EPA personnel collect water samples along the Louisiana coast after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
Sarah Anderson

Associate Professor of Environmental Politics, University of California, Santa Barbara

Trump may reverse US climate policy but will have trouble dismantling EPA

Trump may reverse US climate policy but will have trouble dismantling EPA

History suggests that it may be harder to make radical cuts at EPA than Trump and his advisors think. While many politicians have called for eliminating entire cabinet agencies, none has succeeded.

EPA personnel collect water samples along the Louisiana coast after the...
EPA personnel collect water samples along the Louisiana coast after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill.

During the Republican primary debates, President-elect Trump threatened to gut the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), saying, “We are going to get rid of it in almost every form. We’re going to have little tidbits left but we’re going to take a tremendous amount out.”

History suggests that it may be harder to make radical cuts at EPA than Trump and his advisors think. While many politicians have called for eliminating entire cabinet agencies, none has succeeded.

Such efforts run into two empirical realities. First, government departments are rarely eliminated. Second, in my research I have found that, paradoxically, over the past six decades Democrats have been more likely to enact big cuts to programs than Republicans. Furthermore, while climate change programs may be an easy target, other presidents have found that voters like clean air and water and do not support gutting the agency whose job it is to protect them.

This article was originally published on The Conversation.

Smog over Los Angeles, 2011. The city’s air quality has improved greatly...
Smog over Los Angeles, 2011. The city’s air quality has improved greatly over the past 50 years, but the Los Angeles-Long Beach area still records some of the highest pollution levels in the nation.

Easier to grow than to cut

When I was a graduate student researcher updating a budget database, I was puzzled when I searched the 623 pages of the fiscal year 1983 budget for the budget of the Department of Education and couldn’t find it. There simply wasn’t an entry for the Department of Education because President Reagan had proposed to abolish it. Yet the budget for the Education Department increased in seven out of Reagan’s eight years as president, and it is still here today (Trump has also called for eliminating it).

Proposals to eliminate agencies have become pro forma for Republican politicians, recently including Ron Paul, Newt Gingrich and Ted Cruz. But these proposals rarely come to fruition.

Most instances in which agencies were eliminated over the past 20 years were either reorganizations – for example, merging 22 agencies to create the Department of Homeland Security in 2002 – or involved small, obsolete agencies like the Board of Tea Examiners, which was closed in 1996. When Republicans proposed cutting government after winning control of Congress in the 1994 elections, one of the few agencies that was actually closed was the Office of Technology Assessment, a small agency that provided technical and policy research to Congress itself.


Through this period, a surprising trend stands out. When Laurel Harbridge and I analyzed spending on more than 1,500 subaccounts in the federal budget from 1956 through 2003, we found that more large cuts to these accounts occurred when Democrats controlled two or three lawmaking institutions of government (House, Senate, and presidency) than when they controlled only one. (One limitation of our analysis was that we did not have data for periods when Republicans controlled all three branches.)

William Ruckelshaus is sworn in as administrator of the newly created En...
William Ruckelshaus is sworn in as administrator of the newly created Environmental Protection Agency, Dec. 4, 1970.

Why would Democrats, who traditionally support a more expansive role for government, make more large cuts in federal spending than Republicans? In social psychology Dan Kahan's words, “individuals … fit their processing of information to conclusions that suit some end or goal.” So we expect Democrats to make lots of small increases to programs.

But after making all those changes, the party must make corrections to balance its prior decisions. And when parties ignore information that runs counter to their ideology, they end up having to make big corrections. So we’d expect Democrats to occasionally make large cuts to programs.

For example, in 1993, after increasing the budget in four out of the prior five years, the unified Democratic government cut spending to the Bureau of Land Management’s land acquisition subaccount. Although Democrats are generally supportive of acquiring land for conservation, President Clinton had pointed out that buying property was coming at the expense of maintaining existing federal lands. The budget for land acquisition was cut by more than 56 percent. It took until 2000 to reach the 1992 level of spending again.


Starting in January, when Republicans will control Congress and the presidency, this perspective suggests that they will make lots of cuts, consistent with their ideological stance in favor of more limited government. But we can also predict that they may make more big increases than Democrats when the evidence shows that they have cut too far and they have to make big corrections.

EPA’s history is illustrative. Its budget was volatile in the early years under Republicans Nixon and Ford, with both huge growth (including a 238 percent increase) and big cuts. Since the funding became more stable in 1981, the budget has essentially been flat. During the period of unified Republican government from 2003-2007, the budget slowly declined. EPA received a 35 percent increase under President Obama in 2010, but since then has experienced another slow decline.

Americans value core environmental benefits

To reduce the EPA to “tidbits,” President Trump will also have to contend with public opinion. Air and water quality have greatly improved in the United States over the past 50 years, thanks to enactment of landmark laws like the Clean Air and Clean Water acts. But Americans are still concerned about these issues.

Last March 81 percent of respondents in a Gallup poll said they worried a great deal or a fair amount about pollution of waterways. More than three-quarters of Americans have held this view in Gallup surveys dating back to 1989. The same survey found that more than 70 percent of Americans had similar views about air pollution.


Trump’s EPA transition team leader is Myron Ebell, director of the Center for Energy and Environment at the Competitve Enterprise Institute. Ebell is known for arguing that climate change is not a serious problem and that the U.S. should not take action to reduce carbon emissions. We can expect that under President Trump EPA will focus on rolling back Obama administration climate change policies, such as the Clean Power Plan to reduce carbon emissions from power plants.

But the EPA is unlikely to disappear. While cuts on a lesser scale certainly would reduce the agency’s ability to enforce existing law and would dismay environmental advocates, the agency has been through reductions on this scale before and continued to function. But if the Trump administration makes too many cuts, lawsuits and public pressure to keep environmental quality high are likely to limit the administration’s ability to decimate the agency.

We are more like to see a period of slow decline similar to what occurred during George W. Bush's presidency. The motivated reasoning that encourages Republicans to cut spending showed in many small cuts across EPA’s budget. And these matter in the long run. By all accounts, the agency is being asked to do more with less and has been roundly criticized for failures like the one in Flint, Michigan. On the other hand, even Republican presidents recognize that people want a clean environment and are therefore limited in how much they can cut the EPA. If they do cut, they may even be forced by the public, the environmental movement, and lawsuits to reevaluate and make corrections.

The Conversation
Patients with chronic diseases are getting limited treatment in health centers and are still waiting for restoration of power and water supply. Univision News visited several hospitals.
The 1998 hurricane killed 11,000 people in Honduras and Nicaragua and left more than a million homeless. As a result, the United States granted temporary visas to citizens from those countries who were living illegally in the U.S.
The weather station in Key West, Florida, is sending weather balloons into the atmosphere to measure the powerful category 5 hurricane, which currently has winds of 175 miles per hour.
The Trump administration on Tuesday rescinded the DACA program that President Barack Obama introduced to protect the young undocumented immigrants known as Dreamers. Sessions said the program would be phased out over six months to allow Congress time to have another go at passing legislation.
Two brothers graduated from Harvard and Middlebury. They grew up in Houston and are practicing Christians. "Like "good Americans," they like Taco Bell. They have lived most of their lives in the United States and have a simple request for the president: "Do not get rid of DACA."
During a meeting in the Oval office Friday, the president was asked by reporters about the future of DACA, to which he responded that a decision was coming soon. "We love the dreamers, we love everyone," he added.
Nilsa Huete is an undocumented Honduran immigrant living in Key West, Florida. In the last five months, five of her family members have been arrested by agents from the Monroe County Sheriff's Office. Now she’s fighting against the deportation of her daughter and brother.
The Univision News anchor sat down with Chris Barker, leader of the "Loyal White Knights," a branch of the Ku Klux Klan. The interview was part of the special that aired Sunday on Aqui y Ahora.
A crowd surrounds a young man in a Trump hat and t-shirt, and draped in an Israeli flag, on Boston Common.
Jorge Ramos spoke with the musician's lawyer after he was detained by the Nicolas Maduro regime. The attorney said Arteaga had been "tortured". The Univision reporter asks: #FreedomforWuilly
The new defense team of alleged drug trafficker Joaquin 'El Chapo' Guzman could face a legal hurdle to represent him in federal court of New York, after Univision News learned that his attorney Jeffrey Lichtman previously represented a key potential witness in the trial. That could represent a conflict of interest in the case, experts say.
The former Republican presidential candidate says a Senate immigration proposal that would cut immigration in half is flawed, but he backs idea of merit-based points system.
Republican senators continue this week to seek ways to repeal the existing health care law known as Obamacare. Their proposal includes a halt in reimbursement for Medicaid patients who visit Planned Parenthood’s clinics. This is the testimony of a 27-year-old woman who relies on the reproductive health services offered by the organization.
The footage shows a man wearing a badge, apparently from the local sheriff’s department, and claiming to be bail bonds agent. A lawyer then rebukes and questions his authority.
A.CHAL is a rising R&B urban star because he's just being himself: reflective, proud of his Peruvian and indigenous roots, humble: "Most of my fans are not just Hispanic but of other ethnicities besides just black and white. When they see someone like me doing what I do and the world that I do it in, they feel inspired or feel like, ‘shit, I can do this too’." A.CHAL shared the stage with Lil Wayne and Kendrick Lamar at Rolling Loud Festival recently, and just released new mixtape 'On Gaz'.
This is what Greek artist Eleni means when she speaks about the power of the voice. She improvises a sing-along with a group of immigrants, refugees and allies in Boston's Urbano Project and the result was just beautiful.
Remedios naturales para evitar el reflujo y la gastritis
Después de haber sido diagnosticado con una gastritis severa, el Dr. Juan Rivera investigó cuáles son esos 'santos remedios' con los cuales puede mantener a raya su padecimiento.
Oficiales de ICE no podrán entrar a oficinas del condado de Los Ángeles sin orden judicial
La medida busca proteger a migrantes indocumentados frente a posibles operativos o investigaciones. Razón por la cual algunos empleados reciben un entrenamiento especial para distinguir entre una orden judicial y otra de inmigración.
La cachetada de Yáñez sigue: Mark Tacher la justifica y su hermano Alan discrepa
Al preguntarle a Mark Tacher qué opina acerca de la cachetada que Eduardo Yáñez le propinó a un reportero de El Gordo y la Flaca, el actor compartió su polémico punto de vista. ¡Y su hermano Alan dejó claro no está de acuerdo con él!
El 93% de los mexicanos no confía en su presidente, Enrique Peña Nieto: Pew Research Center
La encuesta de esta organización ubica al mandatario debajo de su homólogo venezolano, Nicolás Maduro, y lo deja en el último lugar entre 38 países. El estudio, en el que participaron 42,000 personas, también revela que Peña Nieto tiene el nivel más bajo de aprobación de la más reciente década en México.
Universidad en Michigan ofrece licenciatura en estudios sobre la marihuana
Las clases, que arrancaron en otoño de este año, incluyen cursos de química, biología y horticultura, así como de mercadotecnia y finanzas.
Puerto Rico: un mes de angustia (y esperanza) tras el huracán María
Este viernes se cumple un mes desde que la tormenta destruyó gran parte de la isla, volcó su economía y dejó a millones sin luz. Quienes pueden se han ido y, de los que se quedan, muchos aún necesitan ayuda para levantarse.
Cielo nublado, brisa y probabilidad de chubascos para este viernes en Miami
Hoy habría una leve disminución de la lluvia en Miami, aunque no se descartan los chubascos aislados. La temperatura máxima será de 86 grados, y hay alerta por corrientes de resaca en el sur de Florida.
Regresa a corte el policía acusado de mostrarle sus partes íntimas a dos menores en El Bronx
El policía enfrenta al menos ocho cargos por presuntamente mostrarle sus partes íntimas a dos hermanas de 7 y 12 años.
Adiós al 'milagro': los Cubs caen ante los Dodgers y se despiden de la Serie Mundial
La novena de Chicago perdió este jueves el quinto juego 1-11 contra la de Los Ángeles, que ganó la serie con un contundente 4-1y regresa después de 29 años a esta instancia definitiva. Pese a que los aficionados de los cachorros estaban convencidos de la remontada, el equipo no pudo revertir la situación.
Los Dodgers regresan a la Serie Mundial luego de 29 años y en Los Ángeles se desata la 'locura'
Los aficionados de la novena californiana se tomaron las calles de la ciudad para festejar la victoria 11-1 de su equipo frente a los Cubs de Chicago, lo que significó el campeonato de la Liga Nacional y la superioridad en la serie que terminó 4-1.
"Esto es algo que nunca voy a olvidar": Kike Hernández tras guiar a los Dodgers a la Serie Mundial
El puertorriqueño conectó tres jonrones para aportar en la victoria de la novena angelina por 11 carreras a 1 frente a los Chicago Cubs, actuales defensores del título.
Se enciende la luz verde para que Lewis Hamilton gane su cuarto título de Fórmula 1
Aunque hasta hace cuatro carreras la pelea por el primer puesto era cerrada con Sebastian Vettel, el piloto de Ferrari se rezagó en la clasificación y le dejó todo servido al hombre de Mercedes.