publicidad
The billing agent said, "Why do you illegals come to this country? What are you doing here? Go back," Gricelda told Univision.

"She humiliated me in the midst of the pain": When a trip to the ER comes with hate

"She humiliated me in the midst of the pain": When a trip to the ER comes with hate

A reader tells Univision she was verbally abused at a hospital in the midst of an illness. The woman, an undocumented immigrant, says she's never felt more fearful during the more than 20 years she's lived in the United States. A lawyer responds: "Whether or not you're undocumented is not relevant to your care."

The billing agent said, "Why do you illegals come to this country?...
The billing agent said, "Why do you illegals come to this country? What are you doing here? Go back," Gricelda told Univision.

In March, when Gricelda entered an Illinois emergency room, she was seeking relief from an intestinal obstruction. In addition to the severe pain, she was vomiting and unable to tolerate food.

But two days later, she left the hospital feeling even worse, after a billing agent allegedly lashed out at her with insults and threats over her undocumented status.

Gricelda, 53, who is from Mexico and has been in the United States since 1994, requested Univision News use only her first name. According to her testimony, the hospital employee, who identified herself as Dora Jackson, entered the room while Gricelda was under the effect of morphine and “with a feeding tube.” Jackson demanded to know why Gricelda had presented the hospital with a Mexican identification card, and why she did not have a driver’s license.

But the incident didn't stop there, according to Gricelda, who is a mother of four. Jackson then pressed for information on her immigration status and details on how she intended to pay for her medical care, even threatening to follow her. She repeatedly insulted undocumented immigrants.

“She said to me: 'How are you going to pay the hospital? I don’t know why the illegals want the hospital to pay for them,’” Gricelda said, adding that the incident occurred at Delnor Community Hospital, 45 miles west of Chicago. “Why do you illegals come to this country? What are you doing here? Go back.’” Gricelda said Jackson spoke in fluent Spanish. “She spoke to me in my language so it was perfectly clear.”

publicidad

Lea esta nota en español.

The incident occurred over two days and ultimately led Gricelda to leave the hospital before she felt better, she said.

Un paciente no está en la obligación de proveer detalles sobre su estatu...
Any individual in the United States in need of medical care should be able to access that care without fear of intimidation, lawyer Steven Monroy told Univision.

When reached by telephone, Jackson declined to provide comment and hung up.

Christopher King, a spokesman from the Delnor Hospital, says the hospital’s financial counselors are “trained to provide information in a professional manner.”

“We believe that occurred with [this patient],” King said. “We regret [Gricelda’s] interpretation of the discussions.”

Relacionado
In November, this family's home was vandalized with racist messages:...
Six months of hate: how anti-immigrant sentiment is affecting Latinos in the United States

In recent months, incidents fueled by bias and hate have targeted Latinos around the country, in small towns and big cities, coast-to-coast. Gricelda’s is one of hundreds of reports that Univision has received through Documenting Hate, a project that tracks these incidents around the country since the presidential election. Hers is the only incident we've received that occurred in a hospital.

Experts say such incidents, as well as tougher immigration enforcement pushed by the Trump administration, is leading undocumented immigrants to report fewer crimes and abuses due to fears they might be reported to authorities and deported.

And that has a direct impact on health, too. According to a report from the nonpartisan Hastings Center, 80 percent of undocumented immigrants in the United States are Hispanic -- a group that is more likely to suffer from chronic illness and less likely to have health insurance compared to the general population, citing official data.

publicidad

Patient protection laws

A lawyer told Univision that Gricelda should never have faced such treatment.

Any individual in the United States in need of medical care should be able to access that care without fear of intimidation, regardless of their immigration status, said Steven Monroy, a lawyer from the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund, MALDEF.

“Hospitals are supposed to be safe zones,” Monroy said.

He points to a number of privacy laws that safeguard patients’ information, as well as laws that protect patients from discrimination based on their race, country of origin, financial means and other factors. The Federal Emergency Medical Treatment & Labor Act (EMTALA), enacted in 1986, requires medical facilities to take people in during emergencies regardless of their ability to pay.

Hospital staff have “no legal obligation to ask patients their immigration status,” Monroy said.

That goes for immigration officials, too. According to an October 24, 2011 memo titled “Enforcement Actions at or Focused on Sensitive Locations,” issued by former Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Director John Morton, immigration officials cannot take enforcement action at hospitals. It also ensures that ICE agents won’t intervene at schools, places of worship, funerals, weddings or marches.

Bajo ley federal, los hospitales son considerados zonas seguras del cump...
"Hospital staff should not be reaching out to ICE or inquiring about immigration status because there is no federal law that they should take it upon themselves to check."

“Hospital staff should not be reaching out to ICE or inquiring about immigration status because there is no federal law that they should take it upon themselves to check,” Monroy said. “A patient has no obligation to give that information.”

States often implement their own immigrants-rights laws to further protect patients, such as ensuring that state police officers do not enter sensitive locations. In California, a law ensures health coverage to undocumented immigrants under age 19.

In May, the Illinois General Assembly passed the Illinois Trust Act, which would prevent law enforcement agencies in the state from assisting in immigration actions unless there's a warrant, and would offer protections from immigration enforcement to safe havens like schools. It’s currently awaiting final approval from the state;s Republican governor.

publicidad

As a general rule, Monroy said patients should not give more information than is necessary for their treatment. “They should avoid disclosing anything related to immigration status,” he said. “If asked, say ‘why is this relevant?’”

Patients also always have a right to ask to speak with a patient advocate, the person in charge of privacy or an attorney, if they feel they’re being discriminated against, he said. Often that information is listed in the emergency room. Groups like MALDEF or the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) may also be able to provide advice.

“The sooner people reach out, the better,” Monroy said.

“I can’t get over it”

At Delnor Hospital, Gricelda told Jackson that her insistent questions were “irrelevant.” But Jackson continued to push, Gricelda said. That led Gricelda to feel increasingly worse.

"In all my life, I think that was the most horrible thing that can be done to a human being. What hurt me the most was that she came and stood in front of me while I was suffering from extreme pain,” Gricelda said.

“I had never felt such urgency to leave a place, feeling that I was in danger because of my race, my origin, my nationality … that my stay in this country was in danger and that at any moment, for all the hatred she expressed towards Mexican immigrants, she could call immigration to take me,” Gricelda added.

On her second day in the hospital, Gricelda was still in pain, with severe nausea. But she lied to a nurse: after eating, she said she felt better in order to be discharged.

publicidad

"I felt vulnerable, in danger, emotionally harassed and discriminated against,” she said. “In a place where I am supposed to feel cared for and protected.”

Have you been the victim of or witness to a hate incident or crime? Share your story.

publicidad
publicidad
Presidents don't usually pardon criminals until they have been sentenced or have at least expressed some regret, but this was not the case with Arpaio, who spoke to Univision News two weeks after being forgiven by his ally, Donald Trump.
During a meeting in the Oval office Friday, the president was asked by reporters about the future of DACA, to which he responded that a decision was coming soon. "We love the dreamers, we love everyone," he added.
Nilsa Huete is an undocumented Honduran immigrant living in Key West, Florida. In the last five months, five of her family members have been arrested by agents from the Monroe County Sheriff's Office. Now she’s fighting against the deportation of her daughter and brother.
The former Arizona sheriff pardoned by President Trump is one of the most unpopular figures in the Hispanic community. For 24 years he was sheriff of the fourth largest county in the country and was convicted in July 2017 of ignoring a court order to stop his officers from racial profiling of Hispanics.
The former Republican presidential candidate says a Senate immigration proposal that would cut immigration in half is flawed, but he backs idea of merit-based points system.
Republican senators continue this week to seek ways to repeal the existing health care law known as Obamacare. Their proposal includes a halt in reimbursement for Medicaid patients who visit Planned Parenthood’s clinics. This is the testimony of a 27-year-old woman who relies on the reproductive health services offered by the organization.
The footage shows a man wearing a badge, apparently from the local sheriff’s department, and claiming to be bail bonds agent. A lawyer then rebukes and questions his authority.
Maty Muy, a Guatemalan immigrant, went to renew her work permit at an ICE office and ended up facing a nightmare. Authorities placed a GPS monitor on her ankle and sent her husband to a detention facility. Now, she has taken over the family business – a tire and auto repair shop – while facing deportation.
This 9 year-old child is one of the 75 million people who benefit from the Medicaid program. His parents explain in this video why they fear losing the assistance they receive if the large cuts proposed by Republicans are approved.
This is what Greek artist Eleni means when she speaks about the power of the voice. She improvises a sing-along with a group of immigrants, refugees and allies in Boston's Urbano Project and the result was just beautiful.
Eleni Arapoglou uses new sounds and rhythms to preserve her roots. Eleni is part of the U-Lab 'Immigrant Sounds' sessions that celebrate World Refugee Day and Immigrant Heritage Month.
There has always been movement of people, and as we commemorate World Refugee Day on June 20th a group of musicians, activists and community members got together at The Urbano Project​ in Boston to share their experiences and reflect on the diversity that makes up American society: "The direction of where the world is going is encouraging us all, almost forcing us all, to break down those walls."
La cantante Eleni interpreta 'Milo mou kai mantarini', grabada en exclusiva para U-LAB Music como parte de las sesiones 'Immigrant Sounds' en honor al Mes de la Herencia del Inmigrante y al Día Mundial del Refugiado. Featuring Vasilis Kostas en el laúd.
Artist Nora Valdez and youth in the Boston community are sharing their stories one suitcase at a time at The Urbano Project. At U-LAB Music we documented their process as part of our 'Immigrant Sounds' series.
Nestor Duarte was driving his car in Key West, Florida, when Monroe sheriff deputy David Lariz pulled him over and asked for his papers. Lariz is the same officer who recently asked a Honduran man who had been hit by a car if he was "illegal."
Mimi Martinez, 30, arrived to the United States when she was five years old. Her mom stayed behind in Mexico. Now a legal resident, she was recently able to travel to see her mother in Mexico after 25 years.
Agentes migratorios entran a propiedad privada sin aparente permiso y detienen a inmigrante en Oregon
Un compañero del detenido grabó la escena para luego publicarla en las redes sociales donde el video ya cuenta con más de 40,000 visitas. Horas después del incidente, autoridades señalaron que se trató de un error por lo que dejaron en libertad al trabajador.
Barack Obama y George W. Bush arremeten contra las políticas de Donald Trump
Desde diferentes escenarios, los dos expresidentes cuestionaron fuertemente las políticas del actual gobierno del mandatario de los Estados Unidos.
Hugh Hefner hace historia al ser el primer hombre en la portada de la revista Playboy
La famosa revista "del conejito" le rinde tributo a su creador Hugh Hefner, después de su muerte eel 27 de septiembre de 2017. Esta es la primera vez que un hombre aparece en la portada de dicha publicación.
Puerto Rico entre la angustia y la esperanza tras un mes del paso del huracán María
Se completan 30 días luego de que la isla viviera uno de los más fuertes y devastadores huracanes en su historia. Más del 80 por ciento de la población sigue sin energía eléctrica, el 30 por ciento vive sin agua potable y decenas de personas no tienen un lugar donde vivir.
publicidad
Alertan a bañistas de la playa Surfside por muestras que evidencian baja calidad del agua
El Departamento de Salud de Florida le tomó muestras al agua de la zona, con resultados que no alcanzan los estándares de calidad necesarios para los bañistas.
Con gritos de rechazo fue recibido Richard Spencer en la Universidad de Florida
Los asistentes acallaron el polémico discurso del líder de la supremacía blanca. Cientos de personas se manifestaron a la salida del recinto donde dos fueron arrestadas y al menos cinco sufrieron heridas leves.
Accidente en la autopista Turnpike deja un muerto, un herido y congestión vehicular
El accidente registrado durante la madrugada de este viernes está siendo investigado por las autoridades, que informaron sobre una persona muerta y otra herida. El tráfico de vehículos está afectado.
Senadores demócratas piden a la administración Trump extender el TPS
A través de una carta dirigida al secretario de Estado Rex Tillerson un grupo de legisladores resaltó el aporte económico que generan unos 200,000 salvadoreños y 61,000 hondureños que viven y trabajan en EEUU amparados bajo el TPS.
Joseph Blatter asistirá al Mundial de Rusia por "invitación de Vladimir Putin"
El expresidente de la FIFA prepara un libro y aseguró que el Presidente de Rusia lo contempla para estar en la próxima Copa del Mundo.
Real Madrid
Keylor Navas, baja por una lesión muscular en la pierna derecha
El portero costarricense del Real Madrid se perderá el partido contra el Eibar tras recaer de una lesión muscular en la pierna derecha.
Adiós al 'milagro': los Cubs caen ante los Dodgers y se despiden de la Serie Mundial
La novena de Chicago perdió este jueves el quinto juego 1-11 contra la de Los Ángeles, que ganó la serie con un contundente 4-1y regresa después de 29 años a esta instancia definitiva. Pese a que los aficionados de los cachorros estaban convencidos de la remontada, el equipo no pudo revertir la situación.
Los Dodgers regresan a la Serie Mundial luego de 29 años y en Los Ángeles se desata la 'locura'
Los aficionados de la novena californiana se tomaron las calles de la ciudad para festejar la victoria 11-1 de su equipo frente a los Cubs de Chicago, lo que significó el campeonato de la Liga Nacional y la superioridad en la serie que terminó 4-1.