A five-story coal ash pile next to the AES electric power plant in Guayama, Puerto Rico.
Hilda Lloréns

Hilda Lloréns is a cultural anthropologist whose regional specialization is the Hispanic Caribbean and Latino/a US. Currently, she is investigating environmental racism, injustice, and women’s activism in Puerto Rico.

In Puerto Rico, environmental injustice and racism inflame protests over coal ash

In Puerto Rico, environmental injustice and racism inflame protests over coal ash

In Puerto Rico’s south, protests are building over the disposal of toxic coal ash in landfills.

A five-story coal ash pile next to the AES electric power plant in Guaya...
A five-story coal ash pile next to the AES electric power plant in Guayama, Puerto Rico.

For scholars like me who study environmental justice, it has been encouraging to see residents in Flint, Michigan and the Standing Rock Sioux in North Dakota organize against threats to their homes and health. But elsewhere in our country, other struggles are happening out of the spotlight – and often dragging on for years.

In Puerto Rico’s south, protests are building over the disposal of toxic coal ash in landfills. Small-scale protests began in 2014, but opposition has grown. A recent demonstration drew an estimated 1,000 people. Protesters have been routinely harassed by police and arrested.

As a native of the island’s southeast, I have been following these developments closely. Historically this region has been a zone of human exploitation and natural resource extraction. In the struggle over coal ash disposal, poor and mostly black communities in Puerto Rico’s hinterlands are being forced to sacrifice their health and the health of their environment to support the island’s energy-intensive economy and lifestyle.

The AES coal-fired power plant in Guayamas, Puerto Rico. Hilda Llorens, Author providedThis crisis illustrates two closely connected problems: environmental injustice and environmental racism. The first refers to disproportionately high levels of exposure to environmental risks experienced by some segments of the population. The latter describes cases in which those unequal impacts fall on communities of color. Both are factors in this conflict and reflect Puerto Rico’s socioeconomic history.


But even as locals fight these problems, there is one hopeful development: the spread of rooftop solar power as a replacement. Coquí Solar, a project initiated in a Jobos Bay community near Guayama’s AES plant, is working to define an alternative to the underlying problem – coal-fired energy – and find ways to achieve it.

A sacrifice zoneLike many places that struggle with environmental injustice, Puerto Rico’s Guayama-Salinas region along the island’s Caribbean coast is a low-income area with a high fraction of minority residents. The median yearly household income is US$15,000, and more than half of residents live below the poverty line. According to the 2010 U.S. Census, 17 percent of people in the region self-identified as black or African-American, compared to the national average of 12.4 percent. (In Puerto Rico, large concentrations of black residents are a marker of poverty.)

The area has suffered historically from high unemployment and poverty rates. It lies far from the national capital, San Juan, and was highly dependent on sugar cane agriculture for many years. Because of this legacy, the coastal environment is especially valuable to residents. It provides resources that buffer them against local and global economic crises – much like resource-dependent communities along the U.S. Gulf Coast that face similar environmental justice struggles.

One recent study quotes a saying among Puerto Rican artisanal fishers: “Nos defendemos con pescado fresco,” meaning, “We defend ourselves with fresh fish.” Another study found that people in this region who made a significant part of their living from fishing in the ocean and foraging in the mangroves derived a sense of cultural identity and well-being from these activities, along with food and income.

Coastal mangrove forest in Puerto Rico. Mangrove forests provide habitat...
Coastal mangrove forest in Puerto Rico. Mangrove forests provide habitat for many species of fish and shellfish.

The source of the coal ash is a 454-megawatt coal-fired electric power plant in Guayama owned by the utility AES that has been operating since 2002. The plant is adjacent to a Superfund site where Chevron Phillips operated an oil refinery from 1966 through 2002.

Throughout the area, former sugar cane fields, mangrove forests and oceanfront lands have been converted to housing developments, shopping plazas, manufacturing and power plants over the past 50 years. Residents thus already bear a heavy burden from development that has compromised their health and the natural resources that many rely on for their livelihoods.

Broken promises

The coal ash generated by AES in Guayama is known to contain high levels of arsenic, heavy metals and radioactivity. Under current EPA regulations, coal ash can be disposed of in surface impoundments and landfills, in surface-waste ponds or recycled into products such as concrete and drywall. These methods are widely practiced throughout the United States and other parts of the world.


AES pledged in 1996, before the plant started operating, that it would not deposit coal ash in landfills on the island. The company’s initial strategy was to ship thousands of tons of ash to two rural coastal communities in the Dominican Republic. But after local doctors reported increases in spontaneous abortions and birth defects near those areas, AES was ordered to clean up the ashes and paid $6 million in a legal settlement with the Dominican Republic’s Environmental and Natural Resources Agency.

AES then developed a construction product called Agremax, a filler based on coal ash. Some two million tons of coal ash were used throughout Puerto Rico to build roads, parking lots, malls and as fill in tract housing developments, including sites near public water wells, farms, wetlands and beaches. Alarmed by fugitive dust and other impacts, environmental groups sued. In 2014, lacking customers, Agremax was retired from the construction market.

In response, Puerto Rico’s Environmental Quality Board and the island’s public power company (which buys the coal plant’s electricity) allowed AES to reverse its pledge and deposit coal ash in local landfills. But according to the EPA, a majority of Puerto Rico’s 29 landfills are over capacity, and some are open dumps that do not comply with current regulations. The agency currently has legal agreements to close 12 landfills. In sum, the ash disposal controversy is worsening a landfill crisis.

Taking core samples at the site of a coal ash spill on the Dan River in...
Taking core samples at the site of a coal ash spill on the Dan River in North Carolina, 2014.

Slow violence

The struggle over coal ash is rooted in colonial and economic policies that have turned Puerto Ricans into migrants, consumers and debtors over the past century. These circumstances illustrate what Princeton University’s Rob Nixon calls “ slow violence”: a steady accumulation of gradual, and often invisible, environmental harms endured by vulnerable individuals and communities during capitalist expansion.

Southeast Puerto Rico was populated in the 18th century by enslaved Africans, and later free blacks and mixed-race individuals, who worked on sugar cane plantations. When the island industrialized in the mid-20th century, many workers left farms for factories, while others sought agricultural work in the United States. Massive migration to U.S. cities became a way of life for Puerto Ricans, and multinational corporations began to build facilities on empty agricultural land.


As a result of these processes, people in this part of Puerto Rico have little political or economic clout and are vulnerable to exploitation by corporations like AES. But they recognize that landfilling coal ash threatens the resources that they depend on, and are trying to end it.

A solar-powered future?

Residents of the Coquí neighborhood in the Bay of Jobos are working with scientists at the University of Puerto Rico-Mayagüez to build and install solar panels throughout the community. If this initiative succeeds, it would be the first solar-powered community in Puerto Rico. Community volunteers will receive training in the hopes that they will be able to install and maintain the equipment locally. Perhaps anticipating this shift, AES has opened a solar energy farm on fallow agricultural land in Guayama.

Many other communities in places far from the public eye face what can seem like insurmountable obstacles in their own struggles against enduring environmental injustice and racism. Every case is unique, but as pioneering environmental justice scholar Robert Bullard argues, the central challenge is the same: providing equal protection to disenfranchised communities, and ensuring that their voices are heard.

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Latino millennials account for almost half the 27.3 million eligible Latino voters in this election. But Latino turn out is traditionally far lower than black and Anglo voters. J.P. Dominguez asks “when are we going to wake up?”
A study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic policy found that undocumented immigrants pay $11.64 billion a year in state and local taxes. The undocumented pay on average 8% of their income on taxes while the wealthiest 1% pay only 5.4%. J.P Dominguez says that's "trumped up."
During the first presidential debate, the candidates took a chance to bring up each others past mistakes to affect their performance.
After the "Taco trucks on every corner" comment from the co-founder of Latinos for Trump, part of his immigration past emerged. This is JP Domínguez's take on the issue.
Donald Trump's wife and aspiring First Lady is an immigrant who says she always "went by the law" - but her story is a little 'SUS'.
Niegan servicios en el banco a una anciana porque sobrepasa el límite de edad de 110 años
En México, un banco le negó una tarjeta débito a María Félix Nava, una anciana de 116 años, alegando que el límite de edad para entregarla es de 110 años. Por lo tanto, la mujer no pudo cobrar sus 2,400 pesos mexicanos, unos 130 dólares de pensión.
Tres hijos del cantante Juan Gabriel se enfrentan en una corte de Florida para reclamar la herencia del artista
En la corte, los dos hijos biológicos del cantante se sentaron juntos. Al otro lado estaba el hijo adoptivo, el único heredero, según el testamento que habría dejado el artista. Él ha solicitado que la petición de uno de sus hermanos para que la herencia se reparta en partes iguales sea desestimada por supuesta falta de jurisdicción.
Joaquín 'El Chapo' Guzmán asegura que está enfermo y que escucha voces en la cárcel
'El Chapo' dice estar muy aburrido en la cárcel de Nueva York, donde permanece recluido. Sus abogados se quejaron del trato que le dan, que califican como inhumano. Aseguran que su salud se ha deteriorado hasta el grado de que escucha voces, y que está cansado de ver el mismo programa sobre rinocerontes.
Detienen para su deportación a un inmigrante indocumentado que estuvo 9 meses refugiado en una iglesia en Denver en 2014
El mexicano Arturo Hernández fue apresado este miércoles por agentes de ICE mientras trabajaba. El hombre había salido en 2015 de una congregación en Colorado tras recibir una carta del gobierno precisando que no era una prioridad de deportación.
La misteriosa desaparición de un niño de 5 años mantiene en vilo a las autoridades en California
Aramazd Andressian Jr. fue reportado como desaparecido el pasado sábado, pero aún no hay respuestas sobre su paradero y todavía es una incógnita el cómo fue que su padre le perdió el rastro.
Autoridades en Arizona encuentran niños encerrados en una habitación con drogas y las paredes manchadas con heces
Aaron Fish, de 36 años, y Amanda Sistrunk, de 28 años, fueron arrestados este miércoles cuando las autoridades los buscaban en cumplimiento de una orden judicial por delitos relacionados con drogas. En la residencia encontraron a los menores encerrados.
Venezuela anuncia su retiro de la OEA
La decisión anunciada por la ministra Delcy Rodríguez ocurre luego de que el organismo continental votara a favor de la convocatoria a una reunión extraordinaria de cancillerres para abordar la crisis en ese país.
Diego Alonso: “El triunfo es producto del respaldo que tenemos de la directiva del club”
“Este partido lo empezamos a preparar desde hace un año”, aseguró el estratega del Pachuca, y resaltó la motivación que tenía todo el grupo por ganar este torneo y llegar al Mundial de Clubes.
Ricardo ‘Tuca’ Ferretti: “Si se ganaran los torneos nada más por dinero, sería muy sencillo”
Tras perder la final ante Pachuca, el DT de Tigres mostró su desacuerdo con un periodista que afirmó que Los Felinos estaban obligados a ganar por tener una nómina más costosa.
Jonathan Urretaviscaya: “No veníamos bien en Liga y esto nos da confianza”
El atacante del Pachuca destacó el gran nivel de Tigres, y resaltó la importancia anímica del triunfo para todo el grupo. “Fue un partido muy abierto y fuimos justos vencedores” aseguró.
Raúl López: “Es un sueño para mí ir al Mundial de Clubes”
Para el lateral del Pachuca, el haber clasificado al evento ecuménico será una gran oportunidad para “demostrar que está en un gran nivel el fútbol mexicano y que ha crecido mucho”.