How almost 400 journalists around the world collaborated on Paradise Papers

How almost 400 journalists around the world collaborated on Paradise Papers

On Sunday, barely a year after the Panama Papers scandal broke, the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) announced another anonymous leak of documents, this time from a law firm in Bermuda. Journalists began working on the documents in secret in March after a meeting of media partners in Munich, Germany.


A few days before the publication of a massive offshore documents leak, a company in Bermuda warned its clients of a security breach. Journalists had been asking a number of questions about confidential company information. But "we are confident that our data integrity is secure," it stated.

The award-winning 2016 Panama Papers project had come out of a major leak of offshore documents, the largest document leak in history. Less than a year since that scandal broke, the Paradise Papers project sheds new light on the offshore world.

For Panama Papers, almost 400 journalists around the world had gained access to the secrets of Panamanian law firm Mossack Fonseca via an anonymous leak.

In March 2017, a group of journalists from nearly 100 global media outlets met in Munich, Germany, with the same intentions - and a little more experience. This time, a Bermuda company, Appleby Global is the company in question.

Offshore trove exposes Trump-Russia links and piggy banks of the wealthiest 1 percent
A new leak of confidential records reveals the financial hideaways of iconic brands and power brokers across the political spectrum

There were reporters from all continents, press, television, radio. Among the newcomers: two reporters from The New York Times. The newspaper did not participate in the Panama leak but this time they want in.

Among the reporters were Bastian Obenmayer and Frederik Obenmaier, from the German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung, who were already familiar faces in the world of collaborative journalism. They are the same reporters who received the leaked batch of documents that led to the Panama Papers.

The two Germans are perhaps the most generous - and practical - journalists on the planet. They have shared two huge databases with their colleagues without asking anything more than discretion. However, their argument for forsaking their own scoop is a good one - they simply can not do it alone.


While the digital information from Appleby wasn't as big - in terabytes - as the Mossack Fonseca leak, there were about two million more documents (13.4 million in total).

Video: Paradise Papers explained Univision

The reporters had access to emails, company records and Power Point presentations with confidential data, obtained from two large databases (Appleby, in Bermuda, and Asiaciti Trust, Singapore). They also obtained the secret company registry of 19 jurisdictions.

Marina Walker and Gerard Ryle from the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) began coordinating the reporting, including secure platforms to communicate, such as the private social network Athena, and two other platforms for deep data searches. Walker and Ryle are well-known for managing collaborative projects including Offshore Leaks (2013), Swiss Leaks (2015), and Panama Papers (2016).

In photos: 20 facts about the Paradise Papers leak

Participating reporters were given tips on how and where to search within the documents, which had been loaded onto password-protected digital platforms. Reporters signed non-disclosure confidentiality agreements to keep the investigation secret until it was ready to be published.

Back at their media outlets, they began to search. It wasn't easy. Unlike the Mossack Fonseca database, Appleby used more sophisticated mechanisms and emails were not always as explicit.

Reporters created online groups, depending on their interests, to focus on different topics and avoid duplicating efforts. For example, one group focused on U.S. politicians, while others looked at Glencore, a multinational mining company. Another focused on Appleby itself.

‘Offshore Magic Circle’ law firm has record of compliance failures
Secret stash of documents provide inside view of storied Bermuda-headquartered legal practice.

As the launch approached, increased security measures prevented information leaks by journalists, in the form of encrypted emails and double and triple access verification. A group of journalists from Univision News traveled to the ICIJ headquarters in Washington to receive training in digital search techniques.

Journalists used extreme care when approaching the people they were investigating. In September, ICIJ wrote to Appleby requesting an interview to answer questions about information contained in the documents. A reply warned of possible legal action against the journalists and demanded to know how the information had been obtained. Appleby also asked for copies of the leaked documents.

Another letter sent by ICIJ on Oct. 6 contained 63 detailed questions for Appleby.

A few days later, a group of reporters from Australia, Japan, the United States, Great Britain, and Denmark traveled to Bermuda. They met there with ICIJ reporter Will Fitzgibbon and a film crew from Vox. The idea was to approach Appleby directly by visiting the company's head office.

Bermuda: The island where money goes to disappear Univision

The group was politely told that no one from Appleby was available.

A few days later Appleby issued a statement saying that it had "thoroughly and vigorously investigated the allegations."

"We are satisfied that there is no evidence of any wrongdoing, either on the part of ourselves or our clients," it wrote.

However, it added: "It is true that we are not infallible. Where we find that mistakes have happened we act quickly to put things right."

On Sunday, in response to the publication of Paradise Papers, Appleby issued another statement accusing ICIJ and its partners of having a "clear political agenda" against the offshore industry and saying it had been the victim of "a serious criminal act."

It went on: "This was an illegal computer hack. Our systems were accessed by an intruder who deployed the tactics of a professional hacker and covered his/her tracks to the extent that a forensic investigation by a leading international Cyber & Threats team concluded that there was no definitive evidence that any data had left our systems."

Offshore gurus help rich avoid taxes on jets and yachts
Buying a $27-million private jet or plush mega-yacht means millions in sales taxes — unless you know the right pro.
promoICIJ Apple
Leaked documents expose secret tale of Apple’s offshore island hop
Elite tax advisers help Apple Inc. and other corporate giants skirt impacts of crackdown on 'Double Irish' maneuvers.
Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross has business ties with Venezuela's PDVSA, despite U.S. sanctions
Venezuela's state oil company is a client of Navigator Holding, of which Ross has been a shareholder since 2011.
Nike stays ahead of the regulators
When one tax loophole closes, another opens. A flow of trademark royalties had helped Nike build a $6.6 billion pile of cash offshore by June 2014. This sum had been taxed at just 3 percent outside the United States. And because it remained offshore, it had yielded no U.S. tax at all.
Daphne Caruana Galizia, de 53 años, fue asesinada en un atentado de auto bomba cuando salía de su casa. Semanas antes había denunciado amenazas de muerte. En sus investigaciones periodísticas, acusó de corrupción a altos mandos del gobierno maltés.
The Colombian soldier Mauricio Calvo shares his experience as part of a burgeoning industry of men who travel the world to fight in other people's wars.
Teóricamente los futbolistas tenían que pagar impuestos de 35% sobre sus ingresos depositados en malta, pero una ley del país les permitió terminar pagando tan solo el 5%.
Políticos, corporaciones, funcionarios públicos… y celebridades. Los nombres son muchos y los orígenes diversos, la razón: la misma. El Consorcio Internacional de Periodistas de Investigación, junto al diario alemán Süddeutsche Zeitung, reveló miles de nombres asociados con paraísos fiscales.
Juan Fernández, exdirectivo de PDVSA, mostró su preocupación respecto a la posible relación y contratos multimillonarios de transporte de combustible que tendría Wilbur Ross, miembro del gabinete de Donald Trump, con la estatal petrolera de Venezuela PDVSA.
Una investigación reveló que Navigator Holdings, una empresa naviera propiedad de Wilbur Ross, el secretario de comercio de EEUU, tiene contratos multimillonarios de transporte de combustible con la estatal petrolera de Venezuela PDVSA. La empresa de Ross ha recibido, ademas, millonarios ingresos de la compania Sibur, cuyos principales propiertarios son Kirill Shamalov, un cuñado de Vladimir Putin y Gennady Timchenko, un magnate de ese pais sancionado por la Oficina del Tesoro de EEUU por sus vinculos con el presidente ruso.
Una nueva filtración de documentos pone luces en cómo los superricos y empresas multimillonarias esconden sus ganancias para reducir el pago de impuestos.
In recent years Bermuda has become an important offshore financial hub for the super-rich and multi-national corporations, seeking to reduce taxes. But questions have been raised about offshore business practices and legal loopholes. One Bermuda company, Appleby is now at the center of a leak of offshore documents which show how the offshore game is played.
En los últimos años, Bermuda se ha convertido en un importante centro financiero offshore para los superricos y las multinacionales, que buscan reducir sus impuestos. Pero han surgido preguntas sobre las prácticas comerciales offshore y los atajos jurídicos. Appleby, una firma de abogados con base en Bermuda, está ahora en el centro de una filtración de documentos que muestra cómo se maneja el mundo offshore.
When Rodrigo Duterte was sworn in as Philippines’ president in June 2016, he declared a war on drug traffickers and users. Since then, Human Rights groups estimate more than 12,000 people have been killed in this offensive they call "a war on the poor." Univision News traveled to Manila and witnessed this conflict first hand.
Cuando Rodrigo Duterte llegó al poder en Filipinas en junio de 2016 declaró una guerra contra narcotraficantes y consumidores de drogas. Grupos de derechos humanos calculan que ya van más de 12,000 muertos en una ofensiva que tachan de “guerra contra los pobres”. Univision Noticias viajó a la capital del país y fue testigo de este conflicto.
Havana biologist, Marta Llanes, has spent the last year raising two baby chimps in her 5th floor Havana apartment.
President Donald Trump has signed an executive order suspending the US refugee program for 120 days, specifically barring Syrian refugees until further notice. Figures show the US has admitted just over 18,000 Syrian refugees since the war broke out in the Middle East country. It's estimated that 4 million Syrian children have only known war time.
Más de cuatro millones de niños sirios no conocen otra cosa que la guerra, pero el gobierno de Trump quiere vetar la entrada indefinida de refugiados de ese país a EEUU. Univision Noticias ha elaborado esta animación con el fin de explicar de forma sencilla los intereses geopolíticos y la historia de una guerra que entra ya en su sexto año.
Professor Ariel Merari explains the minds behind political and religious martyrdom.
El cantante apareció en un evento en Miami y nos habló del escándalo que salpicó a su familia, además de sus nuevos planes.
Ya sabemos si es hermanito o hermanita: así fue como Ana Patricia descubrió el sexo de su bebé
La conductora de Despierta América finalmente tuvo entre sus manos los análisis donde se revelaría el sexo de su bebé y no quiso esperar ni un instante más para conocer el resultado.
Sherlyn por fin habla sobre los rumores que aseguran que está embarazada
En la presentación de su nueva obra de teatro, la prensa le cuestionó a Sherlyn acerca de los rumores de embarazo que últimamente la han rodeado, a lo que la actriz no tuvo de otra más que responder sí se encuentra en la dulce espera o no.
Shakira ha decidido no operarse las cuerdas vocales, tomará tratamiento intensivo con cortisona
La cantante colombiana ha dejado saber que no se someterá a un procedimiento quirúrgico para corregir el problema que la aqueja en las cuerdas vocales, sino que tomará un tratamiento con el médico que trató los malestares de la cantante Adele.
Critican a Aislinn Derbez y a su esposo por querer que su bebé nazca fuera de México
Las redes sociales se han llenado de descontento contra la actriz Aislinn Derbez y su esposo Mauricio Ochmann, tras dar a conocer que el parto de su bebé será en los Estados Unidos y no en México, país donde ambos han desarrollado sus carreras.
Martes de cielo mayormente nublado y temperatura fresca en Miami
La temperatura máxima para hoy será de 74 grados, con bajas probabilidades de lluvia a pesar del cielo nublado.
El secreto de Jessica Cediel para el cuerpo ideal
Jessica Cediel nos cuenta qué le ha funcionado para mantenerse en forma y sentirse siempre bien.
Un niño permanece hospitalizado tras ser atropellado en Hollywood, Florida
Autoridades no han informado sobre la condición médica del menor. Indicaron que el conductor permaneció en la escena para colaborar con la investigación.
Un oficial de la policía de Miami-Dade resultó herido en un accidente de tránsito
El agente resultó herido en un accidente que involucró al menos a tres vehículos, en el noroeste de Miami-Dade. Permanece hospitalizado.
Simone Verdi rechaza al Nápoles y se queda en el Bolonia
El delantero decidió mantenerse en su actual equipo, pese a la oportunidad de emigrar con el líder del torneo y aspirante a campeón.
Aubameyang pide carta de libertad y el Dortmund le pone precio, según la prensa
El delantero africano podría estar viviendo sus últimos días como jugador del Dortmund
Editorial: ¡Urgente! Chivas debe reforzar a Almeyda para salir de la crisis
Édgar Martínez analiza el presente del Guadalajara y lo que se le puede venir en el futuro si la dirigencia no actúa pronto.
De no creer: así fue el golazo de rabona de Arturo Vidal con el Bayern Munich
El jugador chileno se lució con esta fantástica jugada de fantasía durante el entrenamiento del equipo alemán, demostrando toda su calidad y clase.