publicidad
Human Rights Watch is holding a panel discussion in Miami on May 5, sponsored by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, on how digital storytelling techniques can improve reporting of humanitarian crises and international responses to them

Getting clicks or getting help? Digital storytelling of humanitarian emergencies

Getting clicks or getting help? Digital storytelling of humanitarian emergencies

Human Rights Watch turns to digital storytelling techniques in humanitarian campaigns to capture audiences – and donors

Human Rights Watch is holding a panel discussion in Miami on May 5, spon...
Human Rights Watch is holding a panel discussion in Miami on May 5, sponsored by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, on how digital storytelling techniques can improve reporting of humanitarian crises and international responses to them

By Pascal Fletcher*

In early 2014 in conflict-racked Central African Republic, Human Rights Watch emergencies director Peter Bouckaert and photographer Marcus Bleasdale encountered a group of detained Muslim Peuhl men and women in the town of Bossembele who were being threatened with execution by their Christian “anti-balaka” militia captors.

Bouckaert, who was Tweeting his experiences live, asked the commander of the French Operation Sangaris peacekeeping mission deployed in the former French colony to safely evacuate the Muslims. When the officer appeared to delay, Bouckaert backed up his request with insistent Tweets reminding that the clock was ticking on the fate of the detainees.

“The commander… cursed me and asked who the f*ck I thought I was to tell him what to do, but he ultimately went to save the Muslims,” Bouckaert said.

He gives other examples of how timely and immediate reporting on the ground via social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook probably helped to save lives in the Central African country, which was being torn apart by religious, political and social violence little understood and largely ignored in the wider world.

Bouchaert gives other examples of how timely and immediate reporting on...
Bouchaert gives other examples of how timely and immediate reporting on the ground via social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook probably helped to save lives

International charities and rights organizations, as well as United Nations agencies, are increasingly using such digital storytelling techniques in their campaigns to capture audiences – and donors – in an increasingly frantic and fast-moving world where attention span is short and often distracted, even bewildered, by saturation news coverage from multitudes of sources and platforms.

Bouckaert and Bleasdale helped produce for Human Rights Watch a compelling multi-media documentary on the 2013/2014 violence in CAR , The Unravelling, which seamlessly blends first-hand narrative, testimonies and explanation with video snippets and photographs to give the reader/viewer a close-up and immediate vision of the unfolding conflict and the death and suffering it is causing.

Last year, HRW used similarly intensive social media and multimedia tools to report Europe’s refugee crisis. “Our aim was to put a name and a face on that crisis, to explain to people why so many were fleeing Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan,” Bouckaert said.

“Change and Impact”

Human Rights Watch is holding a panel discussion in Miami on May 5, sponsored by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, on how digital storytelling techniques can improve reporting of humanitarian crises and international responses to them. Bouckaert and Bleasdale, who between them have spent years documenting human suffering and abuses in multiple conflict zones, will be explaining their experience in the CAR.

Andrea Holley, Strategic Director for the Human Rights Watch Film Festival, who will moderate the Miami event, said HRW’s decision to move into multi-faceted digital media reporting – using everything from Twitter and Facebook to Instagram and satellite imagery, was also a response to a fast-changing media environment that required new techniques to reach, and influence, mass audiences.

publicidad

“Human Rights Watch is about change and impact, and being effective. As the tools and landscape change, we are obliged to change. We will do what we have to do to talk to people,” Holley said.

This included the novelty of veteran investigators like Bouckaert and Bleasdale using first-person narrative, as they do in The Unravelling – a shift away from the traditional tone and style of rights organization reports that tend to rely heavily on compiled witness testimony and accumulated evidence.

“The first person testimony does capture people’s attention in a different way,” said Holley.

She added too that as international news organizations, challenged by technological changes and rising costs in a shifting world media market, cut back their overseas reporting, it was often left to groups like HRW to deliver first-hand reporting on “forgotten” crises, such as the one in Central African Republic.

More Clicks than Action?

Questions have been raised, however, about the effectiveness of online and social media campaigns, however slickly produced or compelling, in delivering real solutions to humanitarian emergencies.

Two examples from Africa in recent years – one focused on Joseph Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA), a predatory and vicious guerrilla group that preyed on children in Uganda and surrounding countries, and the other on a group of schoolgirls from Chibok in northeast Nigeria abducted in 2014 by violent Boko Haram Islamist militants – drew allegations from critics of narcissistic “clicktivism” and “slacktivism” divorced from the realties they were supposed to be changing.

publicidad

Promoters and supporters of the “Kony 2012” film, which went viral online at the time, and the #BringBackOurGirls Twitter campaign were widely accused of being more interested in gaining publicity for themselves than for the victims in Africa they were intended to help.

“You don’t get the decisive action, because the purpose is so often: ‘look at me, look at the size of my concern’,” says author and journalist Alex Perry, who worked for 15 years in Asia and Africa as a correspondent for TIME, Newsweek and other publications. His 2015 book on his Africa reporting, The Rift, includes a critical view of the motives and effectiveness of what Perry calls celebrity “superstar advocacy” and “humanitarians’ licence to honour themselves” in conflict-torn, impoverished countries.

Despite the social media frenzy generated by the #BringBackOurGirls and “Kony 2012” campaigns, which sucked in armies of celebrities and prompted public promises of help from Western powers, they seem to have failed so far in their ultimate objectives. Most of the Chibok girls remain missing in the northeast Nigerian forest and scrubland where Boko Haram still roam and kill, and LRA chief Joseph Kony is still on the run in the jungles of Central Africa despite U.S. President Barack Obama’s dispatch of elite U.S. Special Forces to try to track him down, apparently prompted by the “Kony 2012” campaign.

Questions over social media campaigning form part of a wider and seemingly growing spirit of introspection in the global humanitarian movement, with many asking whether donor funds are being fully and effectively used by an increasingly sophisticated industry that sometimes seems to be serving itself more than those it purports to serve. “I think there is something wrong with our idea of charity, compassion. Over time, it’s become about us, rather than the people we are helping,” says Perry.

publicidad

HRW’s Bouckaert, however, passionately believes the reporting he and Bleasdale did from CAR had a real impact, something that Perry acknowledges. Bouckaert said he was “personally pretty allergic to ‘feel good’ social media activism … (that) … is all too often a convenient substitute for more meaningful – and difficult – forms of activism.”

Clicks and hits online are ultimately no substitute for timely, decisive humanitarian action by governments and institutions, well-coordinated and funded and reinforced by continued oversight.

But getting the story out fast and vividly can certainly help. “At the center of all of it is what should remain at the core of all good investigative reporting, whether we talk about journalism or human rights investigations: boots on the ground, with a notebook in hand and a darn good photographer as a partner,” Bouckaert said.

“I’m not the kind of idealist that thinks we can change the world overnight. But I’m pretty convinced that our work in CAR—in solidarity with many others equally devoted—helped prevent a much greater tragedy there,” Bouckaert added, calling the CAR conflict perhaps the closest Africa has come to genocide since the ethnic massacres in Rwanda in 1994.

* Pascal Fletcher is an award-winning journalist and former Reuters Africa editor. He also served as Reuters bureau chief in Cuba, Venezuela and Miami.

publicidad
publicidad
A climate of fear around Trump's immigration policies has lead many parents in Immokalee, Florida, to prepare for the worst: deportation. Many are making plans for their children, in the case that they're left alone in the United States, such as coordinating a legal guardian. Others are processing passports for their children, so that the entire family can leave the country in the event of a deportation.
As the legend goes, a UFO landed in Capilla del Monte in 1986, leaving a mark on the side of the Pajarillo mountains. Since then, this Argentinian village has lived off UFO tourism. It's currently hosting its annual Alien Festival.
The young White House adviser who is one of the president's preferred spokesmen once ran for election at his California high school. His stump speech was found racially offensive by many students as you can see in this video obtained exclusively by Univision. He was escorted off the stage by high school staff.
Twelve percent of annual U.S. demand for avocados — or about 100,000 tons — will be consumed in the days before and after the Super Bowl. Mexican producers say that Trump's threats would only mean higher prices for U.S. consumers.
A day after Trump's inauguration, the U.S. capital was filled by hundreds of thousands of protesters who stole some of the limelight from the newly sworn-in president.
Obama’s inaugural poet, Richard Blanco, reflects on last week’s dramatic shift in U.S. policy towards Cuban immigrants, as well as Donald Trump and democracy.
The announcement to scrap the benefits came as a bucket of cold water for the Cuban migrants who just arrived in the United States. As this group waits for their papers, the uncertainty grows on whether they will ever be reunited with the relatives they left on the island.
A group of Argentines diagnosed with mental illness set up a radio station from where they broadcast their experiences
This is the story of how land along the frontier between the U.S. and Mexico passed through Spanish and Mexican hands before becoming part of the United States. In those days there was no wall.
Ramón, who is from Mexico, has worked over the last six years to cross immigrants across the U.S.-Mexico border. He shares with us how he does it, the price he must pay to the cartels and the dangers of the journey.
A simple wall is not going to fix the problems on the U.S-Mexico border. The flow of undocumented immigrants arriving to the U.S. is ceaseless, a 2,000-mile border wall is not viable and investment in the Border Patrol has already increased threefold over the last decade. Univision took a trip along the border to examine the complexities.
In the dairy industry in Wisconsin, at the heart of the Rust Belt where Donald Trump won by a landslide, more than half of the workers are immigrants and most of them are undocumented. No American citizen wants to do the hard work they do.
How Fidel Castro's plan to save Cuban baseball unraveled. The once mighty amateur baseball champions have lost much of their talent in recent years to U.S. Major League Baseball. Now the Cuban government is in discussions with MLB to stop the desertions. But will a Trump presidency make that more difficult?
Julian Rodriguez managed to place his 86-year-old grandmother back in the streets of her childhood home through virtual reality technology.
The funeral events commenced this morning in Havana in the aftermath of Fidel Castro's death. Cuba will be in mourning until Sunday, December 4.
Cuban revolutionary leader Fidel Castro spoke to journalists Barbara Walters in 1977, and Diane Sawyer in 1993, about the differences between Cuba and the United States.
Echa a volar tu imaginación: Ideas para decorar el cuarto de los niños
Nada puede inspirar más a los papás que el poder darle vida a ese lugar en el cual los más pequeños de la casa se sientan felices para jugar y tener dulces sueños. Aquí te damos algunas ideas.
'El Bueno, La Mala y El Feo' llegaron a Premio Lo Nuestro con todo y gallina
Los locutores desfilaron por la alfombra magenta de Noche de Estrellas acompañados de Carlitos 'El Productor'.
Mira como reaccionó el esposo de Lili Estefan cuando vio nuestras cámaras
Todos sabemos que el esposo de Lili no es muy dado con las cámaras y mira todo el trabajo que costó sacarle dos pablaras.
Aquí y Ahora – 19 de febrero, 2017 Accede
Las redadas de los últimos días han hecho que el miedo tome muchos vecindarios del país. Las historias de quienes han sido deportados. ¿Qué hacer si agentes del ICE tocan a su puerta?.
publicidad
Congresista se reúne con líderes comunitarios buscando soluciones para los inmigrantes
Los líderes se reunieron con la congresista demócrata Nancy Pelosi y discutieron las inquietudes de la comunidad inmigrante.
No habrá cargos, por ahora, contra el oficial que disparó en medio de un forcejeo con jóvenes en Anaheim
Así lo aseguró el jefe de la policía, quien además prometió dar respuestas cuando se tenga la investigación adecuada. El hecho provocó manifestaciones por parte de la comunidad e inclusive fueron detenidas cuatro personas.
Google demanda a Uber por robo de tecnología de manejo autónomo
La demanda también nombra a Anthony Lewandowski antiguo empleado de Google quien presuntamente descargó 14,000 archivos confidenciales propiedad de Google en un disco duro antes de dejar la compañía.
Autoridades de Santa Cruz piden perdón a la comunidad inmigrante por detenciones
Las autoridades dijeron que efectuaron detenciones innecesarias porque agencias federales aseguraron que eran pandilleros.
La 'química' de los Warriors los convierten en un equipo letal
A Durant y Curry les encanta observar cómo el otro hace maravillas con el balón, por algo son el conjunto con el mejor récord en la NBA (47-9).
Dallas y Arizona se enfrentarán en el partido del Salón de la Fama
Los Cowboys de Jerry Jones y los Cardinals de Kurt Warner se verán las caras en el juego que abre oficialmente la temporada 2017.
Goooolll!! Kellyn Acosta mete el balón y marca para FC Dallas
Goooolll!! Kellyn Acosta mete el balón y marca para FC Dallas on February 23, 2017
Uyy!! Cristian Colmán dispara y para el portero
Uyy!! Cristian Colmán dispara y para el portero on February 23, 2017