Carlos Gimenez.
Tomas Kennedy

Community Organizer and Miami resident who was undocumented for over 10 years.

Just like Trump does, Mayor Gimenez is bullying me

Just like Trump does, Mayor Gimenez is bullying me

“In a multicultural city like Miami, made up of immigrants from all over the world, the fact that our mayor didn’t even bother to put up a semblance of a fight should anger all its residents”.

Carlos Gimenez.
Carlos Gimenez.

This weekend, Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez did an interview on a local TV station and decided to blame me for something I didn’t do. This Trump-like attitude towards his constituents is not surprising after all he’s done in the last month, but it’s scary to realize how close our immigrant Mayor wants to be to an anti-immigrant president.

Here’s what happened.

In light of Donald Trump’s threat to cut hundreds of millions of federal dollars from cities who refuse to force local police to enforce immigration law, Miami-Dade County became the first jurisdiction to announce it will change its immigration policy and comply with the order.

Other cities all across the U.S. hav e vowed to defy Trump and not cooperate with federal immigration agencies. New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio has vowed to destroy records his municipalities hold on undocumented immigrants if necessary. Seattle Mayor Ed Murray has promised continued support for immigrant communities and Washington State has even filed suit against the Muslim Ban which the Trump Administration also instituted via executive order.

Not Miami-Dade County.

The fact that Miami-Dade County Mayor Carlos Gimenez was the first in the country to capitulate to Trump is an embarrassment of epic proportions. In a multicultural city like Miami, made up of immigrants from all over the world, the fact that our mayor didn’t even bother to put up a semblance of a fight should anger all its residents.

I got a chance to confront Mayor Gimenez at a legislative Miami-Dade Delegation hearing. Alongside two other activists, we held up signs asking the mayor to protect immigrant families while he gave his presentation. Afterwards we got a chance to speak to him but unfortunately he would not budge on his position.


Since 2013, Miami-Dade has refused to indefinitely detain inmates who are undocumented. This is not based on principle, but because the federal government doesn’t fully reimburse the county for the expense. The Mayor made the case that Miami-Dade County never claimed to be a sanctuary and that he did not want to lose millions worth of federal funds, although it’s unclear how much of this money would actually be affected by the grants detailed in Trump’s executive order.

I told the mayor that he had jumped the gun on the issue for a number of reasons. I told him that he himself was an immigrant, a Cuban exile from Havana whose family had fled political persecution and had the privilege of growing up in a system that allowed him to thrive. His personal experience should remind him what immigrants can accomplish and contribute to this country when given the opportunity.

The most frustrating part of this ordeal is the fact that the Mayor has allies and a good case to make if he were to challenge Trump on the legality of his order. City of Miami Mayor Tomas Regalado has criticized Gimenez, calling his decision premature and irresponsible while stating that the City of Miami will not comply.

If Gimenez chose to defy the Trump administration, he has legal precedent to do so by using the case of South Dakota v. Dole in which the Supreme Court considered the limitations the Constitution places on Congress when it uses its authority to influence the individual states in areas of authority normally reserved to them. The Court established a five-point rule for considering the constitutionality of expenditure cuts of this type. The fifth rule orders “the condition must not be coercive.” That would give legal ground to challenge the Trump’s executive order on immigration.


Towards the end of our conversation, I told the Mayor that this will be a chapter of American history that will be remembered very unkindly and that unless he changed course, he would be seen as one of its enablers.

A few days later, Mayor Gimenez attacked me on channel 10 and falsely claimed that I started rumors of ICE checkpoints in Miami. It is pretty sad that the Mayor is taking a page straight out of Trump’s book by attempting to intimidate immigrant right activists, but we are not scared and will not back down. While the Mayor is playing politics and bullying those of us who speak up for our families and friends, immigrants in our community are being sent to ICE detainment and families are anxious.

Mayor Carlos Gimenez, it’s time to step up and fight for the immigrant community in Miami-Dade County.

Disclaimer: We selected this Op-Ed to be published in our opinion section as a contribution to public debate. The views and opinions expressed in this column are those of its author(s) and/or the organization(s) they represent and do not reflect the views or the editorial line of Univision Noticias.

Contenidos Relacionados
07 nov, 2017 | 01:10 PM
Puerto Rico Rises Up
Latino millennials account for almost half the 27.3 million eligible Latino voters in this election. But Latino turn out is traditionally far lower than black and Anglo voters. J.P. Dominguez asks “when are we going to wake up?”
A study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic policy found that undocumented immigrants pay $11.64 billion a year in state and local taxes. The undocumented pay on average 8% of their income on taxes while the wealthiest 1% pay only 5.4%. J.P Dominguez says that's "trumped up."
During the first presidential debate, the candidates took a chance to bring up each others past mistakes to affect their performance.
After the "Taco trucks on every corner" comment from the co-founder of Latinos for Trump, part of his immigration past emerged. This is JP Domínguez's take on the issue.
Donald Trump's wife and aspiring First Lady is an immigrant who says she always "went by the law" - but her story is a little 'SUS'.
Así fue como Dayanara Torres se convirtió en la ganadora de Mira Quién Baila
En un minuto hacemos un repaso a los mejores bailes de la boricua. Mira su evolución en la pista de baile.
Dayanara Torres gana Mira Quién Baila
Luego de 10 semanas de baile y más baile, la competencia llegó a su gran final y ya tenemos a una nueva reina de la pista.
Dayanara Torres: 'Estoy de vuelta y es gracias a Mira Quién Baila'
La boricua espera además que su triunfo le traiga un rayito de luz a Puerto Rico y que sus compatriotas se sientan orgullosos de ella.
Muere a los 83 años el asesino serial Charles Manson, uno de los más infames del siglo XX
El temido psicópata, quien falleció por causas naturales, cumplía una condena de cadena perpetua desde hace 40 años por el asesinato de siete personas con ayuda de su banda delictiva 'La familia Manson'.
Fue entregado a las autoridades de EEUU el niño Noe Reyna, quien había sido secuestrado por su padre
El menor de 15 meses de edad fue secuestrado por Carlos Iván Reyna, de 35 años de edad, el pasado 14 de noviembre luego de que ese mismo día una Corte le anunciara a él y a la madre del menor que perdían la custodia del niño. Noe Reyna fue entregado por un tío. El padre del menor, en dialogo con Univision, reconoció que cometió un error y pidió disculpas.
Descubren más de 1,000 bicicletas y un revólver en un búnker de indigentes en el sur de California
Un escondite subterráneo había sido construido en un campamento de más de 150 indigentes ubicado a la orilla del río Santa Ana en el condado de Orange.
Así fue la marcha hacia el Capitolio para demandar más ayuda a Puerto Rico
A dos meses del paso del huracán María, gran parte de la isla se encuentra aún sin luz ni electricidad, por eso cientos manifestantes tomaron las calles de la capital del país para exigirle al Congreso ayuda para los residentes de la isla. La protesta denominada ‘Marcha en Unidad por Puerto Rico’ contó con la participación del cantante y compositor Lin Manuel Miranda.
Gael Sandoval sobre Chivas: "A quién no le gusta cambiar de equipo para mejorar"
El elemento de Santos Laguna señaló que todavía no es oficial su traspaso el conjunto Rojiblanco.
Cristante: “En la liguilla tenemos que ser más intensos e inteligentes”
Tras el triunfo sobre Xolos, el estratega de Toluca consideró que deben mejorar en muchos aspectos para competir en la ‘fiesta grande’ de la Liga MX.
Toluca domesticó a Xolos y cierra con buen futbol la fase regular
Los ‘Diablos’ se metieron a los primeros puestos y solo deberán esperar para conocer a su rival en la Liguilla.
Miguel Herrera: “Estoy consciente que América no está generando buen fútbol”
El estratega de las Águilas señaló necesitan trabajar demasiado para encarar el próximo encuentro ante Cruz Azul.