treatment was nothing new. Though he was alarmed and disturbed by the increase and severity of the attacks, he’d been on the receiving end of it for years.

“The occupational hazard of being a professional Jew on the Internet with opinions is that you will receive hate mail,” he says. “If you have a visibly Jewish name like mine, or if you cover issues related to Jewish causes or community or Israel, you will get more of it than if you cover City Hall. I am at the nexxus so I get a lot.”

Rosenberg wanted to convert his harassment into a “teaching moment,” using it to display the prevalence of anti-Semitism to those who might not realize it exists, as well as maybe connect with his harasser.


Beginning in 2014, Rosenberg began to test out a strategy that he would end up using throughout the presidential campaign. Every now and again, he would engage with the sender of an anti-Semitic tweet in a creative, smart, even funny way.

“I try not to give people the attention they like. But I don’t like to ignore it either, because that doesn’t make it go away. So how do you raise attention without giving them attention? I will never argue with an anti-Semite. I use humor and creativity and fun solutions people can be a part of.”

By refusing to be silent and instead giving it back to the harasser, Rosenberg say he has successfully unnerved and fended off countless trolls. “They don’t like it when it’s turned on them,” he says.

Often, the original user often ends up removing their tweet completely.

In that same vein, Rosenberg even helped convert a racist symbol into one of solidarity and tolerance. In June, after Mic reported that neo-Nazis were using parentheses known as the “echo symbol” as a way to target Jews on social media, Rosenberg suggested that Jews and others do the same. That tweet reverberated widely.

As a result, the “echo” symbol was adopted by users across Twitter, including Muslims, atheists, and Christians.

“We appropriated the parenthesis so that it is completely useless now to anti-Semites. I challenge anyone to find a more effective example than that,” Rosenberg says.

Still, he concedes that his lighthearted approach will not work for everyone. For some, racist harassment becomes a disturbing burden, especially when it involves in-person harassment, like calls and written death threats.

In the midst of the barrage of harassment, Ioffe told the Guardian last April: “I started the day off having a sense of humor about it but by the end of the day, after a few phone calls like this, with people playing Hitler speeches, and the imagery, and people telling me my face would look good on a lampshade, it’s hard to laugh.”

In that case, Rosenberg says it’s smart to take a different approach.

“It’s important to stress that not everyone can do what I do and there is no shame in that. You have to ask yourself if this is work you’re cut out for, or would it make things worse? If it would make things worse, disengage.”

Have you been the victim of a hate or bias incident? Share your story with us.

Actor Eduardo Yáñez was responding to a question about his son at an event in Los Angeles, leaving everybody around him stunned. Reporter Paco Fuentes asked the actor about a GoFundMe page his son posted asking for help to pay for car repairs, rather than seeking the money from his dad. The actor later apologized via Twitter.
Julian Rodriguez managed to place his 86-year-old grandmother back in the streets of her childhood home through virtual reality technology.
Artist Enrique Chiu is trying to transform the U.S.- Mexico border one paint stroke at a time. Eight years ago, Chiu started inviting people to paint the wall with the aim of uniting people at the border.
Many of the Orlando club-goers couldn't hear the shots over the song. Two survivors talked to Univision about their experience that night.
La Tropical beer was popular in Cuba before the 1959 Revolution, but the factory was nationalized and the brewery later closed.
Emoción a flor de piel: así fue el estreno de Duelo de Reinas con Clarissa Molina y Francisca Lachapel
Las dos conductoras dominicanas de Univision fueron las grandes protagonistas de la premiere de Duelo de Reinas este martes en Miami, donde no pudieron esconder su sorpresa y entusiamo al ver por primera vez terminado su gran reto de baile para homenajear a Celia Cruz.
Los jueces no se tentarán el corazón para calificar a los Pequeños Gigantes
Galilea Montijo, el productor Rubén Galindo y los jueces del show ofrecieron una conferencia de prensa para dar detalles de lo que veremos a lo largo de la nueva temporada.
El secreto tras las mejores fotos de Clarissa y Francisca: lo que no has visto de Duelo de Reinas
El fotógrafo Harry Castiblanco reveló en exclusiva para Univision Entretenimiento Digital algunos de los detalles más íntimos del rodaje de Duelo de Reinas: "Traté de contar la otra historia, esos momentos tan frágiles de amor y amistad" de Clarissa Molina y Francisca Lachapel.
Preparan tres ejecuciones para este jueves en Florida, Texas y Alabama, algo que no pasa en un mismo día desde 2010
Con la disminución de la pena capital en Estados Unidos, es raro que coincidan ejecuciones en una misma jornada. En Texas, una junta recomendó al gobernador conmutar la pena del condenado a prisión permanente, decisión que solo está en sus manos.
Olga Tañón recibirá un reconocimiento en la edición número 30 de Premio Lo Nuestro
La cantante boricua es la artista más galardonada en la historia de estos premios. Este jueves 22 de febrero recibirá un merecido reconocimiento por parte de las nuevas generaciones de mujeres cantantes. La edición número 30 de los premios contará con la presencia de más mujeres sobre el escenario en toda su historia.
La historia de la familia Yorba, uno de los legados inmigrantes más importantes en California
Eran dueños del Rancho Santiago de Santa Ana, que tenía el tamaño del condado de Orange, y en donde trabajan cientos de personas y había un gran número de ganado. La familia estaba enfocada en cultivar y desarrollar la tierra, y sus descendientes han sido personajes ilustres que influyeron en la comunidad.
Se vale soñar: El programa de la NASA que acerca a los niños con el sistema solar
Para los niños nada es imposible y sus sueños hacen que lleguen muy lejos y cumplan sus metas. Las carreras de ciencia, tecnología, ingeniería y matemáticas les permiten a los alumnos volar y soñar muy alto, a pesar de que la situación socioeconómica sea muy adversa. Estas adversidades, en lugar de deprimirlos, los alientan y los obstáculos los engrandecen.
Copa MX
Donovan estuvo muy cerca de anotar un golazo en la victoria de León 4-1 sobre Cafetaleros
El equipo de Landon Donovan, que entró al minuto 58, se impuso en el juego de Copa MX con goles de Hernández, Boselli, Piris y Cerato. Para la visita descontó Bárcenas.
Copa MX
Cauteruccio y Allison mostraron su disgusto, tras quedar con pie y medio afuera de la Copa MX
Los futbolistas de Cruz Azul hablaron con tono de resignación, luego del empate 1-1 contra Alebrijes de Oaxaca. El resultado los deja prácticamente eliminados del torneo copero. Aquí las declaraciones.
Miguel Herrera respeta a Saprissa, pero no le teme
El DT de América reconoció el crecimiento del fútbol costarricense en los últimos años y enfatizó en el hambre de triunfo que tiene su equipo para el duelo por la Liga de Campeones de Concacaf.
Johan Venegas quiere aprovechar la localía para quitarle el invicto al América
El volante del Saprissa pretende ponerle fin a la buena racha que llevan las Águilas en la Liga MX con un triunfo en Costa Rica. "El primer partido marca la serie", advirtió.