Karen Herrera, 23, and her infant son Ivan, on the border in San Diego, California, talking to family members on the Mexican side.

Would a 2,000-mile-long border wall even work?

Would a 2,000-mile-long border wall even work?

Thousands of U.S. agents already patrol the border region where billions of dollars have been spent.

Karen Herrera, 23, and her infant son Ivan, on the border in San Diego,...
Karen Herrera, 23, and her infant son Ivan, on the border in San Diego, California, talking to family members on the Mexican side.

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump is sticking to the promise he made on the first day of his campaign: He will build a wall. “On day one, we will begin working on an impenetrable, physical, tall, powerful, beautiful southern border wall,” he said last week. That would be a 1,989-mile-long wall, from coast to coast.

But building that wall would be very complicated. The U.S. government has already been reinforcing security along its southern border for the past 20 years. It now has about 21,000 border patrol agents, radars, watch towers, spotlights, helicopters, drones – and yes, even a wall.

Lee esta nota en español

In fact, there are already about 700 miles of metal fencing or metal plates and other physical barriers between the United States and Mexico.

Congress approved the construction of a border fence in 2006. Majorities of both parties, including then-Senator Hillary Clinton, voted for the law, which called for a barrier along some 700 miles of the U.S.-Mexico border. By 2011, Border Patrol chief Michael Fisher reported to Congress that 650 miles had been built.

But the Department of Homeland Security reported in 2011 that the border was still “vulnerable to illegal activity, including the smuggling of people and illegal drugs,” according to a U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO).

And while Trump has forcefully made and repeated his promise of a longer wall, the existing barrier has created many headaches for the U.S. government. The so-called Secure Border Initiative cost $4.5 trillion from 2005 to 2010 alone, according to official figures.


Here are some of the challenges Trump could face in building an expanded wall.

1. The Rio Grande

Most of the U.S.-Mexico border is defined by water, not land. The Rio Grande marks the border between Texas and northern Mexico for 1,254 miles. And only about 100 miles are covered by the existing wall.

In fact, treaties between the United States and Mexico forbid the construction of a fence or wall on both the river and along the riverbed.

That would make it pretty hard for Trump to build his wall in many stretches of the border, says Tony Payán, who heads the Mexico Institute at the Wilson Center and teaches on both sides of the border.

“Is it possible to build a border wall? Yes,” Payán says. “Is it possible to build it along the 1,200-mile banks of the Rio Grande? No.”

In places like El Paso, Texas, there is a strip of land between the U.S. side of the river and the fence. But in other places the fence was built several miles from the water.

“What's the use of building a wall ten miles north of the river?” asked Payán.

2. Private properties

In Nogales, Arizona, the backyards and even the kitchens of Mexican homes can be seen across the border wall. Hundreds of American families live close to the current fence.

“Parts of the border, particularly in Texas … are part of private lands … ranches, where the ranchers do not necessarily want to have fencing or a wall close to them," said Doris Meissner, who headed the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services from 1993 to 2000 and is now a senior fellow at the Migration Policy Institute in Washington D.C. "If the federal government would decide to build there, it would [have to] exercise eminent domain.”


Obtaining the land to build just a few miles of wall in the past turned into a major headache for U.S. officials: the government had to file lawsuits against hundreds of landowners. In one case, the government had to pay a woman $56,000 for three acres in San Benito, Texas, that had been in her family for generations.

3. Rough topography and endangered wildlife

“The varied topography of the borderlands—ranging from steep mountains to deep canyons and rivers—make building a barrier in some areas extremely difficult,” professors Joseph Nevins and Timothy Dunn wrote in a 2008 report published by the North American Congress on Latin America (NACLA).

The wall also has caused flooding in southern Arizona after strong rains because it blocks the flow of the water.

The border fence also affects desert wildlife, including jaguars, along parts of the border like the Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge in southern Arizona. That has sparked protests since 2005.

La barrera desde el lado estadounidense en un punto del desierto entre Y...
The border fence between Yuma, Arizona, and Calexico, California.

4. Local opposition

Some locals protested when parts of the wall were built in the 2000s, according to Anna Ochoa O'Leary, a researcher at the University of Arizona.

“The people of Arizona opposed it and there were protests, petitions to the government, lots of meeting with the Border Patrol where residents told the officials about their problems and concerns,” said Ochoa O'Leary.

Most border residents remain opposed to the wall. About 86 percent of those who live on the Mexican side and 72 percent of those on the U.S. side do not want a border wall, according to an April survey by Cronkite News at Arizona State University, Univision Noticias and the Dallas Morning News.

Un agente patrulla en abril de 2013 en La Joya, Texas
An agent patrols in La Joya, Texas in April 2013.

5. A more deadly crossing

More than 6,000 people have died crossing the U.S.-Mexico border since 1998, according to a 2014 International Organization for Migration report.

Several studies link the militarization of the border to the large number of border deaths, says a March report by four university professors in the Journal of Latin American Geography. The report linked the rising number of deaths during border crossings to increased border security since 2006, including the construction of the walls and fences, the deployment of more border agents and the use of new equipment.

Other experts agree there is a correlation between increased border security and border deaths.

"It’s not just the fencing," said Meissner. "It’s the whole border effort which has pushed the trafficking of migrants to more and more remote areas, which tend to be deserts and dangerous areas, so deaths have increased."


6. High costs

The GAO reported in 2009 that the costs of building the wall were far higher than expected, and that land acquisitions had added a significant cost to the project.

The cost of the wall varied by section. From 2006 and 2010, the government spent between $3.9 million and $16 million of taxpayer money for each mile of fence built. In comparison, one mile of a two-lane road can cost some $2 million to $5 million.

There are also required maintenance costs due to the natural wear and tear or damage caused by migrants and drug traffickers. A 2006 Congressional Research Service study put the overall cost of one mile of fence at somewhere between $16 million and $70 million every 25 years.

Each mile of the wall Trump promises to build would cost even more because he has promised improvements. "We will use the best technology, including above- and below-ground sensors," Trump said last week.

7. Native American land

The Native American Tohono O’Odham tribe lives on both sides of the border near Nogales, Arizona. “They did not cross the border,” Payán said. “The border crossed them.”

A wall would divide their land. Tribe members have moved between the north and south sides for centuries to take their children to school, go to the doctor or visit relatives.

But it's increasingly difficult. Today, they can cross if they have cards identifying them as members of the tribe, according to the website Open Borders. The page also notes that about 30 other Native American tribes have been affected by increased U.S. border security.


8. Migration

The National Research Council, which brings together experts on many fields, published a 2011 study arguing that a wall does not dissuade migrants from trying to cross the border, and only makes it more difficult and expensive. What's more, violence in migrants' home countries, especially in Central America, is likely worse than situations on the border.

The study also argued that the wall also keeps people from returning to their home countries.

In recent years, the number of detentions of undocumented migrants along the border has dropped far below the peak years from 1995 to 2006. Border apprehensions have fallen 80% since a peak in 2000, according to David Aguilar, former Chief of the United States Border Patrol during the George W Bush administration.

In the 2015-2016 fiscal year apprehensions at the border are expected to number around 380,000 people, down from 1.6 million in 2000. A 2,000 mile border wall is "ludicrous," Aguilar told Public Radio International on Thursday.

"That is not necessary and it would be a tremendous waste of treasure ... it would not help the situation as it relates to control and management of our borders," added Aguilar who is a principal at Global Security and Innovative Strategies (GSIS) a security consulting and business advisory firm headquartered in Washington, DC.

Undocumented immigrants detained on the southern border
SOURCE: Border Patrol, by fiscal year | UNIVISION

There are many reasons for the drop, and not just the wall, experts say.

“It's very probable that the wall has a lot to do with this, but the arguments for building more wall cannot be based solely on detention statistics,” security consultant Sylvia Longmire wrote in her book Border Insecurity.

Most experts say a variety of factors has affected the number of detentions. The Great Recession reduced the attraction of the U.S. economy and more agents and technology are now on the lookout for illegal crossings.

Aguilar also points out that resources would be better spent on tackling the 500,000 people last year who flew into the country at national airports and overstayed their visas.

9. Drug traffickers

“As long as there are people in the United States ready to pay, drug traffickers will find a way to cross, although that will increase the price,” said Ochoa O'Leary. “It might put more power and more money in the hands of drug traffickers to design better strategies for smuggling drugs into the United States.”


Tunnels along the border are common: at least 100 drug-smuggling tunnels were found under Nogales from 1990 to 2014, according to Border Patrol statistics. On Aug. 29, Border Patrol agents announced the discovery of a tunnel in Nogales that covered 103 feet on the Mexican side and 46 feet into U.S. territory. Smugglers have also used catapults to fling drugs into the United States as well as ultralights.

10. Intrepid climbers

It's happened more than once: young men quickly scale the border wall, in urban areas and broad daylight, carrying what is believed to be drugs on their backs. They are known as narco-spiders, and this video from Nogales shows the barrier is not that difficult to breach.

But migrants can die when they try to climb the wall. In Nogales, authorities found the body of a 32-year-old Mexican woman on June 16. Nogales police spokesman Sgt. Roberto Fierros said the woman apparently fell and hit her head.

The Texas golf course is stuck in no-man's land.
Why a golf course got stuck between the border fence and the Rio Grande
The town of Eagle Pass, Texas, fought to keep the fence out - but lost.
Cruce frontera
In Améxica, commuting requires patience and a passport
On the U.S.-Mexico border, residents are at the mercy of checkpoints that can take hours to cross.
Esta evidencia podría significar que la familia podrá presentar juicio contra el agente de la Patrulla Fronteriza.
El FBI detuvo en San Isidro a una exdiputada de Sinaloa, México, quien ha sido vinculada con el narcotraficante Joaquín 'El Chapo' Guzmán.
Desde el año 1993, más de 1,500 mujeres han desaparecido en este punto de México. El grupo Intocable se unió a varios artistas para mandar un mensaje contra la violencia en el país.
Santiago Tovar fue el buen samaritano que defendió a una mujer de los puñetazos de su novio en un edificio de la capital colombiana. El presunto abusador le fracturó la nariz y lo dejó tendido en el suelo, sin conocimiento. La mujer golpeada no denunció a su pareja.
La edificación del muro en la frontera con México fue una de las promesas de Trump durante su campaña a la presidencia y su financiamiento fue desestimado por el Congreso de Estados Unidos durante la aprobación del presupuesto fiscal.
Así lo dio a conocer el mandatario durante su visita a Iowa, sin embargo, Jorge Silva, exportavoz de la campaña de Hillary Clinton, dice que es una tontería que Trump piense que México pagará ese muro.
Durante un discurso en Iowa, el mandatario aseguró que con su idea se creará energía y se autofinanciará la obra. En su intervención también hizo referencia a la lucha contra la pandilla MS13 y acusó a los inmigrantes de usar los servicios sociales sin tener derecho.
El sujeto llamó al servicio de emergencia de Chicago al ver que su hija, de 3 años de edad, no respiraba. Cuando llegaron, el hombre estaba dándole primeros auxilios a la pequeña, que llegó muerta al hospital.
Los agentes se preparan para rescates de inmigrantes afectados por las altas temperaturas. Según uno de los agentes, el año pasado se registraron más de 80 muertes por el calor.
Solo en Baja California y San Luis Río Colorado, en Sonora, México, cada año entran legalmente entre 700 y 800 mil llantas usadas en EEUU. Con ingenio, las comunidades fronterizas han logrado rescatar los neumáticos usados y convertirlos en fuente de su sustento.
For Cassandra, a Mexican-American teenage girl, the school year meant more than staying up late to get good grades, going to soccer practice and applying to college. It also meant taking care of her three younger siblings while her mom worked long hours at a restaurant. Like her, many Hispanic students struggle to achieve their goals.
Tomas Pendola, from Argentina, is one such teacher. He says he's open about his status so that students can understand the reality of being undocumented.
Artist Nora Valdez and youth in the Boston community are sharing their stories one suitcase at a time at The Urbano Project. At U-LAB Music we documented their process as part of our 'Immigrant Sounds' series.
El secretario de Relaciones Exteriores de México manifestó que la Conferencia para la Prosperidad y la Seguridad en Centroamérica tiene el fin de que los países del Triángulo Norte busquen estabilidad, seguridad y empleos para la permanencia de sus pobladores y agregó que los presidentes Donald Trump y Enrique Peña Nieto han estado en contacto por vía telefónica.
La cumbre realizada en Miami, que reúne a líderes gubernamentales y a empresarios de México, Estados Unidos y América Latina, busca afrontar los desafíos de seguridad, gobierno y economía en Honduras, Guatemala y El Salvador, países del Triángulo Norte.
La menor, de 11 años de edad, desapareció tras subir en un microbús en México y fue hallada con signos de violación y asfixia. El principal acusado del crimen apareció colgado en su celda. Sin embargo, los padres siguen sin encontrar consuelo por su pérdida.
Laura - 'Mi padre se convirtió en mi madre' Accede
Jamás le voy a perdonar a mi padre que se volviera mujer. Por su culpa todos se burlan de mi. Odio a mi padre pues su elección me destruyó la vida.
Mexicanos que trabajaron por más de 10 años en EEUU podrían recibir una pensión al regresar a su país
Representantes del seguro social de Estados Unidos en Tamaulipas ofrecieron este beneficio a personas mayores de 62 años. Para acceder al mismo, los solicitantes únicamente deben presentar un número válido del seguro, un acta de nacimiento y una identificación.
¿El gobierno de EEUU puede quitarle la ciudadanía a un extranjero que mintió para obtenerla? Esto decidió la Corte Suprema
La máxima autoridad judicial dejó claro que el mentir no es razón suficiente para anular la ciudadanía; la falacia tiene que ser grave y relevante para los funcionarios de inmigración que deciden concederla o no, según el Supremo.
Viernes mayormente nublado y con probabilidades de lluvia en Nueva York
El cielo estará un poco despejado durante la mañana, pero a partir del mediodía llega la nubosidad y las probabilidades lluvia y tormentas eléctricas, como consecuencia de la cercanía de la tormenta Cindy. La temperatura máxima para hoy será de 83 grados.
Arrestan al hombre acusado de desnudarse y perseguir a una adolescente en Long Island
La joven denunció que el hombre la estaba acosando en un parque de Babylon, y que ella lo descubrió cuando corría tras ella con la ropa en la mano. La menor de 17 años alcanzó a escapar del lugar, y el sujeto fue arrestado.
Autoridades buscan al sospechoso de pinchar las llantas de varios autos en Queens
El hombre fue visto dañando las llantas de al menos 10 vehículos, y luego huyó del lugar. Entre los carros afectados se encuentran varios de alta gama.
Investigan el caso de un hombre de 55 años apuñalado en El Bronx
Las autoridades revelaron imágenes del sospechoso de herir a la víctima en los dos hombros con un objeto sin razón aparente, el pasado 17 de junio. El herido pudo caminar hasta un hospital del sector para recibir atención médica.
¿Shannon de Lima o JLo? Canelo decide contra las cuerdas
El boxeador mexicano reveló 10 cosas que no sabías de sus gustos personales.
Toda la información y noticias sobre lo último del fútbol mundial
Top 5 de jugadores que han sido escogidos primeros en sus respectivos Draft de la NBA
Magic Johnson, Lebron James y Kareem Abdul-Jabbar están en la privilegiada lista. Ellos demostraron su talento en el básquetbol universitario y se hicieron leyenda en la máxima categoría.
América empata 1-1 con Atlante en su primer duelo de pretemporada
Carlos Orrantia se estrenó con las Águilas. Los de Coapa también anunciaron el 18 de julio como el día en que jugarán a beneficio de Ezequiel Orozco ante Murciélagos.