EPA personnel collect water samples along the Louisiana coast after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
Sarah Anderson

Associate Professor of Environmental Politics, University of California, Santa Barbara

Trump may reverse US climate policy but will have trouble dismantling EPA

Trump may reverse US climate policy but will have trouble dismantling EPA

History suggests that it may be harder to make radical cuts at EPA than Trump and his advisors think. While many politicians have called for eliminating entire cabinet agencies, none has succeeded.

EPA personnel collect water samples along the Louisiana coast after the...
EPA personnel collect water samples along the Louisiana coast after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill.

During the Republican primary debates, President-elect Trump threatened to gut the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), saying, “We are going to get rid of it in almost every form. We’re going to have little tidbits left but we’re going to take a tremendous amount out.”

History suggests that it may be harder to make radical cuts at EPA than Trump and his advisors think. While many politicians have called for eliminating entire cabinet agencies, none has succeeded.

Such efforts run into two empirical realities. First, government departments are rarely eliminated. Second, in my research I have found that, paradoxically, over the past six decades Democrats have been more likely to enact big cuts to programs than Republicans. Furthermore, while climate change programs may be an easy target, other presidents have found that voters like clean air and water and do not support gutting the agency whose job it is to protect them.

This article was originally published on The Conversation.

Smog over Los Angeles, 2011. The city’s air quality has improved greatly...
Smog over Los Angeles, 2011. The city’s air quality has improved greatly over the past 50 years, but the Los Angeles-Long Beach area still records some of the highest pollution levels in the nation.

Easier to grow than to cut

When I was a graduate student researcher updating a budget database, I was puzzled when I searched the 623 pages of the fiscal year 1983 budget for the budget of the Department of Education and couldn’t find it. There simply wasn’t an entry for the Department of Education because President Reagan had proposed to abolish it. Yet the budget for the Education Department increased in seven out of Reagan’s eight years as president, and it is still here today (Trump has also called for eliminating it).

Proposals to eliminate agencies have become pro forma for Republican politicians, recently including Ron Paul, Newt Gingrich and Ted Cruz. But these proposals rarely come to fruition.

Most instances in which agencies were eliminated over the past 20 years were either reorganizations – for example, merging 22 agencies to create the Department of Homeland Security in 2002 – or involved small, obsolete agencies like the Board of Tea Examiners, which was closed in 1996. When Republicans proposed cutting government after winning control of Congress in the 1994 elections, one of the few agencies that was actually closed was the Office of Technology Assessment, a small agency that provided technical and policy research to Congress itself.


Through this period, a surprising trend stands out. When Laurel Harbridge and I analyzed spending on more than 1,500 subaccounts in the federal budget from 1956 through 2003, we found that more large cuts to these accounts occurred when Democrats controlled two or three lawmaking institutions of government (House, Senate, and presidency) than when they controlled only one. (One limitation of our analysis was that we did not have data for periods when Republicans controlled all three branches.)

William Ruckelshaus is sworn in as administrator of the newly created En...
William Ruckelshaus is sworn in as administrator of the newly created Environmental Protection Agency, Dec. 4, 1970.

Why would Democrats, who traditionally support a more expansive role for government, make more large cuts in federal spending than Republicans? In social psychology Dan Kahan's words, “individuals … fit their processing of information to conclusions that suit some end or goal.” So we expect Democrats to make lots of small increases to programs.

But after making all those changes, the party must make corrections to balance its prior decisions. And when parties ignore information that runs counter to their ideology, they end up having to make big corrections. So we’d expect Democrats to occasionally make large cuts to programs.

For example, in 1993, after increasing the budget in four out of the prior five years, the unified Democratic government cut spending to the Bureau of Land Management’s land acquisition subaccount. Although Democrats are generally supportive of acquiring land for conservation, President Clinton had pointed out that buying property was coming at the expense of maintaining existing federal lands. The budget for land acquisition was cut by more than 56 percent. It took until 2000 to reach the 1992 level of spending again.

Starting in January, when Republicans will control Congress and the presidency, this perspective suggests that they will make lots of cuts, consistent with their ideological stance in favor of more limited government. But we can also predict that they may make more big increases than Democrats when the evidence shows that they have cut too far and they have to make big corrections.

EPA’s history is illustrative. Its budget was volatile in the early years under Republicans Nixon and Ford, with both huge growth (including a 238 percent increase) and big cuts. Since the funding became more stable in 1981, the budget has essentially been flat. During the period of unified Republican government from 2003-2007, the budget slowly declined. EPA received a 35 percent increase under President Obama in 2010, but since then has experienced another slow decline.

Americans value core environmental benefits

To reduce the EPA to “tidbits,” President Trump will also have to contend with public opinion. Air and water quality have greatly improved in the United States over the past 50 years, thanks to enactment of landmark laws like the Clean Air and Clean Water acts. But Americans are still concerned about these issues.

Last March 81 percent of respondents in a Gallup poll said they worried a great deal or a fair amount about pollution of waterways. More than three-quarters of Americans have held this view in Gallup surveys dating back to 1989. The same survey found that more than 70 percent of Americans had similar views about air pollution.


Trump’s EPA transition team leader is Myron Ebell, director of the Center for Energy and Environment at the Competitve Enterprise Institute. Ebell is known for arguing that climate change is not a serious problem and that the U.S. should not take action to reduce carbon emissions. We can expect that under President Trump EPA will focus on rolling back Obama administration climate change policies, such as the Clean Power Plan to reduce carbon emissions from power plants.

But the EPA is unlikely to disappear. While cuts on a lesser scale certainly would reduce the agency’s ability to enforce existing law and would dismay environmental advocates, the agency has been through reductions on this scale before and continued to function. But if the Trump administration makes too many cuts, lawsuits and public pressure to keep environmental quality high are likely to limit the administration’s ability to decimate the agency.

We are more like to see a period of slow decline similar to what occurred during George W. Bush's presidency. The motivated reasoning that encourages Republicans to cut spending showed in many small cuts across EPA’s budget. And these matter in the long run. By all accounts, the agency is being asked to do more with less and has been roundly criticized for failures like the one in Flint, Michigan. On the other hand, even Republican presidents recognize that people want a clean environment and are therefore limited in how much they can cut the EPA. If they do cut, they may even be forced by the public, the environmental movement, and lawsuits to reevaluate and make corrections.

The Conversation
On November 15, days before the allegations of sexual harassment against Charlie Rose came to light, the CNN International host issued a public call to editors and executives to end the abuse and sexual harassment in the media. That evening, Rose, who is being replaced by Amanpour on an interim basis, was sitting only a few feet away as she spoke.
The Colombian soldier Mauricio Calvo shares his experience as part of a burgeoning industry of men who travel the world to fight in other people's wars.
Angela King went from being a Neonazi skinhead to working to lure people out of hate groups. Today, King says she’s worried about what she sees as an increase of hate and a U.S. president who refuses to publicly denounce it. She has a unique insight into the most effective ways to respond to incidences of hate and extremism, and why people are in the life in the first place.
Through tears, Joaquín Ramírez recalls the minutes after a gunman entered a Baptist church in Sutherland Springs, Texas, and fired at everyone in his path.
When Rodrigo Duterte was sworn in as Philippines’ president in June 2016, he declared a war on drug traffickers and users. Since then, Human Rights groups estimate more than 12,000 people have been killed in this offensive they call "a war on the poor." Univision News traveled to Manila and witnessed this conflict first hand.
They grew up in Chicago and their husbands, the Flores twins (aka ‘Los Mellizos’), worked for the Sinaloa cartel. The twins later became DEA informants in Mexico who helped bring down El Chapo Guzman. They have written a book, Cartel Wives, telling their story as a lesson to others not to fall for the narco life, and they regret what they put their families through. "Our fathers put on their suit of armor and their badge, and they are going out there on the streets of Chicago,” Mia confesses. “It’s the very same streets that our husbands were flooding with drugs.”
Patients with chronic diseases are getting limited treatment in health centers and are still waiting for restoration of power and water supply. Univision News visited several hospitals.
The 1998 hurricane killed 11,000 people in Honduras and Nicaragua and left more than a million homeless. As a result, the United States granted temporary visas to citizens from those countries who were living illegally in the U.S.
The weather station in Key West, Florida, is sending weather balloons into the atmosphere to measure the powerful category 5 hurricane, which currently has winds of 175 miles per hour.
The Trump administration on Tuesday rescinded the DACA program that President Barack Obama introduced to protect the young undocumented immigrants known as Dreamers. Sessions said the program would be phased out over six months to allow Congress time to have another go at passing legislation.
Two brothers graduated from Harvard and Middlebury. They grew up in Houston and are practicing Christians. "Like "good Americans," they like Taco Bell. They have lived most of their lives in the United States and have a simple request for the president: "Do not get rid of DACA."
During a meeting in the Oval office Friday, the president was asked by reporters about the future of DACA, to which he responded that a decision was coming soon. "We love the dreamers, we love everyone," he added.
Nilsa Huete is an undocumented Honduran immigrant living in Key West, Florida. In the last five months, five of her family members have been arrested by agents from the Monroe County Sheriff's Office. Now she’s fighting against the deportation of her daughter and brother.
The Univision News anchor sat down with Chris Barker, leader of the "Loyal White Knights," a branch of the Ku Klux Klan. The interview was part of the special that aired Sunday on Aqui y Ahora.
A crowd surrounds a young man in a Trump hat and t-shirt, and draped in an Israeli flag, on Boston Common.
Jorge Ramos spoke with the musician's lawyer after he was detained by the Nicolas Maduro regime. The attorney said Arteaga had been "tortured". The Univision reporter asks: #FreedomforWuilly
Ilia Calderón: "Para mí es un privilegio poder acompañar en este crecimiento a la comunidad hispana"
Ilia Calderón, la nueva copresentadora del noticiero nacional de Univison, habla de cómo llegó a la televisión y cómo hace historia convirtiéndose en la primera afrolatina en presentar un noticiero de habla hispana en Estados Unidos y en su país, Colombia.
Vicepresidenta del Senado de Florida explica los proyectos legislativos para el 2018
Anitere Flores habla sobre las leyes que fueron aprobadas en el año 2017 y lo que se puede esperar para 2018 en cuanto a educación, salarios a los maestros, los estragos de los huracanes y cómo prevenirlos, y el transporte.
Polémica por aprobación de un cobro extra de la FPL a sus usuarios para proyecto de limpieza
La Comisión de Servicios Públicos aprobó que la FPL cobre más de 200 millones de dólares a sus usuarios, que serían invertidos en un proyecto para limpiar la contaminación en los canales de enfriamiento de la planta nuclear Turkey Point.
Analista republicana defiende al presidente Trump de las acusaciones de acoso sexual
El Congreso ha pedido una investigación sobre las denuncias de acoso sexual que han hecho varias mujeres contra el mandatario, antes de convertirse en presidente. Cada partido analiza la situación.
La crisis de Honduras amenaza con regresarla a su imagen de "república bananera"
Tres semanas después de una elección fallida, las protestas callejeras y las acusaciones de fraude han generado dudas sobre cualquier posibilidad de obtener un resultado creíble de las elecciones del 26 de noviembre. La inestabilidad a largo plazo podría generar un aumento en la migración, advierten los analistas.
Este es el programa contra la Mara Salvatrucha que propone el gobernador de Nueva York
Con iniciativas educativas y deportivas después del horario escolar en áreas de riesgo y apoyo a jóvenes inmigrantes susceptibles de unirse a ella, Andrew Cuomo desveló este domingo un programa para su agenda del 2018 que busca atajar el reclutamiento de la MS-13 en Nueva York.
Esta familia de extraficantes de personas cuenta cómo opera esta red en México
La familia Garfias solía dedicarse al tráfico de personas. Ahora, tras pasar más de una década en prisión, rehabilitarse y convertirse en cristianos renacidos cuentan la dura realidad de este negocio.
¿Se pueden utilizar las denuncias de acoso sexual en contra del presidente Donald Trump?
Una analista demócrata y una republicana debaten sobre las acusaciones de acoso y agresión sexual en contra del presidente Donald Trump.
Coutinho guió la goleada del Liverpool al Bournemouth
Con el 4-0 como visitante, el equipo que dirige Jurgen Klopp recuperó la cuarta posición en la Premier League.
Kaká anuncia su retiro del fútbol a los 35 años
El brasileño que brillara con el Milán y Real Madrid anunció mediante las redes sociales su retiro de las canchas como profesional.
Kaká anuncia su retiro del fútbol a los 35 años
El brasileño que brillara con el Milán y Real Madrid anunció mediante las redes sociales su retiro de las canchas como profesional.
Higuera sobre Cota: "A Pachuca se le juntaron los perritos"
El directivo rojiblanco explicó el motivo por el que lograron quedarse 6 meses más con el portero antes de que el equipo partiera a la pretemporada.