What is to be done about Venezuela?

What is to be done about Venezuela?

Venezuela is a dying star, and if it explodes in a supernova, it'll be everyone's mess to clean. So it's in everyone's interest to make sure that doesn't happen. But is there any hope for dialogue with Venezuela's intransigent rulers.


Venezuela is a disaster. Its democracy is broken and its economy is in ruins. The social fabric is being torn apart, and its national identity is up for grabs. People are going hungry and institutions are going to pot. The country is increasingly isolated and has all but exhausted its supply of medicine, food, money, and friends. Venezuela is so close to the maw of the abyss, it can feel its hot breath.

Unfortunately, the situation could still get much worse. Problems of this magnitude often do, especially when they've got years of momentum. That's Newton's first law of motion.

There are no easy fixes for Venezuela. Pundits who tweet 140-character solutions or helpful listicles promising "5 steps to fix Venezuela" can be safely ignored. Any attempt to oversimplify the problem is an insult to the countless Venezuelans who have taken to the streets to push back against a repressive regime, as well as those who have been jailed or killed trying.

Still, something must be done about Venezuela. The difficulty of the country's problems is no excuse for inaction. Something's gotta give.

But the first step to finding a solution is deciding who should be involved in that process.

China thinks Venezuela should go it alone, and that everyone else should butt out. China is wrong. Venezuela is already everyone's problem. Venezuelans have been fleeing their country in all directions for years, and Maduro's dysfunction and brutality are putting a serious strain on neighborhood relations. Venezuela is a dying star, and if it explodes in a supernova, it'll be everyone's mess to clean. So it's in everyone's interest to make sure that doesn't happen.


And Venezuela clearly needs all the help it can get. The country has been trying for years to find a path out of the forest through elections, dialogue, protest marches, referendums, hashtags, and most recently, an officialist constituent assembly. But Venezuela's problems are like Chinese handcuffs—the more the country struggles to wrest free, the tighter it gets pulled in.

Latin America, which is always leery of interventionism, has been slow to act. Former President Hugo Chávez's petrodollars bought his country a long leash, and his charismatic antagonism towards the United States was a guilty pleasure to many Latin Americans who didn't dare utter similar provocations. But that was then, and this is now. Maduro is a weak substitute who seemed destined to fail; he would have found a way to blow it even if world oil prices hadn't tanked.

Maduro's grip on the situation became even more tenuous after the international community rejected his government's efforts to rewrite Venezuela's constitution. The U.S. responded by slapping more individual sanctions on corrupt Venezuelan officials. Meanwhile, 13 countries from across the hemisphere (minus the U.S.) signed the "Lima Declaration," which denounces the rupture of democracy in Venezuela and refuses to recognize the legitimacy of Maduro's new constitutional assembly.

That's like if all your neighbors signed a petition warning you that they will no longer recognize the legitimacy of your property title if you continue making home renovations. Needless to say, it's going to make for some awkward moments at the next neighborhood cookout.


Maduro responded immediately to the Lima Declaration by calling for a new "dialogue of respect for Venezuela" among his ALBA allies and four of the declaration's signatories: Mexico, Colombia, Peru and Argentina. Maduro's proposal is essentially to create a smaller Latin American focus group to counter what he calls the "failed efforts" of the Organization of American States (OAS), an organization the Venezuelan government considers a Trojan Horse for U.S. interests.

At first blush, Maduro's call for new talks looks like a terrible idea from a desperate man. Maduro has repeatedly proven himself to be an intransigent and cynical negotiator who uses talks to buy time and divide opponents.

There's little reason to think that a new dialogue would be any different, says Latin America analyst Eric Farnsworth of the Council of the Americas. Farnsworth believes the Maduro regime would only negotiate in good faith if its survival were really on the line, and right now the stakes in Venezuela probably aren't high enough.

But despite the skepticism, some analysts think new talks might be the best of several bad options.

Farnsworth says if Mexico, Colombia, Peru, and Argentina accept Maduro's proposal and enter talks with a realistic agenda, a clear list of deliverables, and a series of pre-conditions to make sure Maduro isn't wasting everyone's time, the talks might just be Latin America's best chance to negotiate a homegrown solution to the Venezuela problem.

Best case scenario, the talks could take an unexpected turn and produce a roadmap back to democracy—a type of modern-day Esquipulas peace accords, Central America's remarkable effort to bring an end to the war in Nicaragua in the 1980s. Worst case scenario, the Venezuela talks would quickly fall apart if Maduro is unwilling to compromise and only wants to grandstand on an international stage.


"Maduro’s call for a regional peace dialogue is hard to take seriously at this point, in light of his government’s massive crackdown and his failure to keep his word" in previous talks, says Michael Shifter, president of the Inter-American Dialogue.

Still, Shifter agrees it's worth a try because the alternative is bleak.

Without talks, there are several things that could happen in Venezuela, none of which are good:

  1. The constituent assembly writes a new constitution, expanding Maduro's authority. Protests continue, repression increases, the economic collapse deepens, the crisis worsens.
  2. The constitutional assembly tries to gain international legitimacy by removing Maduro from office and appointing a new Chavista hardliner as temporary president. It backfires. The government is less legitimate than ever, protests escalate, repression increases, Venezuela falls into the abyss and can't pull itself out.
  3. The Venezuelan military pulls a "Honduras" by ousting the president in a last-ditch effort to save the constitution and restore order. The move backfires even more spectacularly than it did in Honduras, triggering a horrible cycle of violence. The country falls apart.

That's not an exhaustive list of hypothetical scenarios, but before imagining other terrible outcomes for Venezuela, it's probably worth giving some serious consideration to Maduro's call for talks. It might only look like a good option in comparison to the terrible alternatives, but in realpolitik, that's all that matters.


"There is no guarantee that formula will work, but it’s worth a try," Shifter says. "It's surely preferable to other scenarios that could well bring significant levels of violence and lawlessness."

Contenidos Relacionados
20 oct, 2017 | 12:29 PM
Mexico rises
Nelson Denis, author of 'War Against All Puerto Ricans,' details how the commonwealth's 119-year-long association with the U.S. has produced total economic and governing dependence. With over $70 billion in crushing debt, Puerto Rico's governor turned to the courts on Wednesday to put certain debts before a federal bankruptcy court.
We traveled to Ciudad Juárez to see if hundreds of thousands of jobs in the Mexican maquiladora industry would return to the United States if Trump were to modify or abandon the NAFTA free trade agreement, as his government is considering. A border tax would have serious consequences in Mexican cities.
A wave of demonstrations in Venezuela has left several dead and hundreds more detained in the last two weeks. Univision reporter Tamoa Calzadilla explains how a democratic crisis, inflation and shortages of food and medicine have sent Venezuelans into the streets.
Gina Potes and Patricia Espitia were attacked with acid in Colombia, a country with one of the highest number of attacks of this kind. They have created a sisterhood, which they have used to help other victims and raise awareness about these brutal attacks.
As the legend goes, a UFO landed in Capilla del Monte in 1986, leaving a mark on the side of the Pajarillo mountains. Since then, this Argentinian village has lived off UFO tourism. It's currently hosting its annual Alien Festival.
The announcement to scrap the benefits came as a bucket of cold water for the Cuban migrants who just arrived in the United States. As this group waits for their papers, the uncertainty grows on whether they will ever be reunited with the relatives they left on the island.
A group of Argentines diagnosed with mental illness set up a radio station from where they broadcast their experiences
How Fidel Castro's plan to save Cuban baseball unraveled. The once mighty amateur baseball champions have lost much of their talent in recent years to U.S. Major League Baseball. Now the Cuban government is in discussions with MLB to stop the desertions. But will a Trump presidency make that more difficult?
A half-century of armed conflict has left behind 8 million victims in Colombia. It has also affected the country's unique natural resources. We explore the war’s impact on Colombia’s environment.
Forty three students in Mexico were abducted two years ago, and to this day, none have ever been found. When his son Jorge disappeared, New York City plumber Antonio Tizapa began to run marathons, not to win, but to send a message at the end of each race: he won’t stop until he finds his son or the truth about what really happened on that shameful day. On Sunday, Antonio and 20 friends will be running the New York City Marathon.
Latino millennials account for almost half the 27.3 million eligible Latino voters in this election. But Latino turn out is traditionally far lower than black and Anglo voters. J.P. Dominguez asks “when are we going to wake up?”
A study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic policy found that undocumented immigrants pay $11.64 billion a year in state and local taxes. The undocumented pay on average 8% of their income on taxes while the wealthiest 1% pay only 5.4%. J.P Dominguez says that's "trumped up."
The evidence against El Chapo: undercover recordings, intercepted communications, protected witnesses’ declarations, drug seizures, and a confession. As U.S. prosecutors prepare their case against the world's most feared drug trafficker, this is what the government's case is built around.
During the first presidential debate, the candidates took a chance to bring up each others past mistakes to affect their performance.
Six months after the U.S. president visited the island, Cubans are divided over his impact. A government reform program is on hold as anxious residents pray for a tourist invasion.
After the "Taco trucks on every corner" comment from the co-founder of Latinos for Trump, part of his immigration past emerged. This is JP Domínguez's take on the issue.
Así fue mi encuentro con las dos esposas de los gemelos que traicionaron a 'El Chapo'
Llegaron puntuales a la cita, asustadas, vestidas de negro y ropa de marca. Sus protectores vigilaban además que todo estuviera bien en los monitores y nada revelara su identidad. Las mujeres de los Flores viven con miedo y trabajos de bajo perfil que, aseguran, son legales.
"La situación no es aceptable": Cory Booker habla de Puerto Rico y cómo Trump ha manejado la crisis
El senador por Nueva Jersey dice que aún falta mucho por hacer para ayudar a Puerto Rico y dice por qué decidió aprender español.
Puerto Rico, Donald Trump y Richard Spencer, los protagonistas de esta semana en las redes sociales
Una encuesta realizada en Twitter, reveló que el 71% de los votantes están en desacuerdo con las acciones del presidente Trump ante la crisis en Puerto Rico. La visita del supremacista blanco Richard Spencer a la Universidad de Florida generó un gran debate en las plataformas digitales.
“Ellos eran uno solo”: hija de cubana que murió en los brazos de su esposo intentando escapar del fuego en California
Mónica Berriz-Ocon, hija de la pareja cubana que se refugió en una piscina para intentar sobrevivir de los fuertes incendios en California, relata los angustiosos momentos que vivieron sus padres y otros familiares y del actual estado de salud de padre que, después de luchar, logró salir con vida de esta tragedia.
La policía halla el cuerpo de un menor durante la búsqueda de Sherin Mathews
Las autoridades de Richardson, Texas, informaron que se trata "muy probablemente" de la niña de 3 años, cuyo padre dijo que desapareció de un callejón cuando la castigó por no tomarse la leche. Los restos fueron encontrados en una alcantarilla.
En fotos: La desaparición de Sherin Mathews en Richardson (Texas)
Se emitió un alerta Amber luego de que los padres de la niña de 3 años la reportaran como desaparecida el sábado 7 de octubre. La notificación se canceló el lunes, pero la búsqueda siguió y ahora la policía pide ayuda para determinar dónde estuvo un auto de la familia poco después de que la niña, según su padre, fuese castigada en un callejón por no tomarse la leche.
Cómo los traumas de la infancia producen deseos de pertenecer a grupos de odio
Habitualmente quienes integran estas sectas han sido víctimas de abuso, acoso escolar o maltratos durante la niñez, y formar parte de ellas les brinda un sentido de pertenencia e identidad. Luego del controvertido discurso del supremacista Richard Spencer en Florida, revisamos este fenómeno.
Un hombre empuja sin razón aparente a una mujer a las vías del tren
El hombre de 56 años fue arrestado después de haber empujado a la mujer en una estación de tren de China. Las imágenes de seguridad muestran a una trabajadora ferroviaria de 59 años parada en la plataforma esperando un tren hasta que el hombre se acerca y la empuja.
¡Pura Vida! Kendal Waston marca el primero para Vancouver ante Portland
El defensa costarricense abre la cuenta en casa de los ‘Timbers’, después de un cabezalo letal dentro del área, en jugada de pelota detenida.
Real Madrid hace pesar de nuevo el Bernabéu
Los merengues lograron un triunfo cómodo para mantenerse entre los primeros sitios de la liga española.
Con golazo de último minuto, Cavani evitó derrota del PSG en Marsella
El delantero uruguayo apareció en el momento preciso, justo después de la expulsión de Neymar y cuando su equipo parecía desfallecer.
Hamilton se quedó con el GP de Estados Unidos
Mercedes festejó el Mundial de constructores en el circuito de Austin, Texas.