publicidad
Trump addresses a joint session of Congress on Feb. 28, 2017, as VP Mike Pence and House Speaker Paul Ryan applaud.

Trump suggests ‘merit-based’ immigration policy in address to Congress

Trump suggests ‘merit-based’ immigration policy in address to Congress

That would favor the best and the brightest, but severely restrict low-skilled immigration, hurting companies in the agricultural or manufacturing sectors.

Trump addresses a joint session of Congress on Feb. 28, 2017, as VP Mike...
Trump addresses a joint session of Congress on Feb. 28, 2017, as VP Mike Pence and House Speaker Paul Ryan applaud.

(Editor’s note: President Donald Trump gave his first address to a joint session of Congress on Feb. 28. The speech featured policy ideas that appealed to Republicans, and others that sounded more Democratic. We asked scholars to react to the substance of the speech and evaluate its tone for hints of bipartisanship.) The Conversation

President Trump called for a “merit-based system” for immigration, which would represent a major change in U.S. immigration policy.

This could, for example, boost innovation. But, at the same time, it would require significant adjustments by U.S. companies, while raising the costs of services in many parts of the U.S. Importantly, it is unlikely that this policy would “save countless dollars, raise workers’ wages and help working families,” as President Trump claimed.

In short, a merit-based immigration system, like that in place in Canada and Australia, assigns applicants points based on their status in each of several categories, typically emphasizing an immigrant’s language fluency, educational attainment, age and whether employment has been secured prior to arrival. As a result, the system tends to select young immigrants ready to perform skilled work.

The benefits of a merit-based immigration system derive from welcoming a steady stream of the best and brightest from around the world, something the U.S. has done for most of its history through the H-1B visa and other programs.

It should be noted that recent immigration has already been tilted toward those with skills, so such a system wouldn’t necessarily provide companies with more able workers.

publicidad

In fact, the primary effect of the introduction of a merit-based system would be to severely restrict low-skilled immigration, hurting companies in the agricultural or manufacturing sectors that are more reliant on such workers. One of the most consistent findings within the immigration literature is that companies are quick to replace low-skill workers with capital by replacing them with machines when conditions change. The wages of a few remaining workers would rise but most would likely lose out.

At the same time, costs such as dining out, landscaping, housework and elderly care would become more expensive as low-skill immigrant service providers become more scarce.

While a merit-based system would impose some coherence on U.S. immigration policy, which today is quite piecemeal and inefficient, it would severely restrict low-skill immigration. This is unlikely to increase Americans’ economic prospects, and in fact would probably reduce them.

Greg Wright, Assistant Professor of Economics, University of California, Merced

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

publicidad
Contenidos Relacionados
publicidad
Latino millennials account for almost half the 27.3 million eligible Latino voters in this election. But Latino turn out is traditionally far lower than black and Anglo voters. J.P. Dominguez asks “when are we going to wake up?”
A study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic policy found that undocumented immigrants pay $11.64 billion a year in state and local taxes. The undocumented pay on average 8% of their income on taxes while the wealthiest 1% pay only 5.4%. J.P Dominguez says that's "trumped up."
During the first presidential debate, the candidates took a chance to bring up each others past mistakes to affect their performance.
After the "Taco trucks on every corner" comment from the co-founder of Latinos for Trump, part of his immigration past emerged. This is JP Domínguez's take on the issue.
Donald Trump's wife and aspiring First Lady is an immigrant who says she always "went by the law" - but her story is a little 'SUS'.
El drama de perder la comunicación: Shalimar Rivera suplicó a sus seguidores la ayuden a ubicar a su papá
La modelo puertorriqueña compartió su angustia en redes sociales al enterarse que la zona donde vive su padre fue afectada fuertemente por el Huracán María.
Cuál es el impacto de las redes sociales durante un desastre natural o catástrofe
El psicoterapeuta Alfredo Hernández explicó cuál es el verdadero impacto que causa postear videos e imágenes de desastres naturales que impactan a nuestra comunidad, y nos resolvió una duda: ¿realmente vale la pena compartirlas?
La pregunta del millón: ¿cuántos Legos se utilizaron para grabar 'The Lego Ninjago Movie'?
Ninette Ríos se coló a los estudio de animación donde se filmó 'The Lego Ninjago Movie', tercera película donde sus protagonistas son figuras del famoso juguete Lego. ¡Y ahí descubrió cuántas piezas fueron utilizadas en total en la cinta!
publicidad
En fotos: Fuerte terremoto estremece México
El Servicio Geológico de Estados Unidos reportó una magnitud preliminar de 7.1 con epicentro en el sur de México. El sismo ocurrió casi una hora después de que se hiciera en el país una gran simulacro de terremoto para recordar el de 1985, que dejó miles de muertos.
Hospitales públicos y privados brindan atención gratuita a heridos por terremoto
Muchas familias mexicanas siguen viviendo una pesadilla tras el terremoto de 7.1 que sacudió a ese país. Para atender la emergencia, hospitales públicos y privados han abierto sus salas de urgencias para recibir, de manera gratuita, a todos los pacientes que lleguen a ellas. La donación de sangre también ha sido importante y ha contado con la ayuda de bastantes voluntarios.
Opciones para que los estudiantes obtengan el dinero necesario para la universidad
Beatriz Mendoza, de California State University Northridge, explica las opciones de financiación que tienen los estudiantes actualmente para cubrir los gastos universitarios. Invita a la feria de educación donde se tratarán este y otros temas relacionados.
Temperaturas frescas antes de que inicie el otoño, el pronóstico del clima para este jueves
Este jueves será el día más fresco de la semana con temperaturas que estarán sobre los 73 grados. Recuerde que este viernes comienza el otoño y se registrará algo de calor en los próximos días. En las altas elevaciones se podrán registras algunas nevadas.
Futbolistas mexicanos promueven la campaña #YoXMex a favor de las víctimas del terremoto
Figuras internacionales del fútbol como Javier 'Chicharito' Hernández y Miguel Layún utilizaron sus redes sociales para promover la iniciativa #YoXMex a favor de las víctimas del terremoto que sacudió a México el pasado 19 de septiembre.
El Chelsea confirma acuerdo con el Atlético de Madrid por el traspaso de Diego Costa por 62 millones de euros
Así lo confirmó este jueves el equipo inglés a través de un escueto comunicado donde confirma la salida del jugador hispano-brasileño Diego Costa.
Emilio Butragueño y Karim Benzema envían condolencias a México
El director deportivo de relaciones institucionales del conjunto blanco recordó el tiempo en el que estuvo viviendo en suelo azteca.
Sporting KC, el 'Rey de Copas' estadounidense celebró por todo lo alto un nuevo título
Los Red Bulls, en tanto, lamentan la mala racha que los persigue y que desde 1996 los mantiene sin títulos oficiales.