Venezuela’s President Nicolas Maduro speaks with first lady Cilia Flores as they arrive to the Supreme Court, before delivering his state of the union address, in Caracas, Venezuela.
José Miguel Vivanco

José Miguel Vivanco, director of Human Rights Watch's Americas division and a former attorney for the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights at the Organization of American States (OAS). A Chilean, Vivanco studied law at the University of Chile and Salamanca Law School in Spain and holds an LL.M. from Harvard Law School.

Venezuela’s crumbling façade of democracy

Venezuela’s crumbling façade of democracy

For years, Venezuela has been run by a government with a deplorable human rights record that has taken advantage of a tremendous concentration of power to gradually erode human rights guarantees and checks on its own power. But Wednesday's Supreme Court ruling to shutter Congress is a turning point.

Venezuela’s President Nicolas Maduro speaks with first lady Cilia Flores...
Venezuela’s President Nicolas Maduro speaks with first lady Cilia Flores as they arrive to the Supreme Court, before delivering his state of the union address, in Caracas, Venezuela.

On March 29, the Venezuelan Supreme Court effectively shut down Congress, the only key government institution that remained independent of executive control, making the incredible announcement that it would assume all legislative powers itself or choose some other institution to delegate them to. This ruling is the end of Maduro administration’s façade of democracy.

This was not an isolated event that occurred out of the blue. Over the years the Maduro administration has steadily and very deliberately rolled back checks on its own power while running roughshod over Venezuelans’ fundamental human rights.

Lea este articulo en español

Holding periodic, free, and fair elections. The National Electoral Council—with its majority of government supporters—has deliberately stalled a recall referendum on President Nicolás Maduro. It has not organized municipal and state governor elections that, under the Constitution, were supposed to take place in 2016.

Separation of powers. None of Venezuela’s government institutions have maintained any ability to act as a check on executive power. Former president Hugo Chávez took over the Supreme Court in 2004, and both Chávez and Maduro have re-packed it since then, destroying its watchdog function. Since Venezuelans overwhelmingly gave the opposition a majority in the National Assembly in 2015, President Maduro has used the court to undermine it. After months in which the court nullified every law that threatened the government’s interests, it declared that Congress was in contempt of the court’s decisions and took over all legislative functions, effectively shutting down the legislature.


Repression of Political Opponents and Critics. The Venezuelan Penal Forum, a non-profit group that provides legal counsel to detainees, counts more than 100 political prisoners, including Leopoldo López, an opposition leader who has been behind bars for over three years. Some political prisoners were arrested on the basis of information provided by anonymous “patriotic” informants. The government has been using its intelligence services to detain and prosecute political opponents and critics.

But the Supreme Court ruled that opposition legislators’ support for the ongoing debate at the Organization of American States (OAS) on the Venezuela crisis may constitute treason and warned that the lawmakers responsible would not have parliamentary immunity.

Venezuelan military attacks Univision correspondent in Caracas
Univision correspondent assaulted in Venezuela as political crisis deepens
The journalist was doing a live report when she was approached by ten officers from the Bolivarian National Guard who took her cell phone and beat her.

Respect for freedom of expression. Very few independent media outlets remain. Security forces have detained and interrogated journalists and confiscated their equipment. International journalists have been stopped from entering the country to cover the crisis, or detained for doing so. News channels have been forced off the air. The government has adopted measures to restrict international funding of non-profit organizations whose work exposes abuses—on the unsubstantiated grounds that they undermine Venezuelan democracy. Ordinary citizens who criticized the government have been criminally prosecuted. The media have reported that hundreds of people were fired from government jobs for supporting the recall referendum.

Respect for other civil and political rights.Venezuelan security forces have repeatedly used brutal force against bystanders and demonstrators at anti-government protests. In some cases, they have used torture. A series of police and military raids in 2015 in low-income and immigrant communities has led to widespread allegations of abuse: extrajudicial executions, mass detentions, arbitrary deportations and evictions, and the bulldozing of homes.


Respect for economic, social, and cultural rights. Venezuela is facing a dramatic humanitarian crisis. Severe shortages of medicine, medical supplies, and food have undermined the ability of many Venezuelans to get adequate nutrition and health care. The government has denied that the crisis exists, failed to alleviate the shortages, and made only limited efforts to obtain readily available international humanitarian assistance.

For years, Venezuela has been run by a government with a deplorable human rights record that has taken advantage of a tremendous concentration of power to gradually erode human rights guarantees and checks on its own power. The latest Supreme Court ruling is a turning point. Faced with something that looks more and more like a full-fledged dictatorship, the international community should react—strong and decisive multilateral pressure on the Maduro administration is more important and urgent than ever.

Jose Miguel Vivanco is Americas director at Human Rights Watch.

Contenidos Relacionados
20 oct, 2017 | 12:29 PM
Mexico rises
Latino millennials account for almost half the 27.3 million eligible Latino voters in this election. But Latino turn out is traditionally far lower than black and Anglo voters. J.P. Dominguez asks “when are we going to wake up?”
A study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic policy found that undocumented immigrants pay $11.64 billion a year in state and local taxes. The undocumented pay on average 8% of their income on taxes while the wealthiest 1% pay only 5.4%. J.P Dominguez says that's "trumped up."
During the first presidential debate, the candidates took a chance to bring up each others past mistakes to affect their performance.
After the "Taco trucks on every corner" comment from the co-founder of Latinos for Trump, part of his immigration past emerged. This is JP Domínguez's take on the issue.
Donald Trump's wife and aspiring First Lady is an immigrant who says she always "went by the law" - but her story is a little 'SUS'.
Kate del Castillo sobre Sean Penn durante entrevista acerca de 'El día que conocí a El Chapo': "Nunca me enamoré de él, tuvimos sexo"
La actriz mexicana encendió más la polémica por su encuentro con Joaquín Guzmán Loera en 2015 después de hacer pública esta parte de su vida íntima con el actor estadounidense en la fecha del estreno de 'El día que conocí a El Chapo', documental de Netflix.
La carta de una niña contra Enrique Peña Nieto por la violencia en Madera, Chihuahua
"Un futuro seguro y que deje de robar", fue la exigencia que una menor en primaria escribió al presidente de México durante una clase en la que el docente pidió a sus estudiantes reflexionar. Un estudio del Observatorio Nacional de Seguridad indicó que Chihuahua forma parte de los 11 estados con aumento en la delincuencia.
El efecto de los cambios de la administración Trump en el ingreso de inmigrantes a las ramas militares
Las nuevas exigencias en las leyes federales para el acceso de jóvenes con diferentes estatus migratorios preocupan a líderes políticos como Ydanis Rodríguez, concejal de Nueva York. La Coalición para los Derechos de los Inmigrantes critica un comunicado del Departamento de Defensa sobre la revisión de antecedentes de los postulados.
Nueva York conservará las temperaturas cálidas para este fin de semana
El pronóstico del tiempo indica que las temperaturas por encima de los 70 grados Fahrenheit se mantendrán hasta el miércoles.
¿Por qué dicen que los jefes hispanos tratan mejor a sus empleados?
Una encuesta dirigida por una consultora sobre consumidores de servicios integrales encontró que los empleadores hispanos son más generosos en este aspecto. La investigación también arrojó que los jefes latinos son 23% más probables a ofrecer beneficios a sus empleados.
Realizan vigilia en memoria de dos presos que murieron adentro de una cárcel de Los Ángeles
La conmemoración fue organizada por miembros de los grupos 'Justicia por Los Ángeles' y 'Dignidad y poder ahora' con el propósito también de hacer un llamado a las autoridades del condado a que detengan planes de construir más cárceles.
Chubasco y posibilidad de tormentas en Miami
La temperatura mínima de este sábado 20 de octubre será de 79 grados Fahrenheit y la máxima, de 89. El termómetro hará registros más bajos a partir del miércoles.
Los médicos también se mueren y los goleadores como Raúl Ruidíaz también botan penaltis
Tras el 0-0 ante León, el delantero de Monarcas se refirió al penalti que estrelló contra el poste en el primer tiempo: “Son cosas del fútbol, pateé mal y hay que corregir”, aseguró el peruano.
¡De infarto! Todo lo que no te puedes perder de la última fecha, antes de los Playoffs, de la MLS
La mayoría de los equipos clasificados a las finales están definidos en ambas Conferencias. Sin embargo, podrían darse algunas modificaciones en los primeros lugares. Aquí todos los detalles.
Mauro Boselli, sobre el 0-0 ante Morelia: “El empate es justo, no hay que reprocharse nada”
El delantero de León rescató el punto como visitante en Guanajuato ante Monarcas. Y del penal que falló no se hizo reproches: “Tengo la confianza de mis compañeros y el próximo hay que hacerlo”.
¿Lo compras o no? Al 'Profe' Bracamontes le quisieron vender que ‘Chicharito’ llegará mal al Mundial
En la tradicional sección de Contacto Deportivo, Iván Kasanzew le argumentó al ‘Profe’ que el bajo nivel del equipo West Ham podría perjudicar al delantero. Aquí la respuesta de Bracamontes.