Obama has made criminals the centerpiece of his immigration enforcement strategy - just like Trump wants to do.

Trump echoes Obama in plans to deport 'criminal' immigrants

Trump echoes Obama in plans to deport 'criminal' immigrants

Immigrants can be deported for a host of violations - including the act of crossing the border. So is Trump proposing anything new?

Obama has made criminals the centerpiece of his immigration enforcement...
Obama has made criminals the centerpiece of his immigration enforcement strategy - just like Trump wants to do.

Donald Trump's campaign has sent conflicting signals about his immigration policy in recent days, but on one point it’s stayed the course: the need to deport immigrants who are “criminals.”

During a town hall Tuesday, Trump said that he is open to "softening" laws dealing with undocumented immigrants. His pivot on the issue came after a meeting with Hispanic leaders Saturday, when he told them that he plans to release a new immigration policy that could include legalizing some undocumented immigrants.

But on Fox News Monday, Trump reiterated his as yet unspecified plan to zero in on criminal immigrants. "The first thing we're gonna do, if and when I win, is we're gonna get rid of all the bad ones," he said. Meanwhile, his campaign has spoken of the need for tougher border security - including Trump's wall - and enforcement of immigration laws.

Lee esta nota en español

But what sort of crimes might Trump be referring to? Experts say defining “criminal immigrants” is problematic, in part because of the range of crimes that can trigger deportation - including the simple act of entering the country.

Targeting criminals for deportation

While Trump has continued to rail against so-called criminal immigrants, in reality the Obama administration has already made this the centerpiece of its enforcement approach. Immigration authorities must prioritize those who committed felonies, three or more misdemeanors, and significant misdemeanors for deportation, among other infractions, as detailed in a Department of Homeland Security memo.


"We’re going to keep focusing enforcement resources on actual threats to our security," Obama said when he announced the policy in November 2014. "Felons, not families. Criminals, not children. Gang members, not a mom who’s working hard to provide for her kids."

But that doesn't always work in practice: most deportation cases don't involve serious crimes. From October 2015 to July 2016, 84% of deportation cases in the courts stemmed from immigration violations, according to the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC).

And even if immigrants get detained by police without getting charged, such as for a traffic violation, they still risk deportation. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) can ask jails to keep undocumented immigrants in custody to transfer them to immigration detention centers - and then potentially deport them. About half of ICE requests for jails to hold immigrants are for people without criminal records, TRAC found.

Immigration advocates have criticized the current administration for targeting immigrants without serious criminal records and dubbed Obama as the " deporter-in-chief" since his administration has deported more immigrants than any other president.

"We don't have to wait for President Trump as the 'Deportation Force' is already in action," wrote prominent immigration attorney Matthew Kolken on his blog.

What is a "criminal" immigrant?

"It's something politicians and government officials tend to bounce around," said César García Hernández, a law professor at the University of Denver and the author of the Crimmigration blog. "Other than the political symbolism of that rhetoric, it's a term that's largely meaningless."


One reason is that the number of deportable offenses has grown since the mid-1980s under federal legislation.

"There's an enormous range of criminal activity that can result in deportation - everything from jumping a turnstile in the New York City subway system to the most serious of crimes," said García Hernández. "Most [immigrants] who we're seeing throughout the Obama administration being targeted for criminal activity are folks who are not murderers and rapists; they're people engaged in much more ordinary criminal activity, including things like immigration offenses."

That's because some immigration violations are considered crimes under federal law. For example, if a non-citizen crosses the border without going through an inspection with authorities, he can be charged with a misdemeanor. Illegal reentry - crossing the border without inspection after being deported - is a felony.

A law for Mexicans

Congress first made immigration a crime in 1929. Five years earlier, in 1924, an immigration act was passed that explicitly sought to keep the United States “white” through a stringent national origins quota system. But the law exempted people from the Western Hemisphere from the quota system and a record number of Mexican immigrants entered the United States to work on farm lands. As a result, in 1929, South Carolina senator and white supremacist Coleman Livingston Blease introduced a legislative compromise: Mexican workers could come and go, but the federal government would ensure they went home, through criminalizing unlawful entry. Immigration law and criminal law were effectively fused.


“That was the first law to criminalize immigration, intentionally designed to control Mexican migration to the United States,” says UCLA history professor Kelly Lytle Hernandez. “And that’s the same law that is still in effect today when we talk about criminal entry into the U.S.”

The 1929 law passed legislation to turn crossing the border into a misdemeanor, and crossing the border after deportation a felony.

Why words matter in the immigration debate

Just using the term "criminal" to describe immigrants is problematic, some immigration advocates say. "The fact is that the vast majority of immigrants are not 'criminals' in any meaningful sense of the word," explains a 2015 American Immigration Council report on the criminalization of immigration.

"Those wholesale labels are not helpful," said Avideh Moussavian, a policy attorney at the National Immigration Law Center in Washington, DC. "It's a way of dehumanizing millions of people that are parents, colleagues, neighbors."

And it's precisely this kind of rhetoric that helps shape how Americans feel about immigration, according to Karthick Ramakrishnan, a professor of public policy and political science at the University of California, Riverside. He co-authored the forthcoming book "Framing Immigrants" from the Russell Sage Foundation, which analyzes how the media covers immigration and how the public's views change as a result.

Through a series of surveys since 2007, he and fellow researchers found that people exposed to media framing immigrants as lawbreakers become less amenable to legalization and more likely to favor deportation.


"When you look at the discourse and people's perception of reality, the crime statistics seem to be less important than these claims or even just these adjectives that are repeated time and again," said Ramakrishnan. "Study after study has shown that immigrants are much less likely to commit crimes than the native-born population."

Indeed, perception may be the key to understanding Trump’s about-turn on immigration. The appearance of his softening may appeal to independents who are on the fence about voting for him, while his hardline base still expects him to strictly enforce immigration laws.

When he launched his presidential campaign in June last year, Trump made a direct link between immigration and crime. "When Mexico sends its people they’re not sending their best,” he said. “They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists, and some, I assume, are good people.”

Lytle Hernandez, the UCLA historian, calls it “code talk.” Trump has “decoded what other people have often said in much more complicated ways,” she says.

Donald Trump obtuvo esta semana los niveles más bajos de aprobación desd...
Trump says he's not flip-flopping on immigration
Trump is set to lay out his immigration plan next week. His campaign manager Kellyanne Conway said it is "to be determined" whether Trump’s immigration plan will include a "deportation force" as previously promised.
Mario Rodríguez, head of the Hispanic 100 group in California, and Jovit...
Trump now says he plans to legalize some undocumented immigrants
Sources tell Univision that Trump plans to announce a major shift on immigration policy next week. The Republican candidate met Saturday with Hispanic leaders who said he told them he regrets prior comments about Mexicans.
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rall...
In latest hedge Trump says immigration laws can be softened
Trump confirms Univision reports that if elected he may not deport all undocumented immigrants as previously promised.
For Cassandra, a Mexican-American teenage girl, the school year meant more than staying up late to get good grades, going to soccer practice and applying to college. It also meant taking care of her three younger siblings while her mom worked long hours at a restaurant. Like her, many Hispanic students struggle to achieve their goals.
Tomas Pendola, from Argentina, is one such teacher. He says he's open about his status so that students can understand the reality of being undocumented.
Artist Nora Valdez and youth in the Boston community are sharing their stories one suitcase at a time at The Urbano Project. At U-LAB Music we documented their process as part of our 'Immigrant Sounds' series.
Oscar Lopez, a Puerto Rican nationalist who advocates for independence of the island nation, was jailed for nearly 36 years after being charged for seditious conspiracy against the U.S. government. Univision News traveled to Puerto Rico and talked to family members and those who in the last decade fought for his release.
Univision News traveled to several Texas cities to ask a mayor, a sheriff, a congressman and a council member how the anti-sanctuary law will affect their communities and how they'll be challenging it in court.
Nestor Duarte was driving his car in Key West, Florida, when Monroe sheriff deputy David Lariz pulled him over and asked for his papers. Lariz is the same officer who recently asked a Honduran man who had been hit by a car if he was "illegal."
Mimi Martinez, 30, arrived to the United States when she was five years old. Her mom stayed behind in Mexico. Now a legal resident, she was recently able to travel to see her mother in Mexico after 25 years.
Rejection hurts, but it’s not the end of the world. Here is what you need to be admitted to the schools you apply to, and when you’re not, how to proceed. Step number one: don’t panic.
After a 24-year-old Hispanic man tried to help her, Tiffany Cormier became visibly upset and threatened the man, calling him "spic" and saying "They need to take his f**king ass back to Mexico."
It was the biggest ever anti-gang operation in the area, the result of an investigation that began in 2014 during the Obama administration. Most of those arrested were US citizens.
When 5-year-old Elián was rescued off the Florida coast in 1999 he became the center of an international custody battle that pitted family members against one another and tested U.S. foreign policy at a crucial moment in history. Now 23, Elián talks about his experience and the changing nature of U.S.-Cuba relations in CNN film that hits theaters May 19.
Freed after more more than 35 years in prison, the 74-year-old independence hero tells Univision that "all means" are legitimate to end U.S. "colonial" rule. But López Rivera says he personally opposes violent acts.
Nelson Denis, author of 'War Against All Puerto Ricans,' details how the commonwealth's 119-year-long association with the U.S. has produced total economic and governing dependence. With over $70 billion in crushing debt, Puerto Rico's governor turned to the courts on Wednesday to put certain debts before a federal bankruptcy court.
We traveled to Ciudad Juárez to see if hundreds of thousands of jobs in the Mexican maquiladora industry would return to the United States if Trump were to modify or abandon the NAFTA free trade agreement, as his government is considering. A border tax would have serious consequences in Mexican cities.
Although the deportation numbers for Donald Trump's administration have kept pace with the Obama administration, images of operatives and arrests, hate attacks on different minorities, and the President's own pronouncements have triggered alarms in the immigrant community ... and fear. One of Trump's most vocal campaign promises has begun to come true. And we are not talking about the physical wall, but a deeper, taller and more effective one: the wall of fear.
The young man who was allegedly tortured in Venezuela spoke with Univision News as he left immigration detention, after a day after his arrest. "Thank God I'm out."
"Es falso, es un chisme que ella se inventó", así responde Eleazar Gómez a las acusaciones de su exnovia
Eleazar Gómez salió al paso de las acusaciones que su exnovia, Vanessa López hizo en su contra y esto es lo que el actor dijo al respecto.
Manuel 'El Loco' Valdés se recupera tras cirugía y nos dijo cómo se siente
Manuel 'El Loco' Valdés nos contó sobre su estado de salud tras la operación a la que fue sometido para retirlarle un tumor que tenía en la frente. Mira lo que nos dijo.
Shannon de Lima no debe hacerse muchas ilusiones con 'Canelo', según Kate del Castillo
La actriz mexicana asegura que el boxeador cambia tanto de novias como guantes, por lo que ella ni pierde el tiempo en conocer a su nueva pareja, la exesposa de Marc Anthony.
Escucha los horóscopos del día lunes con Mizada Mohamed en HOY
La astróloga y vidente hizo las predicciones del día lunes para cada uno de los signos zodiacales.
Los científicos están de acuerdo con que el cambio climático es real pero no en cómo derrotarlo
Mientras un famoso estudio dice que el camino es pasar a un 100% a energías renovables lo más rápido posible, para otros el camino más factible es una fórmula energética mixta.
Inauguran una nueva área de insectos del Zoológico de San Antonio
Este martes la admisión al Zoológico de San Antonio tendrá un costo de siete dólares en conmemoración de la apertura de la nueva área llamada “Bugmania”.
El nuevo alcalde y la primera dama de San Antonio nos hablan de su vida familiar y su oposición a la SB4
El nuevo alcalde de San Antonio, Ron Nirenberg, y su esposa, Erika Nirenberg, visitaron los estudios de Univision 41 para hablarnos sobre su vida familiar, los cambios que lo esperan y su oposición a la SB4.
Vuelve la lluvia a San Antonio esta semana
Nuestro Radar 41 muestra que se esperan precipitaciones en algunos sectores hacia al oeste y sur de San Antonio.
Golazos de fantasía y de colección en la semana 17 de la MLS
La fecha más reciente del fútbol estadonunidense regaló goles en todos los estilos. Aquí te presentamos los mejores 5.
Poderío azul: Así vestirán las estrellas de la MLS en el All-Star Game ante el Real Madrid
El uniforme -de diseño clásico- incluirá referencias a Estados Unidos y Canadá, los dos países en los que se juega laliga norteamericana.
El Super Nintendo Classic Edition es una realidad
Llegará en septiembre con un juego inédito.
Brutal batalla campal entre barras bravas del América y Pumas en Estados Unidos
En medio de un partido benéfico entre leyendas de Águilas y Pumas en California, varios aficionados se enfrentaron en el campo y algunos terminaron arrestados por la policía local.