publicidad
Texas immigration detention center
Lindsay M Harris
Opinión

Lindsay M Harris is Assistant Professor of Law, University of the District of Columbia

Is the US immigration court system broken?

Is the US immigration court system broken?

Since 2002, funding for immigration enforcement has more than quadrupled. During the same time period, resources for immigration courts have increased by much less – 74 percent. A backlog of cases has arisen largely because of an increase in the number of Central American women and children seeking asylum. More judges and asylum officers are needed.

Texas immigration detention center
Texas immigration detention center

In the U.S. today, a single immigration case takes an average of 677 days simply to get to the initial scheduling hearing. The Conversation

There are more than half a million cases in the system, and just over 300 judges working on them. The Trump administration’s push to aggressively enforce immigration laws will make this backlog worse.

Since 2002, funding for immigration enforcement has more than quadrupled, from US$4.5 billion to $20.1 billion in 2016. During the same time period, resources for immigration courts have increased by much less – 74 percent.

President Donald Trump’s budget for fiscal 2018 and request for supplemental funds for fiscal 2017 indicate he will continue this trend of funding immigration enforcement but not adequately funding immigration courts.

His budget requests would add to the more than $40 billion that the Department of Homeland Security will receive this year. It would include $4.1 billion to start building a border wall and $2.65 billion to increase the number of immigration detention beds. In comparison, the fiscal 2018 budget requests $80 million to add 75 new immigration judges.

As a law professor, I have devoted my career to representing asylum seekers and studying our nation’s immigration courts. I witness the daily effects of the immigration court backlog on the lives of immigrants.

Backlogged immigration courts

The U.S. has 57 immigration courts nationwide. The judges in these courts preside over cases in which an individual is in the U.S. and the U.S. government alleges that they may be removable. This includes immigrants who have recently arrived and are seeking asylum protection, lawful permanent residents rendered potentially removable due to a criminal conviction and undocumented immigrants who may be allowed to stay in the U.S.

publicidad

In 2015, the TRAC Immigration Project out of Syracuse University estimated that full resolution of cases in the backlog would take from 2 to 6 ½ years. Asylum applicants who are seeking U.S. protection from persecution in their home countries may wait five or more years simply for an interview to assess their claim.

The backlog has arisen largely because of an increase in the number of Central American women and children seeking asylum. Many families without authorization are sent to detention centers to be held while they undergo expedited removal.

The expedited removal process was created to bypass the immigration court system and allow for the swift removal of undocumented immigrants. However, if those immigrants say they’re afraid to return home, the Department of Homeland Security must give them a “credible fear interview” to determine if they are eligible for asylum. These individuals can then take their cases to immigration court.

Asylum officers are sent to detention centers to conduct credible fear interviews. Approximately 85 to 90 percent of families interviewed are granted the right to present their case in immigration court.

Asking asylum seekers to present their cases before both asylum officers and judges is repetitive and time consuming. It would be more efficient to either allow asylum officers to grant asylum after a credible fear interview when they see a strong case, or simply bypass this step and allow all asylum seekers to present their cases in court.

publicidad

As of February 2017, there were only 527 asylum officers working in the nation’s eight asylum offices, even though the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services has authorized hiring as many as 625. The nonprofit Human Rights First estimates that 272 of those officers are needed just to conduct credible fear interviews.

Effects of the backlog

As I have detailed in my work, delays in processing immigrants cause hardships for asylum seekers.

While an asylum seeker is awaiting a decision in their case, they often face financial instability, difficulty finding employment and prolonged separation from immediate family members. Years of delay also make it more difficult for immigrants to find pro bono legal representation.

Meanwhile, the Department of Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly has cited the “historic backlogs” in immigration courts to justify increasing expedited removals.

There’s evidence that such expedited removals circumvent due process for asylum seekers. In some cases, U.S. border officials have even failed to properly implement safeguards to protect asylum seekers from being returned to harm or death. Recently, the U.S. government did not attend a hearing before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights regarding Customs and Border Patrol illegally turning asylum seekers away from our southern border.

The nonprofit Human Rights First estimates that the U.S. needs at least 524 judges working to address the immigration court backlog, in addition to more law clerks and administrative support.

publicidad

More asylum officers are also needed. Human Rights First estimates that with 800 asylum officers on the job, we could get rid of the backlog by 2022.

Solving the problem of our nation’s backlogged immigration courts should be a priority for any administration to ensure that the system functions in a timely and efficient manner.

Lindsay M. Harris, Assistant Professor of Law, University of the District of Columbia

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

publicidad
publicidad
Latino millennials account for almost half the 27.3 million eligible Latino voters in this election. But Latino turn out is traditionally far lower than black and Anglo voters. J.P. Dominguez asks “when are we going to wake up?”
A study by the Institute on Taxation and Economic policy found that undocumented immigrants pay $11.64 billion a year in state and local taxes. The undocumented pay on average 8% of their income on taxes while the wealthiest 1% pay only 5.4%. J.P Dominguez says that's "trumped up."
During the first presidential debate, the candidates took a chance to bring up each others past mistakes to affect their performance.
After the "Taco trucks on every corner" comment from the co-founder of Latinos for Trump, part of his immigration past emerged. This is JP Domínguez's take on the issue.
Donald Trump's wife and aspiring First Lady is an immigrant who says she always "went by the law" - but her story is a little 'SUS'.
¿Enamorada? Francisca Lachapel dedica 'Eclipse total de amor'
Con su particular y divertida forma de ser, Francisca cantó a grito herido la canción 'Eclipse total de amor', como una alusión al eclipse de sol que se presentó este lunes.
#DAEnUnMinuto: Orlando quiere cambiarse el nombre y a las hijas de Karla les dio pánico el eclipse
Además: Marco Antonio Regil casi se nos cae en vivo, Alan demostró que sigue teniendo un gran corazón de niño, y esta es la razón por la que Ana Patricia se perdió del eclipse. Síguenos en #DAEnUnMinuto.
Llega la cigüeña: ellas son las bellezas latinas que están a punto de dar a luz
Zoila Ceballos, Prissila Sánchez, Fabiola Barinas y Paulette Acosta comienzan la cuenta regresiva y están a punto de traer al mundo a sus hijos.
Alimentos para mejorar el desempeño escolar en este regreso a clases
Si quieres enriquecer el rendimiento académico de tus hijos, toma nota de los nutrientes que no deben faltar en su alimentación.
publicidad
Conductores de Uber y Lyft se unen para protestar y exigir mejores condiciones laborales
Los trabajadores de estas plataformas de transporte se dan cita en el Aeropuerto de Los Ángeles para hacer parte de una manifestación que ha afectado las operaciones en la terminal aérea. Los conductores aseguran que no tienen ningún respaldo y seguro a la hora de sufrir un accidente.
Grupos supremacistas planean manifestarse en la ciudad de San Francisco
El alcalde de San Francisco, Ed Lee, y otros líderes políticos de la ciudad manifestaron su rotunda oposición a este evento y realizó un llamado para que la comunidad no asista a este evento.
Video: Un ataque de tiburón a una foca hace correr a decenas de bañistas
Las imágenes muestran el momento del ataque y la enorme mancha de sangre que se formó en el agua. Ocurrió a escasos metros de la orilla en una playa de Massachussets.
Acusan de homicidio imprudente a conductor que causó la muerte de una mujer embarazada y sus 3 hijos
De acuerdo con las autoridades del Condado de Will en Illinois, el joven de 25 años conducía 20 millas por encima del límite de velocidad y no obedeció una señal de alto. Al acusado se le ha fijado una fianza de un millón dólares.
Este es el diseño del impresionante Al Thumama, el sexto estadio para el Mundial de Catar 2022
El Comité Organizador del Mundial catarí presentó un innovador diseño basado en el gorro kufi que utilizán los hombres en la cultura árabe.
José Manuel Abundis, sobre su hijo Martín: “No se tiene que preocupar por lo que yo hice”
El exjugador mexicano aseguró que su heredero futbolístico, el joven delantero del Toluca, debe hacer su propia historia. Y analizó cuáles son sus fortalezas y debilidades.
Francisco Silva, sobre el invicto de Cruz Azul: “Es una motivación y una responsabilidad”
El defensa chileno reconoció la dualidad que existe en toda racha sin derrotas, y deseó que puedan mantenerla el mayor tiempo posible. Además, el ‘Gato’ habló del duelo ante Necaxa.
Barcelona demanda a Neymar por incumplimiento de contrato
El club español reclama una cantidad cercana a los 8.5 millones de euros por no cumplir con lo acordado con el jugador brasileño.