A demonstration marking International Women’s Day in Mexico City.

Street harassment is a public health problem: The case of Mexico City

Street harassment is a public health problem: The case of Mexico City

According to a multi-country poll by YouGov, Mexico City ranks first among 16 international cities surveyed for physical and verbal harassment on public transportation.

A demonstration marking International Women’s Day in Mexico City.
A demonstration marking International Women’s Day in Mexico City.

Lauren Ferreira Cardoso, University of Pennsylvania

“I actually don’t remember when I was first harassed on the street, but I do remember when I first experienced it as an abusive act: I was an adolescent traveling with my mom in a crowded underground wagon, where men could easily touch women without anyone noticing and with little possibility to prevent it.”

This was the experience of Lucía Vázquez, a researcher in Mexico City, Mexico. Unfortunately, her story is not unique.

According to a multi-country poll by YouGov, Mexico City ranks first among 16 international cities surveyed for physical and verbal harassment on public transportation. Street harassment, a form of gender-based violence against women, can include any act or comment perpetrated in a public space that is unwanted and threatening, and is motivated by a person’s perceived sex or gender.

Violence against women in public spaces is not exclusive to Mexico City, of course. Experiences of street harassment – from being whistled at to being touched without consent – are reported each day on crowd-sourced websites like Hollaback and Safecity in dozens of other locations from New York and New Delhi, to Lawrence, Kansas and Lubbock, Texas.

There is still much to be learned about how harassment and feeling unsafe in public spaces affects the well-being of women and girls – a topic I focus on in my doctoral research at the University of Pennsylvania’s School of Social Policy and Practice – but the global scale of these experiences is concerning. Studies documenting the prevalence of street harassment in more than 35 countries show it could have widespread health effects across the globe.


Street harassment in Mexico City

One of the latest studies on this issue aimed to understand the extent of street harassment and its impacts on women, girls and communities in Mexico City. All of the women in this study had previously screened positive for intimate partner violence, a prerequisite for inclusion in the parent study.

Paola Abril Campos, a doctoral student at the Harvard’s T.H. Chan School of Public Health, is a native of Mexico City. She said in an interview for this article:

“Growing up, I learned to fake a phone call to my parents to feel safer and avoid harassment. I learned to wear not the clothes I wanted, but the clothes that made me feel ‘safe.’ I learned to take quick detours during my daily commute. And I learned to put up with the impotence I felt when harassed.”

Her experiences motivated her to conduct a study on street harassment that was published in January in Salud Pública de México, a journal published by Mexico’s National Institute of Public Health.

In this study, Campos and colleagues surveyed 952 women who were seeking health care in Mexico City’s community health clinics. More than 60 percent of the women, 62.8 percent, reported experiencing at least one form of street harassment in the past month alone. For one in four women, 26.8 percent, the abuse was physical.

The study found that the harassment, or fear of harassment, had negative impacts on the daily routines of these women. Nearly 70 percent reported some type of disruptions in their mobility, including missing, being late to or having to change jobs or schools. And yet, Campos said, “The costs and consequences of street harassment to women’s lives have remained invisible.”


The study also found that street harassment may diminish women’s sense of connectedness and trust in their community. Social isolation from one’s community can have long-term implications for well-being and can lead to chronic disease and poor mental health. Therefore, street harassment may contribute to these other public health concerns.

For the women in this study who were also victims of intimate partner violence, violence is a threat in both public and private. Jhumka Gupta, a global and community health professor at George Mason University and senior author of the study, stated: “Comprehensive interventions are needed to ensure women and girls’ safety both in public settings and in private spaces.”

Emerging solutions

There is some political will to address the issue in Mexico City. In conjunction with local authorities, UN Women has launched the program “Safe Cities and Safe Public Spaces for Women and Girls,” which is promoting women’s safety through, among other mechanisms, providing women-only buses throughout the city.

The city’s mayor, Miguel Ángel Mancera Espinosa, is also supporting an initiative that distributes whistles to women that they can use when someone harasses them. The idea is to “break the silence” and bring attention to harassers.

Activists have been vocal too. Las Morras, a group of four young Mexican women, have been using hidden cameras to record harassment, which they post on their YouTube channel. Las Hijas De Violencia, another activist group, has a more unconventional approach. Whenever they are harassed they turn on loud punk music and shoot a confetti cannon at the perpetrator. Their intention is to take back their power in a nonviolent way.


These efforts are a step toward acknowledging that street harassment is pervasive and pernicious. However, these approaches share a critical shortcoming: The onus of action remains with women. They are asked to ride different buses, carry noisemakers, expose their abuse and confront their attackers. Still lacking are interventions that change the behavior of perpetrators, and challenge the prevailing social norms that deem street harassment, as at best, an inconsequential part of city living.

Street harassment is a common problem in the United States too. A recent nationally representative survey found that 65 percent of U.S. women have faced street harassment at some point in their lifetimes. These numbers may be rising.

The Southern Poverty Law Center reports that there has been a post-election uptick of harassment and intimidation of many marginalized groups, including women. However, in February a new bill aimed at preventing street harassment in Washington, D.C. was introduced to its city council. It seeks to “eradicate street harassment in the District of Columbia through education, awareness, data collection and culture change.” The bill is broad and inclusive in its definition of street harassment and comprehensive in its approach. Will other cities follow its lead?

Lauren Ferreira Cardoso, Ph.D. Candidate in Social Welfare, University of Pennsylvania

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

The Conversation

They grew up in Chicago and their husbands, the Flores twins (aka ‘Los Mellizos’), worked for the Sinaloa cartel. The twins later became DEA informants in Mexico who helped bring down El Chapo Guzman. They have written a book, Cartel Wives, telling their story as a lesson to others not to fall for the narco life, and they regret what they put their families through. "Our fathers put on their suit of armor and their badge, and they are going out there on the streets of Chicago,” Mia confesses. “It’s the very same streets that our husbands were flooding with drugs.”
Nelson Denis, author of 'War Against All Puerto Ricans,' details how the commonwealth's 119-year-long association with the U.S. has produced total economic and governing dependence. With over $70 billion in crushing debt, Puerto Rico's governor turned to the courts on Wednesday to put certain debts before a federal bankruptcy court.
We traveled to Ciudad Juárez to see if hundreds of thousands of jobs in the Mexican maquiladora industry would return to the United States if Trump were to modify or abandon the NAFTA free trade agreement, as his government is considering. A border tax would have serious consequences in Mexican cities.
A wave of demonstrations in Venezuela has left several dead and hundreds more detained in the last two weeks. Univision reporter Tamoa Calzadilla explains how a democratic crisis, inflation and shortages of food and medicine have sent Venezuelans into the streets.
Gina Potes and Patricia Espitia were attacked with acid in Colombia, a country with one of the highest number of attacks of this kind. They have created a sisterhood, which they have used to help other victims and raise awareness about these brutal attacks.
As the legend goes, a UFO landed in Capilla del Monte in 1986, leaving a mark on the side of the Pajarillo mountains. Since then, this Argentinian village has lived off UFO tourism. It's currently hosting its annual Alien Festival.
The announcement to scrap the benefits came as a bucket of cold water for the Cuban migrants who just arrived in the United States. As this group waits for their papers, the uncertainty grows on whether they will ever be reunited with the relatives they left on the island.
A group of Argentines diagnosed with mental illness set up a radio station from where they broadcast their experiences
How Fidel Castro's plan to save Cuban baseball unraveled. The once mighty amateur baseball champions have lost much of their talent in recent years to U.S. Major League Baseball. Now the Cuban government is in discussions with MLB to stop the desertions. But will a Trump presidency make that more difficult?
A half-century of armed conflict has left behind 8 million victims in Colombia. It has also affected the country's unique natural resources. We explore the war’s impact on Colombia’s environment.
Forty three students in Mexico were abducted two years ago, and to this day, none have ever been found. When his son Jorge disappeared, New York City plumber Antonio Tizapa began to run marathons, not to win, but to send a message at the end of each race: he won’t stop until he finds his son or the truth about what really happened on that shameful day. On Sunday, Antonio and 20 friends will be running the New York City Marathon.
The evidence against El Chapo: undercover recordings, intercepted communications, protected witnesses’ declarations, drug seizures, and a confession. As U.S. prosecutors prepare their case against the world's most feared drug trafficker, this is what the government's case is built around.
Six months after the U.S. president visited the island, Cubans are divided over his impact. A government reform program is on hold as anxious residents pray for a tourist invasion.
Cubans seeking to flee the island are taking to rustic, homemade boats in increasing numbers since the U.S. and Cuba agreed to normalize relations 18 months ago.
La Tropical beer was popular in Cuba before the 1959 Revolution, but the factory was nationalized and the brewery later closed.
El análisis de Ethor: ¿Por qué América se clasificó a Liguilla y Chivas se quedó por fuera?
El Dios trueno de Tepito explicó cómo las Aguilas se metieron a la fase final del Apertura 2017 y los de Guadalajara se quedaron por fuera. Aquí su divertido análisis.
Lenny de la Rosa bromea sobre su relación con la prensa
El actor, cantante y bailarín cubano, Lenny de la Rosa dio su opinión sobre la relación prensa-famosos y confesó cuál fue la lección que aprendió de sus fricciones con los medios.
Las tarjetas del Conde K: Cruz Azul, amonestado con amarilla por llegar a Liguilla de milagro
Destacado con tarjeta verde está el cuadro del ‘Turco’ Mohamed, el gran favorito para ganar el doblete en el Apertura 2017. La roja directa fue para Chivas, la decepción del torneo por no defender su corona.
Aleida Núñez revela qué hace para sobrellevar su reciente divorcio
Por primera vez en público desde que confirmara su divorcio de Pablo Glogovsky, la actriz Aleida Nuñez reveló cómo está sobrellevando su separación, y gracias a quién lo está superando.
Asesinan a tiros a representante de Derechos Humanos en el norte de México
Los hechos sucedieron alrededor de las 19 horas en una céntrica avenida de Baja California Sur, cuando dos sujetos a bordo de otro vehículo se le acercaron y dispararon varias ráfagas de fuego.
Juez en California bloquea permanentemente la orden de Trump contra las ciudades santuario
Este fallo es definitivo y se dio en respuesta a las demandas presentadas por dos condados de California, San Francisco y Santa Clara.
"Estamos desesperados, con impotencia total": Cubano damnificado del huracán Harvey
Han pasado dos meses del huracán Harvey y sus estragos aún se sienten en muchas de las comunidades de Houston. Algunas familias aún no se han podido recuperar y continúan viviendo con la preocupación de cómo hacer para recuperar sus vidas. Sin embargo, no pierden la esperanza de poder salir adelante.
Encuentran nuevos restos humanos del sargento estadounidense capturado y luego ejecutado en Níger
Este nuevo hallazgo, del que ya ha sido informada la familia, se suma a las polémicas que han rodeado la muerte de varios soldados a manos de ISIS y que tuvo al presidente Trump como protagonista después de que le dijera a la viuda del sargento que él sabía para lo que se enlistó.
Jesús Corona: "Es un halago que Chivas y Almeyda se fijen en mi"
El portero de Cruz Azul le hizo un "guiño" al Guadalajara y de paso aceptó que la Máquina se quito gran presión al calificar a la liguilla del Apertura 2017.
Con su estadio lleno, Columbus Crew espera tener un 'empuje extra' en la apertura de la Final del Este
Más de 20.000 aficionados se congregarán en el MAPFRE Stadium para el inicio de la serie decisiva ante Toronto FC.
La hermosa Nicole Regnier y un entrenamiento de fútbol envidiable
La exjugadora del Rayo Vallecano y el Atlético de Madrid se prepara de la mejor manera para el regreso del campeonato en Colombia, su país, donde jugará con el América de Cali.
Monterrey no es invencible: aquí las debilidades del líder y las claves para superarlo
Para nuestros expertos de Línea de Cuatro, el superlíder del Apertura 2017 no es perfecto. “Si le haces un buen pressing saliendo, pueden hacerle mucho daño”, dijo el ‘Bam-Bam’ Zamorano.