Nassar & Al Sudairi: Forgotten Lives and Unmournable Deaths  logo-notici...

Nassar & Al Sudairi: Forgotten Lives and Unmournable Deaths

Nassar & Al Sudairi: Forgotten Lives and Unmournable Deaths

The authors identify an “empathy gap” in global reactions to similar tragedies taking place in Paris, Beirut and Baghdad

Nassar & Al Sudairi: Forgotten Lives and Unmournable Deaths  GettyImages...

By Fadi Nicholas Nassar  & Mohammed Al Sudairi , PhD candidates at King's College London and Hong Kong University (*)

A Facebook picture with a flag of a victim’s country, a hashtag bequeathing a prayer, and an outpouring of statements of support by foreign leaders are not meaningless gestures. They matter, especially in times of great vulnerability, fear, and mourning.

They are signals that remind those in the wake of a great tragedy that their voices are heard, their lives recognized; in the face of their challenges they do not stand alone. It is, we would like to assume, an expected human response to the wickedness of terror and the anguish of violence.

And what happens when that expected human response does not come? When instead of words of compassion and kindness to those who lost loved ones, there are cheers and jubilations “ for more to die.”

There are no candlelit vigils, no global movements of solidarity, or even the most simple signs of compassion. Silence, too, is a sign. In moments where acknowledgment and empathy are necessary in healing, their absence and elision signals indifference. An indifference that was deeply felt by the victims of the terrorist attacks that took place in Baghdad and Beirut.

An indifference that was made even more pronounced by the opposite reaction that took place a day later as Paris experienced a similar strike. Only moments after blood was spilled, those healing signals of solidarity came, but not for them. In this moment of vulnerability Paris was not alone. Those buried in Baghdad and Beirut, however, remained forgotten lives and unmournable deaths.

Like a broken record, a tragedy strikes a city like Paris and the world rushes in, while citizens of a country on the peripheries of power remind the international community — and sadly find themselves trying to convince it — that they too matter.

They have attempted to decry what the Atlantic’s David Graham has pointed out to be a consistent “ empathy gap” in global reactions — but particularly from those in the West — to similar tragedies taking place in their homes. Those homes are not some faraway wastelands inhabited by violent barbarian tribes who ‘if pricked do not bleed.’

Sadly, while the killings in Paris were depicted- rightly so — as acts of terror, the victims of the Beirut bombings were framed in many outlets as the inhabitants of a “ Hezbullah stronghold” and the losses in Baghdad as just another outbreak of violence in a country where such news is unfortunate but expected.

Despite all being victims of the same perpetrator, ISIS, there were no statements that Baghdad represented all humanity and no monuments were lit up for Beirut. There was, in fact, little acknowledgement of these tragedies and those caught in it before Paris.

Attempts to broaden the conversation (as symbolized, for example, by the hashtag “Pray for the World”) and highlight the commonality of these tragedies were met with little success and even resistance from some quarters.

These attempts, furthermore, were inherently problematic insofar as they continued to position the tragedies of Beirut and Baghdad in the shadow of the events that took place in Paris. Indeed, no matter how broad and encompassing this “solidarity” becomes, it cannot escape the centrality of Paris to its narrative. It is ironic, after all that the Al-Shabbab massacres in Kenya for example only garnered significant global attention and circulation seven months after they took place.


Remembrance thus becomes an afterthought; tragedies are merely international props to paint an international face to a solidarity that has, in truth, largely focused itself on Paris alone. And herein lies the problem with these attempts:  no matter how well-intentioned, they serve to drown out the critiques that are being voiced by those who see an undercurrent of racism and dehumanization in global reactions to similar events that have occurred within such a short time-frame.

The truth of the matter is these are frustrations that have been voiced before and yet the conversations that ensue appear to be stuck in a limbo. What tends to be missed – or sidelined – in such discussions are the power dynamics that define who deserves to be mourned and who is to be forgotten (in life and in death).

Tragedies on the periphery of power are often made invisible, while Western lives – citizens of the more “civilized” lands – are commemorated and remembered globally. The reasoning behind such selective solidarity is often presented in terms of a greater familiarity with Paris, a beacon of “high culture” unaccustomed to the violence that is a daily occurrence in places like Beirut and Baghdad.

As some might say, “this is not Iraq or Afghanistan”. The clinging on to colonial images of some cities as luminous capitals of humanity and others as shrouded in darkness speaks to how those who live in them are (mis)perceived.

In reality, the differences in reaction reflect an inherent hierarchy of power wherein wealthier nations and their citizens, at the core of global politics and economic power, enjoy disproportionate spaces for mourning and representation than other, less fortunate bodies from the poorer nations of the world.


The latter make up a periphery (or multiple peripheries) which, by virtue of their socio-economic limitations cannot, in any substantive sense, exercise significant control over political and cultural capital, or for that matter, be able to even register a presence in the various modes of media that constitute our “global commons”.

These asymmetries were created – and reinforced – by very real colonial and imperial legacies that continue to exercise considerable influence over the representation of these regions and peoples. Thus, lack of access, compounded by orientalist perceptions from this core, ensures that the voices from these peripheries remain minimized and sidelined in the global conversations taking place.

There are, naturally, gradations of mourning and representation inherent to the hierarchy of power. Not all “civilized” cores are the same. The death of citizens from industrialized and powerful polities like Russia are not be ranked as highly as those of the core West.

The downing of the Russian airline jet is a case in point – the deaths of over 224 people garnered very little “ global solidarity”.  This hierarchy moreover contains multiple, smaller hierarchies that reproduce the core-periphery asymmetries noted above, albeit in different contexts and with different constituencies in mind.

The solidarities expressed in the aftermath of the Mumbai 2008 attacks versus the absence of a global conversation over civilian deaths in Kashmir come to mind. Again, what is to be emphasized here is that the modes of representation do not necessarily abide by a Western versus non-Western dichotomy.


Nevertheless, because of its colonial history and status on the global stage, the West stands at the apex of this power pyramid. In a world where, as Frantz Fanon reminds us, race  and power are not so easily separated, critiques of power must always be expanded to incorporate race. The problematic links between power, race, and perceptions of human value, now, become ever too clear, as does the need to break them.

This is certainly a time to mourn the losses of innocent and precious lives. It is a time to condemn terrorism and the indignant targeting of civilians. But, when we mourn some deaths and elide those of others, we are engaging in a violent process of dehumanization.

It is a suffocating environment that suggests some deaths are more mournable than others; some lives more valuable and more human than others. These frustrations pulsing from parts of the world too often forgotten, cannot continue to be ignored or dismissed.

These are not the frustrations of the privileged lamenting the attention given to the marginalized, these are the voices of the Wretched of the Earth interrupting the silence that invisibilizes their lives and deaths. As soon as we acknowledge that the asymmetry in sympathy is not a recent phenomenon, we recognize that something in our reaction to these frustrations is flawed.

Rather than engage in cognitive dissonance, those privileged in life and in death, must do more than pay lip-service to equality and work to dismantle a system that prioritizes their lives over the historically underrepresented.


With the incoming news of two bombings in Nigeria, the lives of the fallen cannot be forgotten and left unmourned. Yola and Kano must know, that like Paris, they do not stand alone.

(*) Nassar is a PhD candidate at King's College London, Department of War Studies. Al Sudairi is a PhD candidate at Hong Kong University, Department of Politics and Public Administration. You can read the Spanish version here.

Disclaimer: This Op-Ed was selected to be published in our opinion section as a contribution to public debate. The views and opinions expressed in this column are those of its author(s) and/or the organization(s) they represent and do not reflect the views or the editorial line of Univision Noticias.

En alianza con:


Las mujeres ganan hasta un 18% menos que los hombres, por eso dejaron de trabajar a las 2:38 pm. Consideran que a esa hora comienzan a trabajar gratuitamente.
El futuro autónomo del transporte de bienes en carretera está a la vuelta de la esquina.
Además, la mayoría opositora en la Asamblea Nacional de Venezuela aprobó iniciar un juicio político contra el presidente Nicolás Maduro y el director de inteligencia James Clapper afirmó que la responsabilidad del ciberataques masivo no recae en ningún actor estatal.
El magnate se encontraba en Sanford cuando volteó a elogiar a la multitud que se encontraba a sus espaldas. "Amo esas pancartas: Negros por Trump", dijo sin notar que una de las personas que sostenía estos carteles era de raza blanca. Internet sí lo vio y reaccionó.
Yessica Flores, de nacionalidad hondureña y residencia en Estados Unidos desde hace nueve años, no tuvo síntomas ni está segura de dónde contrajo la enfermedad. Cada tres semanas tiene un ecosonograma donde revisan si el tamaño de la cabeza de su bebé es normal o si existe algún daño ocasionado por el virus.
Con 3 pies de ancho y 4 de altura fue construido a unos 23 pies de profundidad y con una longitud de 563 yardas de largo. Además, los fiscales consiguieron dos toneladas de marihuana en paquetes, en la supuesta fábrica donde empezaba el túnel.
Según Humane Society International, Pizza conocido como el oso polar más triste del mundo ha empeorado debido a su encierro.
Toyota llevó a cabo ajustes significativos en su Tacoma para convertir a la TRD Pro en la pickups mediana con la mayor capacidad off-road de todas las que hemos probado…hasta ahora.
La medida ocurre luego de que el Consejo Nacional Electoral decidiera suspender la semana pasada el proceso de referendo revocatorio contra el mandatario, lo que pone en duda la viabilidad de esa ruta legal para cambiar el gobierno.
Niños residentes en el campamento de inmigrantes ‘la Jungla’ de Calais se enfrentan a un futuro incierto debido a que las autoridades francesas comenzaron a desmantelar el campamento este lunes.
El candidato republicano dijo que "todos sus empleados" tienen problemas con Obamacare en un evento de campaña en Doral, Florida lo que implicaría que no les ofrece seguro a sus trabajadores. Al ser repreguntado por reporteros, dijo que "solo algunos" tienen Obamacare.
Los agentes acompañaron a la niña de ocho años en su regreso a la escuela luego de la muerte de su padre. La menor estuvo bastante conmovida por la visita de los compañeros de su papá.
La madre del pequeño encendió las redes sociales cuando se enteró de la discriminación de la que su hijo fue víctima. Las muestras de apoyo y solidaridad no se hicieron esperar.
Las participantes del concurso brasilero fueron consideradas irrespetuosas. Diferentes organizaciones religiosas han rechazado la publicación de la fotografía.
El sujeto salió ileso de la arriesgada maniobra para alcanzar su auto, que se le había escapado accidentalmente. El vehículo no corrió la misma suerte.
La carta de la niña ha conmovido por el mensaje que le deja a la sociedad. Su hermano sufre de autismo y ella reaccionó cuando uno de los compañeros de clase lo llamó “raro”. Dijo que las personas no pueden ser juzgadas por sus discapacidades.
Atacante yihadista de París grabó el asesinato del policía y su pareja
El presidente francés François Hollande atribuyó el ataque a una "acción terrorista".
Un museo subacuático que protege a los corales
Bajo las aguas de Cancún yace un museo de arte que ayuda en la lucha contra la destrucción de los arrecifes.
¿Hillary Clinton o Donald Trump? Ya miles comenzaron a elegir con la votación anticipada
Este lunes comenzó, en algunos estados, la votación anticipada para las elecciones presidenciales en EEUU del próximo 8 de noviembre.
Así están hoy las encuestas entre Clinton y Trump en la lucha por la presidencia
¿Qué porcentaje de voto obtendrían los candidatos si se celebraran hoy las elecciones? ¿Cuántos votos electorales ganaría cada uno? Enfrentamos a los candidatos en varios gráficos que muestran el resultado de las últimas encuestas.
El puertorriqueño Roberto Pérez hace historia al pegar dos jonrones en el primer partido
El receptor pegó dos cuadrangulares en el inicio de la Serie Mundial y fue la gran estrella de la ofensiva de los Indians.
Un ruso realiza un salto que pocos se atreverían desde los Himalayas
Este hombre amante de los deportes extremos realiza un salto BASE desde 25,262 pies de altura, en la sexta montaña más alta del mundo en la frontera entre Nepal y China.
Cruz Azul construiría su propio estadio en la Ciudad de México
Luego de que el Estadio Azul dejará de existir en el 2018, los celestes estarían analizando la construcción de un nuevo inmueble.
Mourinho, mis primeros meses en Manchester han sido "un desastre"
El entrenador portugués ha tenido que batallar para encontrar un estilo de juego que rinda con los 'Red Devils' y con un once que le funcione.
Fashion Gurús: Los Detectives de la Moda vs. Milennials ¿quién tiene la razón?
En los Premios Juventud más "retro" enfrentamos las opiniones de los expertos Milennials contra los expertos de la casa, ¿quién te gustó más?
El talento de Univision viajó en el tiempo en Premios Juventud 2016
Una vez más, nuestro talento brilló en la alfombra. ¿Quiénes te gustaron?
El show en fotos: Mira el Mega Reventón Retro de Premios Juventud 2016
Disfruta de una gran retrospectiva que celebra lo mejor de décadas pasadas junto a Pitbull, Gente de Zona, Enrique Iglesias, Chino & Nacho, Daddy Yankee, Prince Royce, CNCO, Magneto ¡y muchos más!
Premio Lo Nuestro 2016: Ganadores, alfombra, musicales, ¡todo el show!
Disfruta lo mejor de la 28va edición de Premio Lo Nuestro y no te pierdas todo lo que ocurrió durante las actuaciones estelares de tus artistas favoritos durante la ceremonia.