publicidad
A bus billboard shows Miami mayoral candidate Francis Suárez in MIami's famous Calle Ocho.

A spectator democracy: Why do only 2 out of 10 people in the U.S. vote for mayor?

A spectator democracy: Why do only 2 out of 10 people in the U.S. vote for mayor?

On Tuesday, dozens of cities will hold local elections and chances are you didn't even know it. Local turnout in the U.S. hovers around 10-20 percent, an extraordinarily low figured compared with cities in Latin America and Europe.

A bus billboard shows Miami mayoral candidate Francis Suárez in MIami&#3...
A bus billboard shows Miami mayoral candidate Francis Suárez in MIami's famous Calle Ocho.

Lea esta nota en español

MIAMI, Florida. The top candidate in the Miami mayoral campaign, Francis Suárez, had breakfast with two colleagues on Thursday at Versailles restaurant, an emblematic meeting point for politicians located in the city's Little Havana neighborhood.

But, with only five days to go before Tuesday's election, he didn't bother to go around the tables to press the flesh and convince the undecided.

Waiters who attended him say he never mentioned that early voting had already begun. Nor were there any TV cameras or the usual gaggle of journalists and onlookers.

That's because Suárez is a sho-in for election on Tuesday.

One waiter, Armando Suarez (no relationship), says that in 30 years working at Versailles he had never seen so little interest in a campaign. "This year is the first time I haven't seen anything about the campaign," he says. "It's weird."

Miami is not the only city holding elections on Tuesday where almost nobody knows about the upcoming vote. Turnout is also likely going to be low in New York, Atlanta or Boston, among other cities. Voters in New Jersey and Virginia are also voting for their state assemblies and governors.

Turnout in the municipal elections of the 144 largest cities in the United States was only 21 percent of eligible voter in 2011 and the trend is downward, according to a study by the University of Utah. In 1999, the turnout was 24.9 percent.

The numbers are extraordinarily low if you look at what happens in large cities in Latin America and Spain. For example, in Mexico City in 2012, 67.4 percent of the electorate turned out to vote, in the Metropolitan District of Caracas in 2013, 58.6 percent and in Madrid in 2015, 69 percent.

Turnout at local elections in the U.S. and the Hispanic world
The graph shows voter turnout for mayoral elections in some of the main cities of the United states, Latin America and Spain. It should be noted that international comparisons are difficult because the powers of each municipality vary as well as official figures (turnout rates for all people elegible to vote versus turnout rates for those registered to vote).
FUENTE: Who Votes for Mayor / Portland State University (2016) / Official figures from election authorities in Latin America and Spain | UNIVISION


Politicians and analysts warn that democracy should not be considered a spectator sport to be observed from the couch, because the right to vote is perhaps the quintessential indicator of civic engagement in a well-functioning democracy.

"When you have fought for democracy you hold it dear," says electoral expert Phil Keisling, observing that contrast.

U.S. apathy can also be observed when comparing voter turnout in national elections in the most developed countries. About 55.7 percent of the voting-age population in the United States voted in the 2016 presidential election, according to the Pew center based on Census data, a small uptick compared with 2012, but lower than the record year of 2008 (58.3 percent).

In Spain, 61.6 percent of the population eligible to vote tuned out in 2016, and in Mexico in 2012, 66 percent did so. The United States ranks 28th in electoral participation in the list of the 35 countries of the OECD organization (the club of rich countries).

publicidad

There are many theories about the factors that best explain abstention, such as: media coverage, climate, competitiveness of a given campaign, or whether the vote coincides or not with a presidential election.

In some cases, such as Miami, the lack of interest may stem from the non-partisan nature of the election, which means that political parties aren't putting money into the race and voters feel less affinity with the candidates. The financial crisis of local newspapers is another factor that has reduced attention on municipal policies, experts say.

The lack of engagement may also be a consequence of the very low confidence in U.S. institutions, others warn.

"This is illustrative of a much deeper problem with American democracy," says Keisling, who as Oregon's secretary of state managed the state's elections between 1991 and 1999. "The danger of lower turnout is not only you empower the extremes, but also that it is less and less possible to have a sensible conversation."

Cynical millenials

One of the red flags is the very high apathy of millennials. A 2016 study by Portland State University shows that people over 65 vote in local elections on average seven times more than citizens between 18 and 34 years old.

Although it has long been observed that younger people participate less than older people, there's concern about the younger generations because they have become more cynical about the value of democracy as a political system.

Only three out of ten U.S. millennials consider "essential" to live in a democracy, according to the World Values Survey.

publicidad

As in national elections, white people turnout at a much higher rate than ethnic minorities, particularly Latinos. Researchers from the Portland State University study, where 46 cities were analyzed, found that the Latino vote was half to two thirds of the average vote in each city.

Maps of Dallas showing where minorities live (left) and where turnout fo...
Maps of Dallas showing where minorities live (left) and where turnout for local elections is higher (right)
Maps of New York City showing where minorities live (left) and areas wit...
Maps of New York City showing where minorities live (left) and areas with higher turnout in the last local election (right)


Across the nation, one in 13 African-American adults also cannot vote because of a felony conviction. In Florida, Kentucky, Tennessee and Virginia, more than one in five African-Americans cannot vote.

Reduced participation has consequences for public policies that tend to forget minorities’ interests. "As absenteeism grows, the electorate looks less and less like the United States," says David Becker, founder of the Center for Election Innovation & Research, a group devoted to increase participation.

Among other actions to increase participation, experts propose to schedule local elections on the same day as national elections, to set the voting day on a Sunday instead of a working day, to send ballots by mail to all registered voters, as well as simplifying the ballots.

But experts regret that in many states authorities are promoting actions that limit voting instead of encouraging people to do so. Laws that require identification or gerrymandering (Districts’ redesign in order to subtract power from minorities’ vote and make people believe that voting is useless) are some examples.

publicidad

While activists try to find solutions that increase turnout, a small number of people get to choose their local authorities. For Suárez, the Miami candidate, that means he can enjoy his breakfast at Versailles.

No polls have been done, but there's no doubt Suárez leads the race. He calls himself lucky enough to have more financial resources than his rivals, and to be the son of former mayor, Xavier Suárez - although he was embroiled in a scandal of electoral fraud in 1997.

"I don’t know about his plans, I’ll vote for him because I've known him all my life, he goes to Saint Raymond church, where I go too," says Mario García, a Versailles client.

In Miami’s most recent local elections, four years ago, turnout was only 12 percent. This year, they’re expecting the same number.

Trump draws attention away from local politics

Óscar Haza, a well-known radio and television journalist in South Florida, says the die is cast. Suárez' three opponents are: a communism sympathizer, Cynthia Mason Jaquith; a protestant minister, Williams Armbrister Sr.; and a young administrator with little experience, Christian Canache. "Suárez doesn’t have any competition. When there is less energy in the campaign, there are fewer elements of discussion that mobilize people to vote," he says.

Haza, who anchors a primetime show at a local TV station, recognizes that for the first time he has not interviewed all the candidates running for the mayor's office. "Trump doesn’t leave us space," he explained. On Nov 7 local elections will be held in three other Miami-Dade County municipalities: Hialeah, Miami Beach and Homestead.

publicidad

At West Flagler library, in the heart of the city, a candidate for commissioner, Ralph Rosado, 45, waited for voters behind a barrier with other volunteers, but only a few retirees approached the voting center. Rosado, much younger than his voters, said he rather put his efforts into convincing the elderly, whom he calls "the supervoters."

He regrets that young people don’t have time to read newspapers and that many don’t understand how local politics affect them, often more than federal issues. "Someone recently told me that my opponents are not the other candidates, but apathy," he noted.

When Rodrigo Duterte was sworn in as Philippines’ president in June 2016, he declared a war on drug traffickers and users. Since then, Human Rights groups estimate more than 12,000 people have been killed in this offensive they call "a war on the poor." Univision News traveled to Manila and witnessed this conflict first hand.
We traveled to Ciudad Juárez to see if hundreds of thousands of jobs in the Mexican maquiladora industry would return to the United States if Trump were to modify or abandon the NAFTA free trade agreement, as his government is considering. A border tax would have serious consequences in Mexican cities.
Although the deportation numbers for Donald Trump's administration have kept pace with the Obama administration, images of operatives and arrests, hate attacks on different minorities, and the President's own pronouncements have triggered alarms in the immigrant community ... and fear. One of Trump's most vocal campaign promises has begun to come true. And we are not talking about the physical wall, but a deeper, taller and more effective one: the wall of fear.
Figures show the US has admitted just over 18,000 Syrian refugees since the war broke out in the Middle Eastern country. It's estimated that 4 million Syrian children have only known war time.
In the dairy industry in Wisconsin, at the heart of the Rust Belt where Donald Trump won by a landslide, more than half of the workers are immigrants and most of them are undocumented. No American citizen wants to do the hard work they do.
The U.S. Senator is in a close race for re-election in Florida. Now comes new revelations about the cocaine smuggling house Rubio briefly shared with his brother-in-law. Prize-winning journalist Tim Elfrink with the Miami New Times explains the significance of the court papers.
Post-debate video captured an awkward greeting between Donald Trump and his daughter Tiffany, who comes from Donald’s relationship to his second wife, Marla Maples. In the video, it appears Tiffany refused to kiss her dad. But that’s not true.
Machado was crowned Miss Universe in 1996. A few months later, she gained weight. As a result, Trump planned a media event for journalists to watch her work out, she told Ramos.
Based on historical trends, current context and campaign strategies, Univision News takes a stab at predicting the results.
It has been a year since the real estate magnate announced his presidential bid. Here is the best (and worst) in a year of Trump.
An evolution of President Obama's reactions to mass shootings during his administration.
La historia detrás de las 103 coreografías que se han montado en Mira Quién Baila
Rodrigo Basurto y cuatro coreógrafos más han sido los encargados de coordinar los bailes de la quinta temporada del show, que han sido de otro nivel.
Cardenal en México culpa a las mujeres de la ola de feminicidios en el país
Las declaraciones del cardenal emérito Juan Sandoval Íñiguez han causado una fuerte controversia. Aquí escuchamos cómo intentó defender sus palabras.
Tras fugarse de Venezuela, Antonio Ledezma habla de los planes para ayudar al país desde afuera
"Voy a contribuir en el exilio a hacer una extensión de la esperanza de los venezolanos de salir de este régimen, de esta dictadura. Venezuela está siendo víctima de un régimen coludido con el narcotráfico", dijo tras llegar a España.
Video muestra agentes sometiendo a un desamparado de manera violenta, ¿fue brutalidad policial?
El incidente ocurrió en Modesto, California y el oficial que golpeó al individuo está bajo investigación. Hablamos con una testigo que nos cuenta qué fue lo que vio.
publicidad
El reencuentro de 12 familias en la frontera de EEUU y México, con matrimonio incluido
La patrulla fronteriza le permitió a 12 familias que viven divididas entre naciones vecinas, reunirse durante tres minutos. Un estadounidense y una indocumentada pudieron contraer matrimonio.
La MTA va a ofrecer servicios de autobuses gratuito en el aeropuerto La Guardia
La medida es debido a congestión vehicular que se prevé durante el día festivo de Acción de Gracias. Se trata de la línea de autobús Q70 y el servicio gratuito estará disponible hasta el próximo domingo 26 de noviembre.
Durante 17 horas bomberos lucharon contra devastador incendio en Hamilton Heights
Nueve personas, entre ellas siete bomberos, resultaron heridas. El siniestro dejó a más de 20 familias sin hogar. El departamento de bomberos de Nueva York evalúa la estabilidad estructural del edificio residencial de 50 unidades. El incendio destruyó por completo los dos últimos pisos.
60 mujeres empresarias migrantes se graduaron del programa 'Empresarias del Futuro'
El programa es con el apoyo de Mujeres Latinas en Acción y el área de Educación Financiera del Consulado de México. La idea detrás del programa es fortalecer una idea de negocios, y aquellas que ya tienen sus pequeñas empresas tuvieron la oportunidad de identificar aquellos aspectos a trabajar.
Tiro de esquina para Necaxa
Tiro de esquina para Necaxa on November 18, 2017
¡Barovero! Trapito salvó con tremenda atajada al Necaxa
Casi marca Raúl Ruidiaz con un gran disparo a la media vuelta.
Tiro desviado de Rodolfo Vilchis
Tiro desviado de Rodolfo Vilchis on November 18, 2017
Tiro desviado de Aldo Rocha
Tiro desviado de Aldo Rocha on November 18, 2017